Finishes
Lapidary Wood Duck
Does anyone know if you can spray laquer over water based poly? Asked on that other board but nobody answered.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Finishes
Lapidary Wood Duck
Does anyone know if you can spray laquer over water based poly? Asked on that other board but nobody answered.
Not sure....
John in NM
With oil based poly I'd definitely expect wrinkles or cracks in the top coat. It will all depend on whether the solvent in the lacquer attacks the WB poly or not.
Why not do a test piece or two and find out.
Or perhaps just use one finish. Why mix like that when either one should work fine on it's own? Just askin' 
Run a test on scrap
John Lucas
It won't work the other way, I screwed one up the other day. It might work lacquer over Poly but I would never try mixing finishes without running a test on scrap wood.
Because I made amistake
Lapidary Wood Duck
Because I mistakenly sprayed on a coat of water poly but want to use laquer. Should have noticed no odor when I pulled the trigger but just didn't pay attention I guess.Suppose I'll sand and try. thanks
Re: Finishes
Jesper, Denmark
Conventional wisdom says that it is OK to use waterbased finishes over solvent based, but NOT the other way round.
it must be related to the fact that the water takes longer to evaporate from the fininsh than solvent, so outgassing spoils the adhesion.
There is not an easy answer
Bill Tindall
Always test this sort of application for proper adhesion. To test for adhesion of the top coat make a cross hatch scratch pattern in the finish with a razor blade with scratches about 1/8" apart. Apply masking tape to scratch patter and then lift the tape off. Most of the tiny squares of finish should stay stuck if all is well.
There is a second risk. Lacquer is formulated in strong solvents. They may dissolve the coating they are applied upon which would result in an intermingling of the two film formers. The result could be cloudy, or not.
Why it is hard to tell what may happen without experimentation? There are dozens of lacquer formulations employing many different chemicals. Ditto for the water based poly. The fact that something is called "water based poly" only limits the kinds of chemicals in the cured film to dozens of possibilities. It is entirely possible that in one case your proposal will work, while with different brands the result would be unsatisfactory.
There is no substitute for testing in these situations.
Thank you everyone
Lapidary Wood Duck
Thank you for the replies...........I should have asked here to begin with.
Re: Finishes
Jesse Cloud
Play it safe. Sand it down, do it over.
Even if the lacquer adheres, the water based poly may (or may not) be more elastic than the lacquer and cause the lacquer to crackle when humidity or temperature change.
In my opinion, just not worth the risk...
Re: Finishes
Lapidary Wood Duck
I did just that..........thanks