Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Milk paint question

Posts

Milk paint question

#1

Milk paint question

GolfSteve in Calgary

Several months ago I finished two kitchen chairs with milk paint, then applied ONE coat of polymerized tung oil. I was in a hurry to finish the project so did not apply as many coats of oil as I usually would.

Initially the chairs were moisture resistant when wiping them down, but now the paint is wearing off when wiped...my "antiqued" finishes are rapidly becoming "ancient".

What's your experience? Need more coats of oil? Something that should be expected with milk paint?

Re: Milk paint question

#2

Distressed Finishes vs.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Finishes in Distress.

As you've found out, one coat of oil will not act to protect that fragile milk paint.

Suggestion: Let them "weather" to a nice antique point, then get out the spray equipment and apply 3 coats of good waterborne poly like General's Enduro. After that, you can wipe them down with Windex (even Barry's windshield washer stuff- blue, pink, or clear) to no ill effect.

Re: Milk paint question

#3

Re: Milk paint question *LINK*

Clay Foster

What brand of milk paint is it? "Genuine Old Fashioned Milk Paint" brand is real milk paint, and bullet proof. It isn't fragile, and won't rub off with anything other than sandpaper. General brand of milk paint isn't really milk paint.


Genuine Milk paint

Re: Milk paint question

#4

Ditto what Clay said

john lucas

On my first Windsor chair I remember having to work very hard to get the first layer of milk paint rubbed off so the bottom different color showed through. that was before applying any finish.

the General finish milk paint that I used on a friends shelves was quite fragile.

Re: Milk paint question

#5

Genuine old fashioned milk paint

GolfSteve in Calgary

Yes, I used "Genuine old fashioned milk paint" bought from Lee Valley.

It went on very chalky, but it burnished very nicely using grey/maroon scotch brite pads. I distressed the finish with a bit of wax between coats and wet-rubbing through layers with the scotch brite pads, then applied a single coat of polymerized tung oil.

Re: Milk paint question

#6

Re: Genuine old fashioned milk paint

Clay Foster

Do I understand correctly that you applied wax between coats of milk paint?

Re: Milk paint question

#7

Ooopsie!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

That wax has done you in, Mr. Golf. Nothing sticks to wax, with the possible exception of shellac. If you put wax on a surface, you can pretty much forget putting anything other than more wax over it. Your oil finish failed due to adhesion failure. If you want anything to stick, you'll need to remove all that's gone before, i.e strip it, to remove the contaminating wax molecules. Then you can start over, this time omitting the wax.

Re: Milk paint question

#8

Re: Ooopsie!

GolfSteve in Calgary

The wax has nothing to do with this issue. The wax was spotted on a few places to deliberately cause the next layer to not adhere at that spot - simulating centuries of wear ;-)

What I'm seeing is probably just that one coat of oil is not enough to provide adequate waterproofing for the milk paint to resist wiping down with a damp cloth. I thought it would be enough, but seems not.

Re: Milk paint question

#9

Re: Genuine old fashioned milk paint

Steve Schoene

You mixed this with water from a powder and then applied it soon there after to wood that was bare and unfinished? It has purchased shortly before you used it?

Milk paint without any oil will waterspot and discolor from water but water won't wipe anything off except unbound pigment left on the surface initially. Your description of how you applied it shouldn't make that a very big deal. Beyond that milk paint should be pretty much bullet proof, laughing at most standard paint strippers even.

Pictures might help make your problem more clear.

Re: Milk paint question

#10

Re: Genuine old fashioned milk paint

GolfSteve in Calgary

I don't want to make too big a deal of this. I was just wondering if one coat of oil would be sufficient to waterproof the milk paint finish. I suspect that if I applied a few more coats of oil this problem would disappear. But, from what Steve Schoene says perhaps the paint should not rub off at all even if no oil was applied (but would spot).

I've used these chairs for several months. The black chair gets the most use. We've wiped down the chairs regularly (due to young kids) and until now the colour has not wiped off.

Then this week we've noticed that when the black chair is damp wiped, the cloth will be black afterwords - like this:


This is a photo of the chairs (sorry, bad light & iPhone):


And a shot of distressing. The paint was applied yellow, then red, then black. A dab of wax was put on this spot after the yellow layer. After the final black layer, this area was rubbed down exposing some red and causing the black/red to flake off over the spot where wax was applied. Wax was not applied anywhere else.


Re: Milk paint question

#11

JL

One coat is never enough.

JL

We're not talking latex, we're talking a film forming finish.

The first coat puts on a base. The second coat fills in the voids. The third coat levels and evens out. You might get by with two coats, but....

Re: Milk paint question

#12

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Milk paint question

#13

Could it be old paint

john lucas

Milk paint does go bad if stored too long. Can't remember the symptoms I was having because it's been too long I purchased new paint and the problem went away. It seems like it was a chalky appearance but it's just been too long since I had a problem with Milk Paint.

Re: Milk paint question

#14

Bonding Additive

Steve Kirincich

When applying milk paint to pine, a bonding agent is generally used for the first coat. This can be purchased from the milk paint company.

Steve

Re: Milk paint question

#15

Milk Paint Expert to give program

Bill Tindall

Curtis Buchanan, famous Windsor chair maker and designer, is doing our May club meeting and the topic is "Milk Paint". http://www.curtisbuchananchairmaker.com/home.html

If anyone has questions I will ask and get an answer. Email the questions to me.

The meeting is at the Woodcraft store in Boones Creek, TN (between Kingsport and Johnson city) at 6:30, Tuesday May 8.

Re: Milk paint question

#16

Re: Milk Paint Expert to give program

Chuck Bjorgen

The chair maker Bill mentions also has a 51-episode collection of videos on Windsor chair making on You Tube. Search for curtisbuchanan52 and look for episode 46. That's where he starts mixing and applying milk paint to the chair project. He goes into considerable detail about the process. Can't help feeling this would be useful information for you.