We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
My shop is a stand alone building, 24x24 with a 5/12 pitch and a single ridge. It is about 20 years old and heated in the winter. It has the original asphalt shingles. I discovered in December before I went south, that branches had damaged some shingles. The OSB was exposed in some places. I smeared roofing cement over all the damage and it has not leaked.
I want to reroof myself. Can I apply shingles over the single layer without a tear off or should I tear off and start over? Thanks.
Here in this area (central Indiana) it is considered ok to apply 2 layers. However the fact that you had OSB exposed shows you have no felt paper or have damaged that layer. If you have an area of damaged underlayment (felt) on one side of your roof, I personally would at least strip that side of the roof and replace that prior to applying shingles. I used Ice guard, a self adhesive/rubberized material that is used to replace the felt for the lower area of the roof (I applied it for the first 6' or so. This material prevents water from penetrating the layers in the event of an Ice dam at the edge of the roof, in fact with a low pitch like one of my add on rooms (3~4 pitch) I covered the entire roof with that material instead of the felt.
Yes and yes. If you are agile enough to work on the roof safely, you can d this yourself. And You can apply them over the existing shingles if you wish. the conventional wisdom is it will shorten the life of the roofing by something like ten percent. Maybe more or less. the advantage to a nail over is that it is cheaper and less risky. You don't have to pay for the tearing off and the dump charges, etc. And there is little chance it will leak during the nailing over. OTOH, if you tear them off, the roof is "open" while the process goes on. A crew of roofers could do this in to or three hours, certainly well under a day. It probably will take you several days.
The numbers I used to use were $50 to tear them off, $50 for the shingles, and fifty to nail them back on. Obviously those numbers are outdated and dependant on lots of variables, but you get the idea. Lets say the tear off adds 25 to 33% to the cost. why would you invest that much up from to get ten percent on the far end?
But, Many people are strongly opinionated and believe in their heart of hearts that stripping them off and installing a single layer is "better".
What I do on my rentals is use up grades shingles that 10 or 20% more and do a nail over. If the nailing over robs me of ten percent, then I still get more life than I would have with cheaper shingles and a tear off.
If you "nest" the shingles you get a good looking job faster and easier with a nail over. If you don't understand, let me know and I will describe how to get started to you.
If you think the old shingles are asbestos then it is probaby going to be cheaper to put the new layer on top. If they are asbestos you will probably be forced to have a licensed contractor remove and dispose of them. If you take them off yourself and try to dispose of them and it is found to be asbestos you end up in a mess.
My bones and brain are too old to be up on a 5 in 12 pitch. I have trouble on level ground! I'd hire it done and have the old removed.
If you have any curling of the current layer, then a tear off is necessary. If they are flat then a nail over should work without a problem. My shop is still in good shape, but with the water and ice dam products available now that were not available when I did my shop the first time I would tear off and put all new shingles and drip edge.
We had a hail damaged roof about 8 years ago that was the only roof on the house. The insurance company said to tear it off before reroofing. The indicated that this was standard practice with them. Not sure if it was just that company or industry wide.
I was in a tool closeout-type store in an outlet mall near Birmingham, Ala., a few days ago (Bosch Colt trimmer/router for about $44--that's pretty good, huh?), and noticed some Bostitch levels. 100-year warranty! Small print: "Not transferable"
Depends on 1. How long do you think you will live - climbing on the roof at 86 just may be a problem! :>) & 2. Who will inherit your shop when your gone. Really I would go with the best you can afford. - my youngest son will get my shop when I go so I really try to do my best to leave him without problems. Don't really know of anyone that has used the roof warranty, there is so much fine print - you may find they pay for 10% of the shingle cost and no labor after the 5th year!