Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

Posts

OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#1

OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

Howard In Toronto

Well, the time's up on my current lease.

I love the car - 2007 KIA Rondo - great seats, small outside package HUGE interior room, 3 rows of seats. BUT this thing gets TERRIBLE mileage and the lack of a telescoping steering wheel has killed my neck since I got it.

I'm the only person in it about 98% of the time. The way I figure it, we need one more family car before there are NO MORE family trips.

Then I can get what I REALLY want - a FIAT 500 Abarth - small and nimble with good performance and great handling.

So until then, I either get something small-ish with better mileage like a KIA RIO5 and get my wife the family car - she has her eye on the Mazda CX5.

Or I get a Prius V for family purposes and get my wife a Subaru Impreza.

I test drove the Prius V today. Smooth ride, ok performance, terrible ergonomics, a weird plastic sunroof that doesn't open - BUT - great mileage with a huge interior capacity. Even if I end up getting half of what Transport Canada says, that'll still be 3x what I'm getting now in basically the same style of vehicle.

Any personal knowledge and experience or opinions and rumours would be welcome.

Thank you.

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#2

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

Hank Knight

Howard. I'm on my second Prius, a 2010 model. It's not a V - it's just a regular Prius sedan. I kept my first one, an 05 with over 100K miles on it, and it runs like a new one. They have been the best cars I've owned since I bought my 67 VW beetle new off the lot in 67. I went from a V-8 Jeep Grand Cherokee to my first Prius. The difference in gas mileage was dramatic. My bank account felt like I'd gotten a pay raise. The sedan has a surprising amount of interior room. We've traveled in the car comfortably - drove it to Nova Scotia and PEI from South Carolina several years ago and numerous shorter trips. It's very good on the highway - not a fire breather, but plenty of go for normal driving. In fact, the electric motor makes acceleration at highway speeds kinda fun - no wait for the motor to rev up to it's power curve. I've found the ergonomics to be comfortable. I tried to change my driving habits so I could maximize my fuel economy, but I finally gave up. I drive the car as I've always driven and I get between 42 and 45 mpg in town and between 48 and 52 mpg on the road. If I behave myself and drive at the speed limit or below I can get 55 to 57 mpg on the highway. The literature says the cars get better mileage in the city than on the highway, but I've not found that the be the case. I do better on the road. I love the cars and I recommend them highly.

Hank

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#3

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners *LINK*

Jim Dillon

Howard,

Our experience with a Prius 2010-II (basic model) after 23K miles is similar to Hanks. Love the car except for a couple of things. The seats seem hard (nonsupportive for our long legs) and the hatchback design interfers with the view out the rear, plus contributes to major blindspots, especially on the passenger side. Gas milage is amazing. The car just seems to glide along. I am often amazed at all the well-integrated technology that is going on under the hood. The Prius has been very reliable over the years as well. For more than you ever wanted to know about the Prius, check out the link below, especially the forums.

Jim


PriusChat

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#4

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

Bill Tindall

If you can tolerate being driven by a computer according to how Honda decided you would be driven the Prius could be a choice. The last economic analysis I saw concluded that there was no payback for the extra expense of the gagetry. But it seems to make some feel environmentally responsible to own one. I saw lots of them in San Francisco, and corresponding Minis in LA. My SF cousin owns one. I found that being computer driven was annoying, but then I only own manual transmission cars and trucks.

Most don't know how it works. Basically the Prius is built with low drag and rolling resistance and a tiny gas engine that provides efficient power adequate for cruising. As such it would be intolerable to drive. An electric motor is added to provide acceleration when needed. To preserve battery life the battery operates in a narrow range about 50% charge so the battery is of main use for acceleration and it charges mostly for free during slowing. Comparative efficiencies depend hugely on how it will be driven and under what conditions.

As an example of this operation the show Top Gear did a race between a full sized car and a Prius on their track with the rules that each car would drive as fast as it could and the metric to be measured was MPG. The full sized car got substantially higher MPG in this situation than the Prius.

Consider a diesel for your needs.

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#5

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

Hank Knight

Bill,

With all due respect, since you don't own one and acknowledge that you don't know how they work, I don't credit your criticism of the prius. It is apparently and philopsophical or an emotional thing with you, not based on your personal experience - which is very unlike you.

Hank

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#6

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

Tony - Memphis

Thanks for all the info. My wife and I have been considering a Prius. I did a financial analysis over a ten year period (typical for us) and it came out WAY ahead even adding in the cost of a replacement battery pack. We test drove a Lexus CT200 and really liked it, but we are having a hard tie justifying the extra cost (less mileage too). We are looking into renting a Prius to go n a trip to see how we like it. Sounds like it works fine for you. We aren't picky (our current vehicles aren't very comfy - truck and a Z), so it will probably work fine for us. You kow, I don't hear or read very much negative about them. I think they are ugly as heck and not that fun to drive, but who cares. I really like the reliability and the efficiency. Anyway, thanks for the info. Good to hear.

Tony

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#7

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

Don Orr

My wife and I both bought new 2010 Priuses in January of 2011 for a very good price especailly when they factored in our tradeins. I had a minivan with tons of room and great visibility and thought I was going to not like the Prius. WRONG. I really like the car. Very comfortable, lots of room, handles and rides great and goes like mad when you want it to. I actually have to be careful on the highway because I can do 75 and not even realizie it. Ours are the level 2 basic models but they still have more features than my van. And I can haul a bunch of fresh cut turning stock and chainsaws easily. Gas mileage is about 42 in the winter and 48 or so in the warmer weather. Carrying a canoe or kayak on the roof degrades the MPG a little but is not a problwm. Overall I am very pleased with the vehicle and don't feel like I'm being told what or how to drive by a computer. I actually find it entertaining to watch the output-kind of like a little video game.

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#8

Toyota makes the Prius, not Honda.


Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#9

Thank you Hank - Bill the

Howard In Toronto

Hank - I appreciate your insights - they were useful and practical

Bill - the voodoo arithmetic of justifying the extra dollars on the technology under the hood is a smokescreen - I'm just seeing a large stationwagon-type vehicle that's competitively priced and gets the best mileage of anything else in its class - I'm also not too worried about unseen electronic processes at work, after all, I have lungs but I don't know how THEY work

Thank you all.

Howard

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#10

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

John Lucas

My boss drives one of the first Prius models. I get to ride with him a lot. I find the car quite nice. I can't justify the expense my self, my used Honda gets 34mpg and the car cost me 5 grand and runs like a top. However if I had the money I would not have a problem with the Prius. He has had only minor problems over the 5 years he's driven it. He bought it used and I believe has more than 100K on it now with no real signs of troubles. He gets over 50mpg on the highway and somewhere in the mid 40's for his 10mile commute to work over country roads in a small town.

If your used to really nice cars you might not like it. It's not the most comfortable thing in the world but easily as nice as any of the cheaper cars that I've owned.

It does take a little getting used to when the engine shuts off. It's not a problem just really weird when your used to cars that run constantly as you drive. You also have to be real careful when backing out of parking spots because it does so on electric motor and makes no noise at all. You could easily run someone over if they aren't watching because they won't hear you.

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#11

Our "Fun Car"

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Howard...sorry...this is not an answer about the Prius. I have never owned one.

But as you mentioned "fun to drive"....I will share my experience. I have driven many sports cars over the years including Porche. Some were really great to drive. But a car I fell in love with to drive was a Mini Cooper S.

We had looked at them with interest and took many test drives. Finally broke down and bought a Mini Clubman S...pretty loaded (certified used). The handling and gears are a thrill. Surprising cargo space for a car that size.

Just for kicks...take an S model out and put it through the paces. Even if you don't buy it...I assure you will have fun!

T.

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#12

Thomas - Cooper S

Howard In Toronto

You're right Thomas.

The Cooper S does exhibit better performance and handling. But the seating position in comparison to the FIAT 500 is waaay too low for these tired old knees to get in and out of several times a day.

Howard

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#13

Re: Thomas - Cooper S

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I can understand. So many great cars out there require nimble people (of whom I am not one) to just get in and out. My only asset is being short. Many great sports cars are not a good fit for the very tall.

T.

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#14

Re: Thomas - Cooper S

Jim Dillon

Howard,

Regarding your knees, you may indeed want to test-drive a Prius first. We have a friend with bad knees, who also owns a 2010 Prius, and his only complaint is that the car sits too low (probably for aerodynamic reasons). Other than that issue, he loves it. The higher end Prius models have larger wheels (17 vs 15 inch, I think) so maybe they are better in that aspect. But thinking about it, I believe our friend has a higher end model, so be sure to get in and out a number of times to check things out.

Jim

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#15

I tend to think this way as well...

John in NM

I've driven a couple of Saturns for years, when I'm not driving one of the horrible old trucks. Best I ever got was 54 mpg on a 200 mile flat run of highway. Average is 38-42 highway. This figures from cars that cost half what the average hybrid costs, it's a shame chevy stopped making the true Saturn line in 02 and started remarking they std products before dumping the brand entirely.

The used one I bought last year cost about $5k, and gets similar mileage to my old one. And it has a stick and hand crank windows. Keep it simple, cheap, and efficient, and you have a pretty good car. :D

Re: OT - Toyota Prius V or Prius owners

#16

Ford Fusion Hybrid

Jim in N. Va

I test drove a Prius several times about 2 years ago. I really liked it, but liked the Ford Fusion Hybrid better and that's what I bought. Why? The Fusion had larger, more comforable seats, had more power, felt more substantial, and had a better crash test rating. What did I give up? Some mpg, for sure. I get about 42 mpg...much better than my Lexus RX but not as good as a Prius. Also, it's a sedan and not a hatch back. But I have a mini van for when I need to haul stuff. And the Ford (at least for the model I bought) was a bit more expensive.

The Fusion has been very reliable, both in my experience and as rated by Consumer Reports.

I'm not sure if you want to broaden your search to consider other hybrids, but given what you listed as factors I thought I'd mention my experience with the Ford.