Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

spray for turnings

Posts

spray for turnings

#1

spray for turnings

eliot d

You may suggest that I post on the turning site, but I think, maybe, that workers on this site may spray more. I went to the Smithsonian Craft Show in Washington, DC, the other day and came back with an interesting observation ( for me anyway). Two well-know turners there finished their work differently: one used what amounts to a French polish with multiple applications of shellac and a little oil, the other used spray lacquer with multiple rub outs. Both finishes were excellent. But, without question, the spray approach was superior -- just striking! Now keep in mind that on a lathe you can let the spinning lathe to do just about all the work. (So French polish is not a chore.) Can you suggest why the spray lacquer was noticeably superior? In my own work I use the French polish approach, and it's not bad. But I'm still thinking about how beautiful the spray lacquer looked.

Re: spray for turnings

#2

Depends On The Lacquer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Rattle can lacquer is notoriously heavy on solvent, light on resin so it will take a lot of coats to build a finish. A good gun lacquer like Campbell will have less film color and will build much faster. The lacquer will, however, require some serious venting where the shellac, while needing the alcohol to be exhausted, is not so demanding. You can, btw, spray your shellac exactly the same way. I use shellac on my turnings and apply it with an HLVP mini-gun both on and off the lathe.

You might also consider the new acrylic lacquers like Target EM 6000 that have the self-amalgamating (100 percent burn-in) property of solvent finishes, but with a higher solids content and even faster build.

Re: spray for turnings

#3

Re: spray for turnings

John McGaw

A does FP. B does spray. Maybe B is simply more skilled than A, thus producing better results? Given the sample size it might turn out that if the two swapped methods then B might till have the better results. Personally, I love the results that John Jordan used to achieve using nothing more elaborate than spray cans of artist's fixative.

Re: spray for turnings

#4

Agreed . . . Sometimes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hey John,

I use Fix-a-Tif on turnings as well. But sometimes a deep, optically "perfect" gloss is called for as part of the design. There are turners who get that with Frenching shellac, others with lacquer in a gun, still others with Waterlox applied with a paper towel. To my design sense, the smaller the item, the higher the gloss it might need. Shiny for the sake of shiny doesn't work, whether round of flat, in my view.

Re: spray for turnings

#5

Re: spray Shelac for turnings?

David C. Lykins

I'm some what surprised that the Lacquer finished was superior to the French Polish as MANY Luthiers use French polishing (mostly on classical instruments) for a finish. My guess is that it may NOT have been buffed out as "fine" as the lacquered piece. The reason I believe this is I had the wonderful privilege of meeting Robert Benedetto when I live in GA. Robert is the foremost "Archtop" luthier probably in the world, his hand built instruments start at $20,000. We got to ask him tons of questions about his instruments and building. One of the suggestions he made to builders there, was to "Spray Finish" at least one guitar in your life with shellac. He indicated that the finish was absolutely beautiful. So I started to do just that on a guitar I was building. And he was RIGHT, the finish, except for me messing it up was absolutely beautiful and had a wonderful patina as I used blonde shellac flakes.

So in short, I firmly believe spraying shellac and buffing it out will give you a wonder finish just as beautiful as lacquer. Plus, shellac is fairly inexpensive to use. Just don't spill your beer or wine on the shellaced surface........LOL.

Re: spray for turnings

#6

Re: spray for turnings

eliot d

Can you remind me of what an artist's fixative looks like on a turning? My impression is that it is a finish that looks like no finish--very pure, in a sense. Very close to "just wood". I believe Ellsworth also does that. Is this right?

As for your A vs B commentary, I suppose you're absolutely right: my sample size is too small to conclude anything significant.

Re: spray for turnings

#7

Re: spray Shelac for turnings?

eliot d

I'll have to try spraying shelac sometime. Sounds terrific.

Re: spray for turnings

#8

Re: spray Shelac for turnings?

Stuart Johnson

One thing that hasn't been mentioned is how well the piece is sanded prior to starting whichever finish. The finish is adding depth but can't overcome a less than perfect sanding. FWIW, I have never come close to that perfectly sanded piece

Re: spray for turnings

#9

Re: spray Shelac for turnings?

john lucas

My opinion is it was what was done to the finish after it was sprayed. for my high quality finishes I spray on what I need sanding with 600 grit between coats to level and get rid of dust nib, etc. Once I have the thickness of finish I want then I go to the hand rubbing stages ending with a white rubbing compound and swirl remover or I might use the traditional pumice and Rhotenstone method.

I think it's more about the color of the finish itself and to what extremes you go to to "finish" the finish.

I remember playing with lacquer, shellac, and Birchwood Casey's true oil and many many coats of tung oil as well as many coats of Minwax wipe on poly. The casual and maybe even serious observer can't tell the difference if you finish the finish to the same degree. There is a subtle difference in grain popping and the color of the finish and that's up to you to decide.

I switched to lacquer mostly because it's quicker than the others except shellac and has less problems from consumer handling. I found out that people who store my hand mirrors in the bathroom used Windex to clean the big mirror. The mist would drift and land on the shellac mirrors and leave spots. It doesn't seem to do that as bad on the lacquer. Of course that's just my problem and not the same problem on a hollow vessel displayed on a shelf.

Re: spray for turnings

#10

Re: spray Shelac for turnings

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

A wet coat of 1lb cut dewaxed shellac will raise the loose fibers on a sanded surface so that they can be taken off with fresh abrasive or card scraper. I think the resulting surface gives a cleaner, crisper finish.

Re: spray for turnings

#11

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

John,

If you want to increase resistance to common household cleaners, try one of the new acrylics. I use a lot of General's Pro line, mostly Enduro Clear Poly. For table tops and such, I put in their cross-linker additive (pricey at $35/pt) and the results have been pretty much bulletproof. Water, alcohol, vinegar, ammoniated cleaners and detergents have no visible effect, even if not wiped off promptly. We actually clean the furniture with Windex, occasionally followed by Guardsman polish.

Talk to Jeff Jewitt for recs.

m