Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

Posts

Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#1

Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

David Frame

Hi everyone at Woodcentral Messageboard,

If I’m going to glue an end grain bevel joint, what is the best glue for the job? By the way, most of my finished joints have slip feathers with this type of joinery or a hidden spline.

Does anyone have any experience with Titebond cyanoacrylate glues and other cyanoacrylate glues? I’ve been using Satellite and Mohawk Brands, thin, medium and thick brand on the joints mentioned above. For years they’ve work well.

However, the problem I’ve noticed with Satellite and Mohawk Brands is that it hardens in the bottle within several months. I use it quite regularly too. Is there something I can do to slow down the drying of the super glue while it is still in the bottle?

Thanks for your time,

David Frame

dframe01@hotmail.com

P.S.

I was wondering about Titebonds instant glues. There ad says they were made for wood. Does anyone have any experience with these glues?

Thanks.

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#2

JL

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

JL

I've dealt with a number of CA glues. I usually use whatever is at hand.

Anyway, the way I keep CA glues from curing in the bottle is to exclude moisture. The silica gel desiccant works well. Get a small glass jar and place your CA glue bottles in the jar with desiccant.

If you use an indicator desiccant, you can tell when you need to bake the moisture out of the desiccant.

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#3

Post *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

on the Turning Board. Turners buy the stuff by the quart. I use Starbond Brand, as its fresh and high quality. I buy by the pint and hold the large bottle in the frig, decanting 1/2 oz. into small applicator bottles as needed.


glue

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#4

answers and coments

Bill Tindall

If I’m going to glue an end grain bevel joint, what is the best glue for the job? .....White or yellow glue is as good as any readily available option.

Does anyone have any experience with Titebond cyanoacrylate glues and other cyanoacrylate glues?...... There are good chemistry reasons to expect this kind of glue will not make a joint that will last decades. Personally, I would not use cyanoacrylate adhesive for "permanent" bonds or heirloom furniture.

However, the problem I’ve noticed with Satellite and Mohawk Brands is that it hardens in the bottle within several months.......This stuff was invented in Kodak's chemistry labs. Kodak sold it for a while under the brand name Eastman 910. The reason Kodak sold the patent rights to Locktite is that its shelf life was unpredictable and Kodak didn't want to deal with the customer complaints. Since this time companies have learned to refine it better and stabilize it more or less and the shelf life has improved, more or less. Because water vapor is one a many things that initiates it setting up, it is only a matter of time before it hardens in the bottle.

This adhesive is different from any other adhesive we commonly use. In the cured state all adhesives are tough polymers(polymers are very long molecules (think spaghetti). The white and yellow glues are water suspensions of polymer balls which coalesce when the water evaporates to yield a tough polymer film that makes the bond. Epoxy and urethane glues are not-tough polymers that become tough by crosslinking (hooking together of the spaghetti molecules to make them even bigger and stronger) after application. Cyanoacrylate is a small molecule (think rice) that would love to hook up(polymerize) with itself to make spaghetti if only something (catalyst) would give it a nudge to do so. Lots of stuff provides that nudge-water, protein, wood, catalyst from the spray bottle, etc.

When using catalyst don't leave the glue bottle open or open it while the catalyst fumes linger. A few molecules of catalyst drifting into the bottle will begin the process that sets it up.

.

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#5

Re: answers and coments

Barry L Elder

It would seem that the life of a CA glue joint is about 10 years among the woodturners and penturners. Good Luck!

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#6

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

Dave Paine

I use Titebond CA glues - when I want a CA glue - which is normally when I want the speed of cure.

I rarely use CA glue for joints. One exception is making jigs with MDF. CA works very well and I can make a jig quickly. Since it is a jig, if the joint failed, I would make another.

For end grain, I would use Titebond "yellow" glue or an epoxy. I buy Titebond III for yellow glue and the 5 minute epoxy.

I have been using Titebond CA glue for a couple of years. I am not finding a problem with hardening in the bottle. I always keep the top on and replace the top before I spray the catalyst.

My problem with CA glues is the top. It can build up a layer of CA glue. Titebond has a small spike in the cap, but despite the spike, I sometimes need to remove the layer, which can damage the top. I have not see Titebond selling the replacement tops.

If you use CA glue, you want to have Acetone on hand to clean-up and spills, or clean your hands if you do not use rubber gloves.

If the piece is going to be stained, you should mask the areas next to the joint to prevent the glue from sealing the area, which would prevent the stain absorbing close to the joint.

If you decide to use the CA glue, I recommend getting the catalyst, also called "accelerant". It does help.

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#7

CA-Life

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've read a couple of articles about CA repairs on turnings, notably on pieces in museum collections, failing over time as the pure CA filler seemed to have simply disappeared over time. I've yet to see anything on the why or whether any special conditions were involved.

I've moved to using epoxy for most all of my filling applications, but still use CA for quick repairs.

Comment: I find CA to form a rather brittle joint which, while fine in some applications, isn't the best choice for a joint that will experience a certain amount of flexing.

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#8

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I agree with everyone above that the "super glues" are not the best choice for any wood joinery. As an Engineer I have used a lot of the Kodak 910 type adhesive in industry for plastics and foam joining for Automotive products - life may be extended by refrigeration and keeping the containers well sealed at all times - especially when around catalyst or moisture. IMHO the only advantages to the cyanoacrylate glues are the ability to adhere non porous materials and the very fast set time. The disadvantages are numerous. 1) low bond strength, short shelf life (if you get months of use you are very lucky), and 3) the bond is brittle, and when used with a substrate that moves due to environmental conditions (humidity and/or temperature) is subject to early failure. Many good adhesives are available for wood - Hot melt hide glue has many of the good proprieties of cyanoacrylate glue without the failure modes, it can be used without clamping, but does require mixing and heating - the mixed material has a short shelf life but the dried glue lasts for years if properly stored. Titebond glues (I use titebond 3), is another excellent choice, but does require "clamping" the joint while the glue sets. While I would anticipate failure of a wood joint within 10 years or so with cyanoacrylate glues, the hide glue has proven itself for centuries and the yellow and whie glues has been used for many years without failure.

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#9

Yes

Bill Howatt

We were told at a turning meeting that archivists (right word?) do not like work that uses CA glue because of the limited lifetime of the bond.

Bill

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#10

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

John Lucas

David As a woodturner I've used a lot of CA glue and done a lot of experimenting. I would not use it to glue wood together. In fact I'm trying to get away from using it for even filling voids. It's great to temporarily hold thing together but it's long term stability is not good.

When I first started making my hand mirrors I used CA to glue the handle to the mirror body. I had many failures after just a year. This was essentially a cross grain dowel joint. Switched to epoxy and the problems went away.

CA is very brittle. I used that to my advantage in my mirror making and it's shown me how brittle. I glue a block to my mirror blanks using CA and Accelorator. The Accelorator make the bond even more brittle. After turning the inside of the mirror I simply hit the block hard and fast and the joint fractures at the glue line every time. Keeps my glue block ready to re-use and keeps my mirror wood in good shape.

I did a test of glues to see what were the strongest for end grain to end grain. Epoxy was the best but barely beat out yellow woodworkers glue if you size the joint first. Soak the end grain with a dilluted mix of yellow glue, let it sit for a few minutes and the apply fresh full strength glue and clamp the joint with medium pressure. Some epoxies that I tried would apparently soak into the joint and make a weak joint as well. I would use yellow glue.

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

#11

Re: Cyanoacrylate GluesDeaHigh everyone

Ace Karner

When the question is "How do I glue this?" Stephen Shepard has taught me that "hide glue" is almost always the right answer. :)