Is mahogany
mdclor
prone to splotching like maple?
TIA,
Merle
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Is mahogany
mdclor
prone to splotching like maple?
TIA,
Merle
Re: Is mahogany
Howard Acheson
No, mahogany is one of the more even coloring woods. However, the more experienced finishers will always test out their finishing schedule on scrap before committing to the real project.
Not really
John in NM
I've not stained it often, but I don't recall having any problems either with stain or plain oil. African mahogany might be more troublesome, being generally a lot softer and more open in grain, but I still don't think it will blotch.
depends on the grain not the wood species
Bill Tindall
It is an inherent property of wood that end grain will take more stain than flat grain. If the piece of wood has places where the end grain is exposed, either from curl or a cut near knots, these parts are going to stain darker.
Maple tends to have more wavy grain than some woods so it tends to stain unevenly, for better or worse. In the past giant mahogany trees were available and the lumber from these trees was straight and knot free. On the other hand, there was "ribbon stripe" that would stain in a striped pattern. Now days the logs are smaller and there is greater likelihood of a board being cut from near a knot. These area will not stain uniformly.
Personally I celebrate these differences in stain uptake. What some call blotchy, I call figure. The way to turn blotchy into figure is proper surface preparation. Any torn grain, something easy to encounter when there are grain changes, will stain dark and ugly and deserve to be called blotchy. A properly prepared surface many stain uneven, but the resulting enhancement of the figure is attractive to many. note example in drawers

Re: yep
Re: Is mahogany
mdclor
Thanks. I didn't think it was and the 4x6" sample board I made didn't splotch, but LOML was talking to a contractor who said........ 
Re: Is mahogany
del schisler
check this video from charles neil about blotching . I use his blotch control . I make jewelry box's from lot's of different wood's and don't want blotching on my stuff.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfCYMdrP8rM&lr=1&user=InTheWorkshop
Use dye stains
Ellis Walentine
I always recommend that you try both pigment stains and dye stains on test pieces before you commit to a course of action. Pigment stains, as Bill Tindall mentions, stain end grain darker. They also collect in the exposed pores of open-pore wood and make them look contrasty, which may or may not be your intention.
Dye stains, on the other hand, usually result in a uniform color, regardless of the figure or grain or porosity of the wood in question.
Ellis
Re: Is mahogany
Steve Schoene
Sometimes mahogany doesn't "blotch" enough and take dye and even pigment stain too evenly, making it pretty much lifeless. One common solution for mahogany is to start with a dye of yellow color, then cover with a light shellac wash coat, and then use a brown stain (or tinted pore filler). Tne shellac seals the more dense portions of the wood, letting less stain penetrate and allowing a bit of gold highlights occur. This gives a better representation of antique mahogany than any one step process.
Definately test out this process completely on scrap. THere will be stages where the wood looks AWFUL until the beauty comes out in the end.
Re: Is mahogany
Steve Schoene
Sometimes mahogany doesn't "blotch" enough and take dye and even pigment stain too evenly, making it pretty much lifeless. One common solution for mahogany is to start with a dye of yellow color, then cover with a light shellac wash coat, and then use a brown stain (or tinted pore filler). Tne shellac seals the more dense portions of the wood, letting less stain penetrate and allowing a bit of gold highlights occur. This gives a better representation of antique mahogany than any one step process.
Definately test out this process completely on scrap. THere will be stages where the wood looks AWFUL until the beauty comes out in the end.