Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Heatpump for shop?

Posts

Heatpump for shop?

#1

Heatpump for shop?

Bjorn

Hello -

haven't been here for a while, but since I have gotten great advice here before, I ask my question here.

Up until now I have an electric 220V heater in my garage/shop. I was discussing with a friend ductless heat pumps and couldn't find a reason why a heat pump wouldn't be a great solution for the shop (besides obviously the price). Is anybody using a ductless heat pump for the shop?

thanks,

--bjorn

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#2

Re: Heatpump for shop?

Jerry Gibbs

where are you located? heat pumps don't work in real cold temps.

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#3

Re: Heatpump for shop?

Bjorn

Close to Seattle, WA, so no big issue regarding too cold.

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#4

Re: Heatpump for shop?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Bjorn, it all depends on your local climate and the type of heat pump. Heat pumps are very efficient (actually over 100% - due to the effect of bringing heat from cool air or water) when the outside temperature is over 40 ~ 45 deg F.. However, as the temperature falls below 35 ~ 40 F the efficiency falls and direct electric is better. Units will not work below a certain temperature dependent on the design - used to be about 30 F.

The exception is when the medium used to "warm" the outside coils is water from a stable temperature source (deep lake, underground well or piping).

Most other methods of heating in my area are less expensive overall. These include natural gas, Propane and even oil heat.

Heat pumps used in combination with either an electric furnace and heat pump or fossil fuel furnace and heat pump are more efficient and less fuel costly in my area, but I don't know about the payback for the extra cost of the heat pump. Therefore if you have a lot of days/weeks when the temperature is mild and you just require raising your shop 15 to 30 deg F, a heat pump is good, again if the temperature falls below 30 F (0 C) you would need to have another source of heat. One major advantage of the heat pump is that you would have central air conditioning.

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#5

JL

Re: Heatpump for shop?

JL

Good Shepherd Church recently revamped its HVAC systems this past fall.

Downstairs is a single mini-split heat pump.

Upstairs in the sanctuary are four mini-split heat pumps.

Yes, they work reasonably well for the place - but there is a "lag" time. Don't expect "instant" heat if you decide to install one.

The downstairs unit managed to keep the downstairs comfortable this past winter. As the space is probably larger than your shop, a similar unit should keep your shop reasonably conditioned.

GSC found them to be a reasonably priced alternative for the application and a lot less expensive than installing two new larger systems with all new ducting.

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#6

Re: Heatpump for shop?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

The life of a heat pump's compresser depends on LARGE airflow,and over-sized return air with super-good filtration. Add in sawdust and small return of a ductless split system and you will have problems. Changing a compresser every 4 to 5 yrs will eat up any savings!

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#7

Re: Heatpump for shop?

Ryan

I 'm almost your next door neighbour (Vancouver BC) and use a heat pump in the house. I've got electric backup which cuts in when the temperature drops. I can tell you that once the outside temperature drops to about 35f, the heat pump doesn't do much even with the electric boost. I've got a wood stove which does a good job when the weather gets cold. Short of putting in a heat pump with natural gas as a booster for cold weather I'd look for other options.

Good luck!

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#8

Re: Heat Pump for shop?

Barry Irby

You have gotten good answers. Check with your local utility to see if they promote Heat Pumps in your area. The Suggestion that they don't hat up quickly is correct. If you leave them on they do a good job, but if you turn it off when you leave do not expect it to recover quickly when you return. Also, air flow is absolutely critical. You MUST arrange for excellent filtration. OTOH, I have been using a window air conditioner in my (Hobby) shop for about five years with no problems. I blow it and the filters out occasionally.

Also, be careful to pick an experienced installer. Locally the mini split systems have not caught on or taken a significant part of the market and you don't want one installed by someone doing their very first one. The last thing you want to hear is " Golly, I ain't never see'd one of these before."

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#9

Re: Heatpump for shop?

Bjorn

Thank you, all!

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#10

Re: Heatpump for shop?

walta

If you keep the shop at a constant temperature then go with a heat pump.

Heat pumps generally don’t change the temperature of a room quickly.

But most shops are only used a few hours at a time.

I understand you enjoy sum of the lowest electric rates country.

What is your current electric rate?

How often and how long do you use your shop?

How many BTU is your current heater?

Walta

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#11

An additional thought.....

Barry Irby

Most heat pumps have electric back up or Auxiliary heat. Basically powerful electric heating elements that come in to play when the heat pump can't keep up. (They actually do three different things, but I won't label through all that here.) If you walked into your shop and turn the heat up more than about two degrees you will most likely bring on the Auxiliary heats and that will at least triple the cost of the heat. Heat pumps are one of the more efficient forms of heat (in the right climate), but the electric heaters are one of the least efficient. So if you let the shop cool down and then suddenly turn the heat up for an hour or two, you will get almost no benefit from the HP. Double check carefully with the manufacturer of the unit to see how it responds to sudden changes in the settings. Be careful, they can get a little mealy mouthed about this.

Re: Heatpump for shop?

#12

Re: An additional thought.....

Bjorn - Redmond, WA

If I go for the heatpump I would like to keep a permanent temperature - something like 65F. For the very few days that we have freezing temperatures, I can always use my old electric heater to help.

My main concern was the dust.