Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

Posts

Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#1

Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

Barry Irby

I see systems advertised that puts an ultra violet light in your ducts and it is supposed to kill mold and germs. I occasionally see these in people's systems during home inspections. I am skeptical. I doubt that flying a germ or virus or mold spore past a UV light at the speed air moves in ducts will damage let alone kill the harmful stuff. I tried looking this up and got nothing I could understand. Does anyone have any information that actually supports this use of UV at a creditable level or that reduces it to snake oil? I am on the snake oil side right now but would like to believe. Mostly just hate a rip off.

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#2

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct questio *LINK*

mdclor

Barry,

According to the link, it works in water and the article states that it works better in air than in water. As you mention, the flow rate needs to be considered, but it should be work if designed properly. I know that UV systems work to purify lake water.

HTH,

Merle


http://www.harvesth2o.com/uv.shtml

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#3

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct questio

John McGaw

UV is also used in aquariums for sensitive species. Water is extracted from the tank and passed through a coaxial tube which has a high-intensity UV lamp in the center and then placed back into the tank. Since the necessary (good) microorganisms live in the tank substrate and filtration beds only free-floating parasites are affected.

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#5

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct questio

John Veerkamp

While UV is used in many industrial and specialty applications, I think it is snake oil for home duct use.

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#6

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct questio

Dan arrowsmith

They are used in corn syrup storage tanks to kill yeasts and molds. The bulbs need to be replaced yearly.

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#7

What's the objective?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I pose that question in a general way, and not to question why you're investigating this device ...

Is someone in the home suffering symptoms and needs purify the air? Or does this fall in the realm of "because I can?"

It seems that this will only treat air that goes through the HVAC system. I wonder (and I don't know the answer to this) how much of the air in a house circulates from room to room without going through the HVAC ducts? (Judging from the poor performance of a dust collector at filtering room air, aside from its designed purpose of collecting debris at the source machine, I'd guess that a small portion of the air in a house goes through the duct work. Not to mention the number of air exchanges a house experiences each hour/day.) This would diminish the overall effectiveness of the system.

(I realize that in Virginia when you're not running the heater you're probably running the a/c. That's what we did in Fairfax. But here in Colorado Springs, when I'm not running the heater, the windows are usually open.)

This forum sure covers a wide variety of topics. Lots to learn here.

Cheers

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#8

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct questio

Jim Dillon

Barry,

I investigated this a few years ago before we installed AC. There is actually quite a bit of research available on this topic. Try searching in PubMed using the search words "ultraviolet disinfection of air" or something close. IIRC, what I concluded (right or wrongly) was that UVAC reduced the level of airborne contaminates by reducing (or preventing) the growth of contaminates at the source, i.e. the coils, drain pan etc. This is why most providers of this equipment (Honeywell, Aprilaire, Ultravation, Sterilaire) recommend that the bulbs be located adjacent to the coils, and not somewhere else in the duct system - because of the air-flow problem others mentioned. The only downside that I can recall (other than expense) is that the plastic on any exposed wires may deteriorate with time, and that the bulbs must be changed at one, two or three year intervals depending on how you are using the system. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#9

Ditto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I asked my HVAC guy about this and I got a similar answer. The lights are meant to disinfect the AC "A" coils in the furnace plenum. They don't (I was told) sterilize the air, but rather prevent or reduce the growth of mold and bacteria on the wet piping and condensate pan. Units run about $100 each although my guy mentioned that, in his opinion, you would need two units per plenum to properly "irradiate" all of the surfaces.

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#10

Thanks, I think.....

Barry Irby

the idea of irradiating the coils is a good idea. The air not so much. I am still skeptical that flying stuff past the bulb at the rate it moves in ducts would do any good. Also that it would only "see" the part that actually went through the system. Unlike chlorinating water where there is residual benefit and the chlorine would spread through the liquid The air coming out of the ducts would have no beneficial effect on the surrounding air. In the case of water, all of the output is treated and not mixed back with untreated water.

Now I am wondering if you could treat a crawl space with the light? How long would it have to sit in place and how far could you move it? What about a Roomba type robot to move it around? Never mind, lost my mind again.

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#11

There you go again, Barry...

Stuart Hough

coming up with new ideas for a marketable product :)

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#12

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I was also told that since the bulbs have a limited lifespan based upon actual usage, the install "should" have an hour meter in the circuit to more accurately determine when to replace them.

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#13

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct questio

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

Hey Barry--Does the spearmint lose it's flavor on the bedpost overnite?

Re: Another OT: Ultra Violet light In duct question

#14

Kinda funny story rg UVC lights

Jim Dillon

Mark,

After my research, I couldn't resist getting a UVC light. During the installation of the air handler, the junior member (third day on the job) couldn't resist plugging the light in, despite all sorts of stickers on the power supply warning not to look at the light while it was on. Well, "junior" ended up in the hospital with retinal burns, plus a week off from work. He was lucky as there was no long-term damage, not that anyone would notice. And, no, the junior member wasn't me - not this time ;) !

Jim

Regarding the bulb life, what I have read regarding the use life sorta depends on what one is expecting the bulb to do. If one expects that it will kill off airborne contaminates in the duct, then the bulb should be changed every year. If one is solely using it to kill stuff on the coils, two years is the limit. Supposedly, three years is the absolute max.