Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

I was talking to a friend yesterday and he mentioned ruefully that yet another woodworking program in a local middle school was being phased out. This is a decline that's been going on probably since I took seventh-grade woodshop fifty years ago, but it still resonates with a lot of us. This month, I'd like to hear about your recollections of your high-school or junior-high woodshop days. How did shop class impact your life, if at all? Did it set you on a course for a lifetime interest in woodworking? Do you have any anecdotes about those days that you'd like to share with us? Do you think that the demise of woodshop education bodes ill for our society?

As usual, we'll slice, dice and pureé your replies and serve them up in our next column in Woodworker West magazine. Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host


Woodworker West Magazine

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#2

Ahhhh yes, "WoodShop"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The blessed break (3 times a week) from Algebra, English Comp, or Latin where we started to learn something that held some glimmer of hope we'd be able to actually use in our lives. And the story goes . .

"Mom, I signed up for wood shop for my elective this semester."

"Great, Dear. You can make me something that I need for the car."

[Mom, at the time, was a traveling trouble shooter for the state chapter AFL-CIO]

"What's that, Mom"

"I need a kind of durable filing box with moveable partitions that I can put in the trunk to keep my files and papers separate and organized when I have to drive to different locals."

"How big would that need to be?"

"Well, it would have to hold folders that are up to 10" by 15""

"How big the other way"

"Oh, say big enough for a cat's coffin"

Mom got her mobile file cabinet, made from 1/2" ply and 1x1 corner molding and a fitted lid, stained to dark walnut with a coat of some finish (she later got a set of bookcases) and the 13x16x24" box was officially named the "Cat's Coffin". That was 1963. Mom passed in 1995. She was still using the bookcases.

On opening her storage unit, what do we find? There, none-the-worse-for-wear after 30+ years and many thousands of miles in the trunks of several cars, was the Cat's Coffin, the partitions now holding files of photos and mementos of my childhood.

Now, in 2012, the Cat's Coffin sits behind my desk, just as Mom kept it. Who knows how far down the Family Tree this first wood shop project will travel?

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#3

Worthless

Bill Tindall

Can't remember the grade but we made some useless trinket from pine. I remember liking the smell of shellac. It didn't motivate me to do woodworking nor teach me anything useful that I can recall.

Much later when I was just married I needed a couch and end table and lamp. A friend had made something similar that would suffice. I borrowed use of a table saw and whacked out the plywood pieces and wife sewed the "upholstery" for the couch. These crude pieces are still in service having been handed down to children and moved about the country.

That experience demonstrated that I could make serviceable furniture. I signed up for an adult ed evening class and made a stereo cabinet and coffee table, again still in service. It has been this way ever since. When we needed/wanted something I learned to make it.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

Moses Yoder

Q #1) How did shop class impact your life, if at all?

Middle schoole (6-8) and high school (9-12) wood shop classes did something for me which was sadly lacking at home. They taught me self esteem. My first rewards were in 7th grade, my shop teacher had us build a checkerboard. My checker board turned out better than any of the others because I was very careful in glueing it together to make the lines match up. The teacher commented about it, and it made me feel good. It was my first indication that putting effort into something would bring rewards. I was not allowed to play school sports, which is where the average kid learns this, so wood shop maybe was a substitute for me. These lessons will last a lifetime.

Q #2) Did it set you on a course for a lifetime interest in woodworking?

The short answer is yes. My dad discouraged us from going to college, so I went to work after high school. I knew from my school experience that I enjoyed woodworking. I did not care that much for sanding and did not think I would like working in a commercial shop but I began and enjoyed it. I knew I would be good at it based on my experience in school. I worked for a kitchen cabinet refacing company and they let me use the tools to build personal projects, so the hobby was reinforced. I now have my own hobby shop. I am currently working for a high end kitchen cabinet company where we do a number of whole house projects every year that wander upwards of $100,000 in cabinetry. Currently the only machine I run is a computer, doing drawings and specifications for cabinetry, and my experience and knowledge of woodworking is invaluable for that.

Q #3) Do you have any anecdotes about those days that you'd like to share with us?

I remember building a large tackle box in 9th grade, first year high school shop class, with multiple fold out trays at the top and a gambrel roof top. It was all built of poplar because that was the cheapest wood. Years later I gave that box to a neighbor due to space constraints, now I wish I still had it. So that is my anecdote; don't throw anything away.

Q #4) Do you think that the demise of woodshop education bodes ill for our society?

Societies change and there is nothing that can be done about it. All of our manufacturing jobs are currently in China or on their way there. What we need for classes now in high school is one where a spatula is put in the students hand and they are taught to deftly flip it. This would be a useful trade, and teach the same lessons in self esteem that I received.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

steve mackay

No offense to any present but, at our high school "shop" was for the guys who really didn't want to be at school in the first place. I see you didn't mention them but my "wood thing" started with Pinewood Derby. I learned, possibly, the most important thing I know about goofing with wood. "You can always sand/cut off more, but you can't put it back on." My love continued with hundreds of projects in Boy Scouts including construction, renovation and traditional woodworking (working at camp you learned that if YOU didn't do it, it probably wasn't going to get fixed.). Today I blame my money maker on Wood Carving Merit Badge. Folks tend to dismiss Scouting as kids just having fun (Oh, we DID !) but seeds planted in youth . . . yadda, yadda.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#6

Re: Ahhhh yes, "WoodShop"

Carol

Priceless, Mark. Care to share a picture?

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#7

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Today folks are beginning to think that maybe a 4 year college degree (or higher)is not a golden ticket to a job. Our society seems to have placed a lot of emphasis on college being the only path to success and foresaked vocational training. Turn the clocks ahead to today and folks aren't so dismissive of vocational education.

I think woodshop can have a place in education. However, there is not a huge demand for furniture makers. I would suggest that woodshop be broadened to include education in various areas of carpentry, building trades and related areas where tools are used. Some day (hopefully) the housing and construction industry will rebound. Folks with with woodworking and related skillsets will be needed.

T.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#8

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

Carol

Woodshop was the place in school where girls were not allowed. Was steered to HomeEc instead. Undeterred, I moved on and today have a shop most guys would drool on their shirt fronts for. But I was miffed and am glad to see that sexist attitude has changed, even as woodshops are disappearing. As for the self-esteem component, that is no less important today and we will have to find other ways to fulfill that for so many whose hearts have been wounded by others.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#9

I taught for 31 years

McKay

I often felt guilty being paid for having so much fun. The last few years I had an average of 20-25% female in the classes. Bill's experience was unfortunate, because when you walked into my classes you were expected to build either a Hadley styled cedar chest or a base cabinet (night stand). Both projects had mortice-tenon, biscuit, screw pocket, dowel joints and drawers w/dovetails. My concern was NOT to make them furniture or cabinetmakers. My concern was to get them to be more productive in whatever they chose to do for a career and to turn off the wretched tv (or now the iphone/ipod). In this state (Utah), the students usually have a chance to take the construction class that includes flatwork, electrical, tile, wall board, etc. The woodworking classes in the high schools are generally very intensive.

I have never discouraged anyone from going to college because I have an advanced degree and I have certainly enjoyed the benefits of that advanced degree. I explain it this way: "If there is a major earthquake, does anyone care that you have a degree in English Lit? Or, do they want shelter"

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#10

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

David C. Lykins

How did shop class impact your life, if at all? All through High School I took Industrial classes, Electronics, Mechanics, Drafting and Metals. Ironically, though it was offered I don't remember Wood Working being part of the curriculum I had to take and never took it in High School. At this point I truly believe it might have changed my life completely, due to my love of wood working and a "creative" side of me I didn't realize I had. But who knows? Right around my Senior year in HS I built my own guitar amp head from a kit for my electronics class, and of course I wanted a matching cabinets for the head and the speaker. So my father and I built both and they looked like they came out of Fender's factory. I believe the ONLY power tools we used was a hand drill and skill saw. Everything else was planed by hand with my great grandfathers wood working tools my father had inherited and now I have them. I'd give ANYTHING to have that 2x12 speaker cabinet back. Like an idiot I traded it many, many years ago.

Did it set you on a course for a lifetime interest in woodworking? Unfortunately "NO", it didn't as I never took Wood Working in HS.

Do you have any anecdotes about those days that you'd like to share with us? I didn't get interesting in wood working until I built my first guitar in the mid 90s from parts that I ordered or purchased locally. After the building the second guitar from parts I had this burning desire to build a guitar from scratch. So I sold some guitar and amps and purchased my wood working tools and the rest is history.

Do you think that the demise of wood-shop education bodes ill for our society? I believe the demise of ANY kind of shop type education is bad for our society and students. Because I took many shop classes in High School it has educated me on the workings of things we use everyday and has motivated me to keep learning about things that are either electrical, mechanical, structural etc., and it has opened opportunities to enjoy such wonderful hobbies such as wood working and flying RC aircraft. YES, we definitely need to keep shop in our school rooms. I feel that if we don't keep offering shop classes, we'll become an "Information ONLY" society and we'll stop producing engineers, mechanics, electricians, and many, many other technical workers our society desperately needs. My BIGGEST REGRETS are NOT getting my Mechanical Engineering degree, and NOT getting into Wood Working earlier.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#11

No influence whatsoever

paul in AZ

In my school woodshop was regarded as a placeholder for kids who didn't want to be in school and for troublemakers. I briefly tried it as a diversion from college entrance track. No memory of having made anything or learning anything.

It wasn't till years later that I began messing with wood by buying some plans, a used radial arm saw, and making an 8 by 12 foot garden storage shed as my first wood project.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#12

The Cat's Coffin

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey


Yeah, I should dust it, but it has a certain 'patina' that shouldn't be disturbed lest some antique dealer in the far future would attempt to devalue it because of ham-handed restoration. :D :D

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#13

JL

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

JL

Electric shop in 8th grade and metal shop in 10th. They did have some influence. I did learn a bit about metals and electricity.

Carpentry (as opposed to woodworking) - I learned from my stepfather. He was a master carpenter (construction type). I learned to cut a stair stringer, frame an addition or wall, etc.

I think shop should be taught - if anything to counteract the erroneous information from the big box stores.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#14

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Yes, I took my woodworking shop class in around 1957 - 58 as a junior in High school. Although my father was gifted in many crafts including woodworking, I was unable to learn from him as he passed on when I was around 10 years old. Our shop teacher, Mr Harmenson (yes I remember his name after 50+ years), dedicated the first week or so to teaching us both accuracy and patience. He gave each of us a rough block of wood, a square and a plane. Our first task was to square up and smooth the block in all dimensions. Some ended up about half size but really SQUARE. In that class I built a Eastern Red Cedar bookcase. It remained with my mother until she passed on - then my youngest son took possession. He has told me many times how he values that unit. I really regret the demise of the shop type courses and believe it to be a tremendous error on the part of the school boards and public. I do see the value of sports - but how often is any of that training used in the students future either for economic gain or as training that enables them to repair or upgrade their home or even build a doghouse? I took many subjects including all the shop classes offered in my school, including welding and woodworking. Although I was admitted to Purdue, I could not attend due to financial reasons. I did eventually take a few classed at other schools and was hired as a Engineering tech, within about a year I was promoted to Engineer and spent about 40 years in that field - I believe the training in shop classes contributed greatly to my success. I also had a contracting / sub-contracting business for 20 -30 years which enabled me to raise 6 children and retire in reasonable comfort again partially due to earlier training. The shop classes certainly help train our next generation of Electricians, Plumbers, carpenters, woodworkers and contractors. Each of these are pretty darn good careers with fairly high pay and are certainly more stable jobs than the stockbrokers and politicians with advanced degrees have.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#15

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I only experienced woodshop in 6th (5th & 6th?) grade. We moved before I started 7th grade, but that brief exposure made a big difference in my interest in and enjoyment of woodworking.

Despite being a middle school shop, it was fully equipped. Mr. H, an experienced teacher and woodworker, was in charge. In addition to shop, he taught 7th & 8th grade Science and built custom cabinets and kitchens for the locals, during the summers.

My dad, like my grandfather, did a lot of building and was always working on our house. My brother, three years my senior, and I often helped, so I was exposed to woodworking and tools at a young age. Most often I was the "gofer." We would also play around with my dad's tools in his basement shop. As a result, when I started woodshop in school, I had more woodworking knowledge and experience than most of my classmates, most of whom had none.

I remember my brother bringing home some nice projects he built in woodshop. Evidently he established a reputation as a good woodworker with the shop teacher. I don't know if they ever worked together, but the shop teacher knew my dad, also.

After a shop tour and required safety instructions, Mr. H. taught us how to enlarge a pattern, how to prepare wood, and how to use all the tools necessary for our first project, a simple napkin holder. It consisted of two butterfly shaped ends connected by two dowels. Before we started cutting out the butterflies the shop teacher showed us how to hold and use a coping saw. His final instructions were to cut well away from the lines because he knew the cuts made with our little, inexperienced 6th grand hands would not be straight. He said we would file and sand to final shape later. Well, I had been there, done that! Filing and sanding were not my favorites. Since I had experience with a coping saw and already broken my share of blades in my dad's shop, I proceeded to cut close to the line, barely a 1/16" or so.

After I had cut only a few inches the shop teacher who was making his rounds got to me. He took a quick look and said, "I thought I told everyone to stay well back from the lines. Your gonna have trouble if you don't!!" Then he took a closer look at what I had done and seemed a bit surprised. He hadn't learned the student's names yet, so asked for mine. His response surprised me when I meekly offered my name, "Oh, you're one of the Schaffter boys." He said nothing more, but even as a 6th grader I could tell what he meant and what he expected from me from then on. After that, I tried to build everything to the best of my ability- gotta uphold the family name, you know!! His one remark and reaction have stayed with me.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#16

Addendum

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I seem to recall some classes in school that required little brain power. I suspect as much is still true. I was never too keen on math in school but I discovered that once I took up woodworking I found myself using it all the time. The point is that woodworking is a great way to use the mind and learn. Woodworking has a sneaky way of making us use our brains for problem solving, geometry, physics etc. And, if you get a coffee table out of it then that's icing on the cake!

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#17

I do not think much of an influence

Dave Paine

Ellis. Good topic. Happy you are volunteering to do the "distillation". :D

Overall I feel having woodwork class did not influence me, but I think it is a valuable aspect of learning / education to create something. Too few people these days attempt to create. My friends look at my projects and claim they do not have the skills. In some cases I think due to a lack of ever trying.

These days we do not have local craftsmen. Far too much is mass produced, and from other countries.

There are many classes I have taken in school or university which become part of my learning, even though I may not have used the knowledge in earnest.

How did shop class impact your life, if at all? Did it set you on a course for a lifetime interest in woodworking?

I would say no. My interest in woodworking was mostly dormant until the 90's.

Do you have any anecdotes about those days that you'd like to share with us?

I lived in the UK for high school and university. I expect the high school curriculum is very different than it was for me in the 60's.

Between ages 12 and 16 if I recall the curriculum was mostly fixed. Around 14 or 15 we did have some elections, since we started to prepare for "O" levels.

In the earlier years we had a class in woodworking and a class in metal working. I did not pursue either of these for the "O" levels.

My main recollection of the woodworking class was making a box for pencils. I had to plane the wood sides to be straight and orthogonal. The straight was not a problem, but to this day I struggle to make the edge orthogonal. Hence this was a negative for me.

By the way, one of the woodwork teachers had lost a few digits from his right hand in a table saw accident. This teacher taught woodwork class and mathematics.

At home we did not have much room for a workshop or much in the way of tools. My father was a welder, so more metal related work in the home.

In the University years, I recall making a sewing box with trays which pivoted from the centre for my then girlfriend despite the sparse tools.

In one of my summer jobs while at University I broke a plastic switch on an electrical lift. I thought I would be in trouble, so I made a wooden replacement, chiselled out the centre. The foreman was most impressed, mostly since I replaced the switch without the need to call in an electrician.

Fast forward to the 80's. Got married and bought my present house in 1983. I did a lot of wood related work in building an extension, various remodelling within the house. I purchased a radial arm saw, electrical hand planer, circular saw. Not much in the way of hand tools, other than hammer, etc. for framing.

In the 90's I had my nephews visit. They were around 10-12. The younger one wanted to "build something for my mom". So we built my first cutting board using white oak. The board is still in use.

Around 2000 I got the urge to own a hand plane. I went into the Woodworkers Warehouse store and said "I want to buy a hand plane, what do you recommend?". The person was honest and replied he did not know much about hand planes so could not make a recommendation. I bought a Record jack plane. Last year I replaced the blade with a Hock blade. A major difference.

I found a local lumber yard which had rough sawn lumber, and purchased my first portable planer.

In 2005 I purchased my first table saw. This was a big step forward in my ability to cut accurately compared to the old RAS.

I gradually started to build wood items. Mostly cutting boards, trivets, a couple of chess boards. The last chess board was when my 18 year old nephew visited. Another case where he wanted to build something. I observed he had a fear of failure, and would not do certain steps "I will mess it up". I think his UK education system and parents were partially responsible.

Over the years I have accumulated more hand tools, mostly planes, spokeshaves, one cross cut saw. I now appreciate that sometimes a hand tool is either a pleasure to use, or easier than a power tool.

Do you think that the demise of woodshop education bodes ill for our society?



Yes. We take too much for granted. I heard a co-worker mention that his daughter stated "Don't we have people for that" a reference to having someone do the work instead of herself.

I think the demise of woodshop reflects a demise of "the trades" as a way of earning a living.

Today's generation assumes everything is available in a big box store. Places like Ikea is where people buy furniture.

When people find out I am a woodworker, they are surprised, which reflects my feeling that the trades and crafts are at risk of becoming lost arts.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#18

Discrimination!

Jerry Nicholson

I was ticked off the same way because boys weren't allowed to take typing in the ninth grade (more than 60 years ago). It was probably the most useful course I took in high school.

Jerry

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#19

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

Jerry Nicholson

I took woodworking in the ninth grade, more than 60 years ago. I started doing woodworking projects, mostly plywood with edging, more than 50 years ago but I am not sure that the woodworking class had very much to do with it. Woodworking class did inspire me to give my dad a Stanly 51 spokeshave and a Miller-Falls router plane for Christmas that year. I don't think my dad ever used the router plane and I still have both of those tools although I much prefer to use the Lee Valley versions. I must have learned enough about planing and scraping at the time because I built myself a large drawing board. I still have it too - we set the Christmas tree on it every year!

I still remember the teacher, Mr Tedlock. He had a pug nose and cauliflower ears from his boxing days. He also had a razor strap for those occasions when the school's trouble makers weren't adequately convinced to mend their ways after the sheet metal teacher, Mr Schmidt, forcefully and enthusiastically applied orange crate slats to their gluteus maximus regions. Most of those troublemakers weren't overly eager to attend an attitude adjustment session with Mr. Tedlock! Things were different 60+ years ago!

Jerry

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#20

Re: Discrimination!

paul in AZ

My experience was the opposite. In 10th grade, touch typing was a required course for the college entrance tack. The boys thought that was a joke but I did get to >60 error-free words a minute.

Even before computers typing skill was handy but now.... !!

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#21

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY - 2

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When I taught school (70's) my system had bowed to the prevailing winds and sent most (but not all) of its "trade" courses to the county Vo-Tech [vocational-technical] school.

My own kids never got the chance to take a "shop" class because there were none offered; the shops had long since been converted to core-subject classrooms. I therefore had to take over what used to be the schools' job, teaching my kids which way to turn a screw to get it to hold something.

This country was founded by a bunch of self-reliant farmers [no, George didn't make his own wooden teeth!] and the ethic of personal responsibility and sweat equity built the U.S. into the position it held on the world stage. It has been imitated, but never equaled, as our Fathers, Grandmothers, and ancestors were intimately engaged and invested in their society and culture.

There has since been created a disconnect between Americans and their environment. Terms like "globalization" and "macro-economic monetization" are floated before our eyes to justify a culture of consumerism and the loss of the D.I.Y. ethos that built this country into the greatest economic engine and egalitarian society the planet has ever known. We have since been sold a bill of goods to cast aside self reliance in favor of dependency on others. Why? Clearly so we can be milked for the treasure created by our forefathers.

The people on this web forum have turned aside from the New Norm [NOT him] and committed to maintain, to larger and lesser degree, the mindset that made our country strong. This is NOT a political point of view, but rather a personal one. Liberal or conservative, Dem or Repub, are all irrelevant here. It is the "hands-on" quality of the American Culture that has created what we have today. The loss, perhaps the misguided discarding, of teaching self-reliance to our children through courses like shop and trades training, will, I suspect, ultimately result in a dilution of the American ethic and an irreplaceable loss of the abilities that enabled the United States to become the shining example of hope and opportunity to the rest of the damn planet that it is.

So, Ellis, does that answer your question?

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#22

Kneale Brownson

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY***

Kneale Brownson

I never took any sort of shop class in my school days. I have friends who probably avoided prison time because of their experiences in either wood or metal shop in my high school.

I had no interest in any of that stuff: I was going to be a surgeon. Closest to that I got was a few carvings of Easter Island-style heads I made while whittling away through college, where a semester of physics and organic chemistry redirected me.

My woodworking began with the addition started on our house when the builder presented me with a "midway" bill far exceeding his total project estimate. I learned to tape and mud the drywall that was hung then, make trim from the leftovers from the exterior materials, solder shut-offs on plumbing stubouts, build a lav, etc., and got hooked. I became an ultimate DIY guy, learning to weld, operate all kinds of equipment and fix all sorts of things. We got into rental properties, I dug basements, installed septic systems, swept parking lots, etc. I had a night job at a mental institution so I could teach skiing during winter days. I've learned to do whatever I can do because I learned to read and research things. I've done what I've done "with my hands" because that stuff was almost as much fun as skiing. I know you couldn't have dragged me into a shop class in high school. I'm pretty sure it would not have changed the course my life has taken over the nearly 60 years since. I think schools have to emphasize book-learning, but I also think there's a place for craftsmanship.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#23

Got thrown out after the first week.

Ray - Middletown, in

First day in the instructor gave us the assignments for the semester and defined the time line for finishing the projects. We had 3 hours of pattern-making a day that year which was the norm for that time. We had our choice of pattern-making, machining, auto body, auto repair, drafting, electricity, and probably a couple of other I have forgotten about. Well that first day I raised my hand and asked if it would be ok to do some of the work at home and he answered "If you think you can, go ahead". The following Monday I turned in all of the projects for the semester and promptly got thrown out of class. He was sure my dad or someone else had done all the work, unbeknownst to him I had grown up in a pattern shop. My dad was a toolmaker by day and patternmaker by night and I had gone to the shop with him since I was old enough to walk. Over the years the patternmakers had shown me one thing and another and by the time I got to patternmaking class I have been making simple patterns for quite a while. The Dean of boys called the shop to get confirmation and I had to go get a letter from him to take back to the shop teacher before I was allowed back in. For being such a smarta## he made up a whole new list of patterns for me to complete during the semester. Unbeknownst to me he was originally a patternmaker by trade and he proceeded to give me some of the gnarliest stuff I had ever seen. I probably learned more that semester than I had in all the years previous after our relationship was repaired.

I'm not sure that shop belongs in school any more. I was part of a group of working people back during the 90's to act as an advisory committee to guide the local high schools. Extremely frustrating on many levels and I finally came to the conclusion that public high school is not the place for shop any more. At least in my area, I hope others find a different atmosphere.

Ray

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#24

Moses Yoder

Re: Got thrown out after the first week.

Moses Yoder

Ray, if you have time I would be intersted in hearing some of the reasons why you found advising high schools extremely frustrating and don't think shop classes should be taught in HS any more.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY*** *LINK*

#25

Re: Got thrown out after the first week.

steve mackay

From what I've seen here on the "outside" boy, are you right ! Schools should try some math and reading. They are too focused on other things.