Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Another misguided criticism of Krenov dowels

Posts

Another misguided criticism of Krenov dowels

#1

Another misguided criticism of Krenov dowels

Bill Tindall

Robert Troup's letter to the editor, Popular Woodworking June 2012, is yet another example of people critical of Krenov's use of dowels in cabinet construction which results from the fact that the purpose of the dowels is not widely understood.

I took a class in Krenov cabinet construction taught by one of Krenov's students, David Finck, where I learned the purpose of the dowels. When building a cabinet with a complex door, for example a bow or faceted door, the door is constructed first and the case built to precisely fit the door. This fitting involves multiple assembling and disassembling of the dry fit case. Only a few of the dowels are installed during these dry fits. When all is well, the worn dowels from test fitting are replaced by fresh dowels throughout and the case glued. Repeated assembly and disassembly of the case during door fitting would permanently damage either mortise and tenon or dovetail joinery. (been there and done that before learning the better Krenov way)

The plyed panel on the back of these small cabinets is precision fit to a rabbit in the case back and glued in place. The strength of the cabinet is substantially enhanced by this back panel such that the dowels are not relied on entirely for case strength.

It was not until I built a true Krenov style cabinet that I came to realize that Krenov was a skilled engineer who devised clever ways to assemble his novel cabinets.

Re: Another misguided criticism of Krenov dowels

#2

Letter-To-The-Editor

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You sending this to PW's Editor as a refutation, Bill? Haven't read the mag, so can't comment on whether your critique is well founded.

Re: Another misguided criticism of Krenov dowels

#3

Re: Another misguided criticism of Krenov dowels

Thomas S Stockton

Some people just don't get the whole picture and spend to much time over analyzing one small aspect of the piece. My first fine woodworking experience was a month long class at College of the Redwoods 6 days a week I was worn out at the end. To criticize the way Krenov uses dowels for construction is to not understand the size, use and intended purpose of his pieces. Even his biggest pieces are not that large and some of his wall hung cabinets are surprisingly small.

They are also objects to be admired and for their owners really special pieces so they are not subject to any abuse and if they were, the joinery is not going to fail unless something extreme happens.

I suggest the guy writing the letter should spend some time trying to make a piece up to the quality of Krenov or one of his many students and understand how hard it is and the subtleties involved.

Tom

Re: Another misguided criticism of Krenov dowels

#4

You are spot  on

Bill Tindall

It was not until I built a wall cabinet with a faceted door that I realized the genius behind its construction details- tiny things that matter a lot.

Re: Another misguided criticism of Krenov dowels

#5

Re: Another misguided criticism of Krenov dowels

Steve Schoene

If this guy objects to using something like a dozen dowels per joint on a small cabinet I wonder what he must think about Maloof rockers?