Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

Posts

Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

#1

Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It looks like we may have to replace our phone lines in the house - we're getting consistent internet failures to connect that appear like they might be noise from the ancient phone lines under the house (going back to who knows when, probably 50 or more years old).

We have DSL for our computer. We're not power users. We are considering going to internet TV of some sort, which I think becomes a power-user kind of traffic, and our ISP can provide very high speed connections (don't ask me for numbers; I'm only but so smart on this stuff).

Home Desperate has Cat-5e and Cat-6 cables and fittings. Apparently, stuffing that last cat into the cables isn't easy (I don't even know how they get the first five cats in - the companies who make this cable must go through a lot of bandaids), because the fittings are four to five times more expensive. The fairly helpful Home Depot employee said that Cat-5e is adequate for today's residential settings, with Cat-6 being for high rises and other places like that. But he also implied that, ten years from now, Cat-6 may be necessary.

Anyone have more experience with this than the minimal amount I have?

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

#2

Why do you need cat anything

Dustmaker Mike

Are you replacing the phone lines? If so use phone line it is cheap and all that is needed. If you are looking at running a network then you will need cat 5 or 6. Cat 5 is fine for just about anything you are going to do.

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

#3

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

Dave Paine

The differences in the cable specifications are meaningful.

Like many people, I had the old POTS cabling (Plain Old Telephone Signal) until I signed up for broadband via my TV cable company. I likely have Cat 5 wire coming into the house. The line for broadband was installed new when we added broadband to the cable subscription, but I expect this is Cat 5. The run goes direct to my cable modem and then I am wireless to the rest of the house including the TV (for Netflix). I have separate analog cable run for normal TV viewing..

As the bandwidth increases, so does electrical noise, not good for data transmission. Not a problem if you lose a few pixels while streaming TV, but if data packets are corrupted, then the packet is meant to be re-transmitted, which effectively means it takes longer to transmit the data, so speed suffers.

The trend for broadband is to higher and higher bandwidths. I started at "only" 1MBps (Mega Bits per second) and now my connection is meant to be "up to" 10 MBps.

If you start to stream TV/movies and another person wants to work on the computer, the extra bandwidth will really help.

I would go with the Cat 6 so that you do not have to worry about a retrofit later.

The cat 6 should have better shielding (for the electrical noise) and to prevent interference to or from other devices in or around your house.

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

#4

How they get the cats in

Henry Higginbotham

Nothing to it, Bill. First, you put in the roof of a car (preferably a just-washed one). The cats will follow. How you get the car roof in, I'm not sure--maybe some sort of endoscopic 3D printer with turbo encabulator. That would account for the high cost. Anything else you need explained? :D

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

#5

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

Bill Howatt

I'm not totally clear on your situation. Normally, the standard telephone 2 pair wire brings the DSL signal to your DSL modem or modem/router combination. This telephone wire has nothing to do with CAT anything. The people who have cable ethernet have their signal brought in on a different type of cable to their cable modem so don't confuse your setup with theirs.

The CAT stands for Category and the bigger the number the higher the amount of data the network cable can handle. Note that the spec is for a 100M run so for shorter runs the cable can typically handle even more data than it is specified for.

You can use a Cat 5E cabling in a gigabit (1000 Mbit) network. Right now I think if you have the fastest internet service available to residential users (fiber-optic) the rate is under 50Mbits which is a long way under the Cat 5E maximum even at 100M cable lengths.

Note that the maximum speed you will get in your connection depends on the slowest device in the link. So if you have a Gigabit network card in your PC and feed a wireless PC on your network via a 54Mbit wireless G rounter then the transfer rate is limited by the 54Mbit link. Note that all the numbers given are somewhat pie-in-the-sky theoretical maxiums. The actual performance is considerably slower.

In a residential setting I doubt that Cat5E cabling will be a limiting factor for internet use for many years but of course, I don't have a crystal ball.

Another thing to be aware of is that care needs to be taken when installing the network cables. They are not to be pinched under staples and should not be tightly kinked at any place or they will not meet the specs.

By all means go Cat 6 if you wish but make sure it is properly installed.

Bill

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

#6

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

Jim Breeden

The first thing you need to do is: Sit down, hava a cold beer or two, think how many cats you want and what size. This way you won't go cat-a-tonic trying to figure it all out. :D

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

#7

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat? *LINK*

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

The different category number are used to specify the maximum design speed. Cat 5E, as already mentioned, is good to gigabit speeds for up to 100 meters, which is way more than the average homeowner will use. Cat 6 cable will go up to 10 gigabit speeds for shorter distances, but it is overkill for household use. 10Gbit switches cost over $300 a port for decent units, so it is pretty far over the average users cost threshold. If you are not running 10Gbit speeds, you don't really need Cat 6 cables.

Cat 5 cable has pretty much been replaced by Cat 5E cable, so that is what I would recommend. Wireless works fairly well for most computer work, but I prefer hardwired circuits when I can get them - Less noise and more secure. It is really difficult to crack into a wire in your wall from outside your house. If you decide to use wireless, be sure you use WPA2-AES encryption - it is the only one that hasn't been cracked.

If you wire your house with Cat 5e cable, you can use it for both phones and computers. A phone cable connector (RJ11) will snap right into a network cable connector (RJ45) and work just fine, so it no longer makes sense to run separate wire. If you are using a VOIP (Voice over Internet) connection for your phones, you will need a network connection anyway.

I get most of my cabling from Monoprice - link below. I work in the computer industry as a consultant and system designer/integrator. We buy cables from Monoprice by the thousands. Don't be fooled by companies touting their "oxygen free copper" and other snake oil for network cables. Networking is a digital signal. It will either work or not work. A properly made cable does not benefit from fancy stuff as long as it has the basics: correctly twisted wire pairs, a properly installed connector and some strain relief.

By the way, if you want to do wireless, here is a website to take a look at:

http://www.microcom.us/pico2.html

Take a look at the Ubiquity Pico Station. For about $60, you can add this to your router and get good range. For a little more, you can get the next step up and get great range - up to 1/2 mile under the right conditions.

Hope this helps.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, Ca


Monoprice - Good cables cheap

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

#8

Re: Phone lines - how fancy a cat?

Jerry Nicholson

"..... I likely have Cat 5 wire coming into the house. The line for broadband was installed new when we added broadband to the cable subscription, but I expect this is Cat 5. The run goes direct to my cable modem and then I am wireless ..."

More likely you have RG/6 coaxial cable coming into the house to your cable MODEM, not Category 5 UTP (unshielded twisted pair).

Jerry