Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Detail sander recommendations

Posts

Detail sander recommendations

#1

Detail sander recommendations

mdclor

I need to sand an exterior door that is about 4'x10' (not mine) and has 1/2" V groves in it. The surrounding trim has 3 different levels that are 2-3 inches wide and is curved over the top of the door. Therefore, I think that a detail sander will be the best option, but feel free to correct me if I am wrong.

I prefer to buy quality once and I am certain that I will find additional uses for the tool once I have it. Which brands have you used? What features are "must haves" and which are not worth the money? Any other thoughts or considerations will be greatly appreciated.

I was unsuccessful in finding this in the archives although I am certain it has been discussed previously.

TIA,

Merle

Re: Detail sander recommendations

#2

Re: Detail sander recommendations

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Merle, many (most) of the people's comments on this site I have read said they didn't use their detail sander. I am somewhat different as I have used mine extensively. I have a Dremel - purchased on a whim at a going out of business sale at a local lumber yard. I use it a lot when sanding frame and panels and really like it. I did not like the sanding sleeves (expensive and short life) so I use the rolls of self adhesive sandpaper from Klingspor's. I do have to change the paper frequently. My Dremel has a variable speed - though most of the time I run it wide open. I also purchased a (I think Porter Cable) sanding pad assortment. I find the tool saves me a lot of time when sanding Ogees and other curved moldings. Happy with the Dremel - only issue is with the pad holder - it is rather worn and doesn't seat as well as it did when new - but still works ok.

Re: Detail sander recommendations

#3

Re: Detail sander recommendations *LINK*

Dave Paine

My wife bought me a Porter Cable 444 Profile sander some years ago, for tasks such as this one. It is no longer made, but still available on ebay etc. Seems to be inexpensive these days.

I rarely used the sander, but I still use some of the rubber profiles, just for hand sanding.

It has been gathering dust for at least 8 years. The problem for me is the small area of the sanding pads. Not as issue for small area hand sanding, but you will need a LOT of pads to sand a large door.

I think you will find it easier to use scrapers on the flat and curved areas. Perhaps you can find a pointed scraper for the V groove. Purchase a small burnishing rod and you can keep the needed burr in shape easily.

A good scraper blade can leave a very smooth finish.


http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=porter+cable+profile+sander

Re: Detail sander recommendations

#4

Re: Detail sander recommendations

Howard Acheson

What do you intend to do after sanding?

If you intend to stain, sanding is not the appropriate way to remove the existing finish. Sanding does not remove the prior stain and/or clear finish that have been absorbed deeply into the wood. This residual finish will cause uneven coloring if re-staining is planned.

A chemical paint stripper containing methylene chloride will do the fastest, most complete job.

Re: Detail sander recommendations

#5

Re: Detail sander recommendations

mdclor

Dave, I will use a 6" ROS for the flat parts of the door, but I would like something for the narrow and curved molding and the V grooves. Do you think the PC would be good for those areas?

Re: Detail sander recommendations

#6

Re: Detail sander recommendations

mdclor

I don't know what was used for the original finish. I suspect that it was an oil of some sort because the wood is a natural color although it is severely faded where the sun hits it most strongly and there is no pealing. My thought is to sand the wood to reasonably smooth and apply Watco Danish oil. However, I am open to suggestions.

Re: Detail sander recommendations

#7

Re: Detail sander recommendations

Dave Paine

Yes, I think the PC Profile sander would work for the detailed areas, it will just take time. The design is an oscillation movement, front to back, since it is intended to be for shapes, groves, etc.

Re: Detail sander recommendations

#8

Re: Detail sander recommendations

Howard Acheson

Watco is an oil penetrating finish. The wood needs to be able to absorb the Watco. If the surface still does not have most or all of the prior finish removed, the newly applied Watco will not be absorbed.

I would still recommend using the chemical paint stripper I mentioned above.