Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Would you modify this chair

Posts

Would you modify this chair

#1

Would you modify this chair

Chad P

So, about an hour ago I purchased at auction a chair made by Sam Maloof. There were a few items in the auction, including a rocker that went for for $80,500. I dropped out before it closed. Prior to the rocker auction I bid, and won, the following auction:

http://www.bonhams.com/auctions/19978/lot/2448/?page_anch

I had really wanted the rocker but since I have always wanted to get a piece of furniture by Sam I bid on this chair earlier in the auction (sort of an insurance bid). Now I don't mind the green color, but if the chair is to be displayed I would prefer a black leather. I am thinking of sending the chair to Maloof Woodworking to have them recushion the chair and ottoman. I would keep the current cover and cushions in case I ever wanted to sell it.

So,... what would you do? I am leaning towards recovering because I could actually use the chair in my home. I wouldn't mind if the new leather gets scratched.

Re: Would you modify this chair

#2

JL

Your chair -- your choice.

JL

I'm sure that some will consider it heresy - but I'm of the opinion, if you've bought it, you can do anything you want with the chair.

As an example, I made a rather nice oak bureau for a customer. She wanted it "pickled". It is her bureau - she paid for it. I might not like her choice - but she paid for it.

If you want to change to color, go for it.

Re: Would you modify this chair

#3

Ellis Walentine

Sure

Ellis Walentine

It wouldn't be a sin to reupholster those pieces. Upholstery is understood by makers to be an expendable part of the piece. It probably wouldn't hurt to retain the original cushions, as you suggested, for posterity. You will need new frames for the new cushions, though. I'd get an opinion from the Maloof folks before you proceed, but it might not hurt to shop around for the best deal. Reputable upholsterers should be able to provide whatever framework is required.

My2¢,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Would you modify this chair

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Would you modify this chair

Moses Yoder

The bright green is kind of an eye catcher, where black will look very boring. If Sam thought it should be bright green and made it that way for his reasons, I would leave it like that. If it is only bright green because of a customer's preference then I wouldn't mind so much changing it. If you make it black, it will blend in with all your other furniture probably and nobody will notice it.

Re: Would you modify this chair

#5

Never

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Seen a Maloof piece in lime green upholstery; most (that I've seen) were originally done in black leather. You might inquire whether there's a provenance for the green leather as original. If not, I would have serious doubts that it's original to the piece.

Upholstery is renewed all of the time, especially leather. If you decide to hold onto the green pieces, you need to make sure they are stored so as to preserve them. Stuffing them in a plastic bag on the top shelf of the broom closet is unlikely to be a good idea. ;)

Re: Would you modify this chair

#6

Re: Would you modify this chair

Jesse Cloud

Interesting question and good answers, too. Here's a couple more ideas:

For what its worth, Sam sent his upholstering work out. He personally selected the fabric and he built the frames, but the work was done by Keith Dixon and other upholsterers (See Sam Maloof, Woodworker).

Sam did keep records of each client and if the green uphostery is original, I'll bet it is mentioned in his records.

The auction web site shows the price paid for the piece and I think you got a very good price! The green upholstery may have scared off bidders.

Having said that, reconditioning originals usually decreased their value.

The green upholstery should be able to be removed without harm, if you take out the internal frame as well. Its probably just screwed on.

Any professional woodworker with experience making chairs can remove the current upholstery and make new frames for new upholstery, thereby conserving the original. If you are a skilled woodworker, you can do this, too. The fit has to be very precise and allow for the upholstery material. Sam used "inexpensive soft woods" for the frames.

Good luck and let us know what you decide!

Re: Would you modify this chair

#7

"rocker that went for for $80,500"

Barry Irby

A few years ago my son and I went to Atlanta to see Sam at one of his Demo's at Highland Woodworking. Grabbed the opportunity to buy him lunch, along with his wife and a couple of guys from Highland. He told a story on himself. Each year he would donate a chair to his favorite charity. The bidding went to $120,000 and then $125,000. The charity took the opportunity to ask him to donate another if the second place bidder would pay the $125,000 top price. So, According to Sam, he "sold" two chairs for a quarter of a million dollars.

Late in life he bought a Porch. The dealer was dumbfounded that a guy that made chairs cold buy one of his cars. Even more so when someone explained Sam got more for a chair than he did for a car.

I would not hesitate to reproduce the upholstery on your set if I kept the originals.

Re: Would you modify this chair

#8

Thanks for all the input everybody

Chad P

I decided that at the end of the day I want this chair for me, not as some type of investment. For that reason I will recover it for my own use.

While its tempting to build the frames myself, I have enough projects I'm not getting to yet. The wife would not appreciate any more delay in my bathroom remodel.

Jesse, I agree about the price. I was actually quite shocked that the chair went so cheap. I bought it only because I was afraid I would be outbid on the rocker. Turns out I was lucky to do so.

Re: Would you modify this chair

#9

Re: "rocker that went for for $80,500"

JoeIrish

For my third chair I am trying to make a copy of Sam Maloof's rocking chair....first out of some spruce(cheaper that way) and work out the specific construction techniques before I buy some more expensive wood to make about four(4) of the for family members. The first Boston style rockers are finished and taken over to my granddaughter's house for use on their patio(desert does not get a lot of rain here).

Am using Chgarles Neil's method of scooping out the seats... comes out very nice and sanding finishes up nicely and smoothly.