Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Krenov style scrub plane

Posts

Krenov style scrub plane

#1

Krenov style scrub plane

jimbo

Ladies and Gents, I am wanting to build a scrub plane based on the krenov style seen in the Hock Kit. I plan to modify the kit probably buying a plan instead and add a "saw " type of handle and a tote. My questions are : is the krenov style appropriate and what width blade would you recommend and do you recommend the chip breaker . I plan to use a Hock blade and breaker if the breaker is necessary. your thoughts? Thanks, Jimbo

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#2

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

mdclor

Jimbo, I don't know the answer, but you will likely get more responses by posting this on the Hand tools forum. In the upper left corner of the message page, select Messageboards, then select Hand tools from the drop down menu.

Good Luck,

Merle

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#3

Why?

Bill Tindall

To get a useful answer to your question it would be helpful to know why you want to build a scrub plane in the Krenov style plane form. For example, the answer could be you need a scrub plane and building one would be cheaper than buying one from Lee Nielsen. Or, it might be you just want to try you hand at building a plane. Or.....?

General thoughts. A cheap and effective route to a scrub plane is to buy a used, cheap Stanley #5 and grind the blade to a scrub plane configuration. This is the path I took and it works for my needs. Krenov style planes seem to me to be more suited for more precise planing. My favorite plane is a block plane made in the Krenov style. Choking the throat with shavings can be a problem with Krenov style planes, a problem made worse by using the plane to hog off lots of material. So making a Krenov scrub plane is a less obvious choice than other plane styles. But who knows, maybe by opening up the mouth it will work just fine.

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#4

Re: Why?

eliot d

Sorry to hijack. But you have touched on the question I asked in the hand tool site about shavings choking in the mouth. So you say it may be a general Krenov plane problem. But , as I said there, one of my Krenov planes -- in fact the one with the really narrow, hairline, mouth opening , doesn't choke. It's the last one I made that chokes, and I can't figure out why. I played with it a lot recently, and I'm beginning to think the problem has nothing to do with that "wall" I mentioned. Perhaps I just have to keep tuning it; I'm adjusting the wedge, for example, now.

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#5

Re: Why?

jimbo

Bill, your questions as usual are very objective and made me think about what i have already , which is stanley #5. (and some blades which could be "radiused" . I guess i thoght the mouth opening would be an issue. Also there was (and still is) a desire to "make" one of my own tools. I appreciate your comments, Thanks, J. Smith

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#6

OK

Bill Tindall

No doubt you will get as many opinions as woodworkers but for what it is worth here is mine. A simple short rectangular, with rounded corners, Krenov style block plane is the only Krenov style plane I still actively use. The others I have made are not planes I can just pick up and use as needed. When they are adjusted well they are indeed a joy to use, but annoying to keep tuned up for the task at hand. I would suggest you make either a block plane or a short smoother. Because both are short planes you won't need to be diddling with keeping the sole as flat.

Years ago I bought a cheap #5 and ground its blade to a radius. Any time I need to hog off some shavings I reach for this plane and it just works. I rarely have to sharpen it or adjust it for that matter. It is the most reliable plane in the stable.

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#7

I did the same as Bill, but with a 5 1/4

John in NM

It was that cheaper series Stanley did with the birch tote and knob. Scrubs are typically a bit narrower than jacks, so that's why I used it instead of a 5 (and I had it already). Worked fine with the mouth as it was. Got dropped and broken one day, so I used some of the parts to make a wood version. I preferred having the adjuster on the metal one, hard to keep things tight enough to stay set without it - scrubs are used for such heavy cuts that the blade tends to get pushed

back. Might not be a problem with a properly wedged plane, but mine is kind of a Frankenstein :D

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#8

Re: OK Question from Bill Tindal

jimbo

Bill, i just finished "hogging' some white oak using your suggestion and radiussing an old stanley blade and putting it my #5. I was more than pleased with the results. Just wanted to thank you again for the suggestion. You guys (and gals ) who have been around in the woodworking are worth bunch to us novices. Jimbo