Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

ot cabin air filter

Posts

Re: ot cabin air filter

#26

you don't have to drive

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

The roads I do. I probably have more exposure to road dust than I do sawdust (at least in the summer months). The company buys the truck and filters. I would have to buy the dust collection at home. Cabin air filters a few bucks, dust collection system, several hundred, when I actually get a dust collection system, I'll investigate your improvments. For me it is money spent vs effect.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#27

hmm .. mine probably does too, huh?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I wonder where it is?

Re: ot cabin air filter

#28

Re: you don't have to drive

Charlie Lenz

Ok Gary, so far your one out of about a dozen.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#29

Missed Something

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

[Not that I read every post on every board :\ as life is too short :D ]

But what, Charlie, are the improvements of which you write/speak? Link to a website, article, or post? I'm always interested in improvements that I can apply.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#30

Re: Missed Something

Charlie Lenz

Mark, here is a link to my dust collection website. https://sites.google.com/site/sawsuckerproject/home And for the table saw dust hood that goes under the saw, to prove to you how well it works, I found a guy on YouTube that copied my design and made one from wood, the video shows how well it works. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MkzY0F-5YlI I have an easier way to make them from wood, but haven't let that out to the public yet.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#31

Not Missed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Actually, I remember that now. Doesn't help me [cabinet saw, 6" ducts, 1600 cfm collector in garage from basement shop], but nicely done anyway. Been using filtered box fans for years, but needed less now that I mounted a JDS-750.

Peace

m

Re: ot cabin air filter

#32

Re: Not Missed

Charlie Lenz

I have a Delta 50-875 Air Filtration unit, the box fan I sit close to where I'm sanding, routeing, etc. to draw the dust away from me and capture it. Are you useing a Dust Separator with your Dust Collector ?

Re: ot cabin air filter

#33

Separator?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

No place in my shop/system for one of those. Basement shop ducting is on the ceiling then goes straight through the rim joist and into the blower

Thence into the 6' filter bag

Pix are of the old system. Since up-graded to a 1600cfm Penn State unit.

Effective separator for 6" ducting would have to be hung from the ceiling and be at least 20-30 gal. to be worthwhile and not kill the system's fpm which runs at a bit over 800 at the 4" ports. Plus a separator would take up too much space in the Shoebox Woodshop. ;)

I just have to be careful not to have hand tools or the house cat laying around when I turn the beast on. :D

Re: ot cabin air filter

#34

Re: If I may suggest

Charlie Lenz

If your PSI DC is setup the same way, I'd try to raise the blower up to the bag ring height and get rid of all those twists in the hose, or even get rid of the hose and duct it to the bag ring.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#35

Not The Same

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

More gentle curve by far now. More importantly, I need the 24" straight run from the final 45° el down to the blower to smooth out duct turbulence and optimize impeller performance.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#36

Re: Not The Same

Charlie Lenz

( I need the 24" straight run from the final 45° el down to the blower to smooth out duct turbulence and optimize impeller performance. ) I'm not sure what thats all suppose to mean, but going down and comeing back up seems unnecessary. The shorter and the straighter the run the better. I also question that a motor that was setup to run horizontally is wise to run vertically. I'm not sure if the bearings are designed to run that way, it's something that I've wondered lately, and need to ask a electric motor shop if there are different motor codes on the label of motors to determine the position of the motor.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#37

Two Issues

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

To optimize impeller performance, you should have a straight run prior to the entrance of the blower housing of at least 3 times the diameter of the duct (4 or 5x is better still). This smooths out internal duct turbulence caused by bends and wyes, and allows the impeller blades to get the maximum bite on the center of the air stream which is where the real suck work gets done.

Motors in this class are all made with thrust bearings and work just fine in this orientation. Your Delta uses the vertical configuration as do a number of other machines, including all of the cyclone units.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#38

Re: Two Issues

Charlie Lenz

Yeah, I don't know. It kind of sounds like a bunch of Bill Pentz mumbo jumbo. As long as you don't have any tight radius elbows before the DC I think that you'd be just fine, and the same goes for the exhaust side.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#39

Rocket Man?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"All the science I don't understand . ."

Sorry Charlie, but it appears you denigrate those who approach matters on more than a superficial level. Pentz has spent years compiling engineering data and knowledge and then posting it on his website for the pure benefit of people like you and me. It's anything but "mumbo jumbo". You are, of course, free to disregard what Pentz and others have done to improve the field of shop dust control and woodworker health, but to dismiss in-depth knowledge and efforts with such a characterization may indicate a preference for ignorance; a message which you might not wish to be communicating.

Everybody can't be an expert in everything; were that possible, we wouldn't have any experts. We can, however, still benefit from what they know.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#40

Re: Rocket Man?

Charlie Lenz

Well, I don't know Mark, you seem to act like what I've done is no big deal, so who's denigrating who ? As I've stated before in this website, I'm a simple, and down to earth kind of guy. If I tell you that something works I mean it, and will do my best to show you in a simple way. I don't think that I should have to use fancy words, or throw a bunch of meaningless mind numbing numbers at you to try to make myself look smart in order to sell you on something.

Re: ot cabin air filter

#41

Missed Something

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Think it's your turn, Charlie. I said I thought you did a nice job on what you posted, so maybe you missed that. However, I hope you don't think that your efforts, however nicely done, created something new and original.

For instance: I fitted 20" box fans with filters as shop air cleaners 12 years ago, even put them on a delay timer, and I wasn't the first to do so. When I had a contractor's saw, I made a dust chute for it that could be an exact copy of yours, and also used a shop-made barrel separator; that was 10 years ago, and I got both designs from someone else. I made an out-feed extension table for my cabinet saw,

just as lots of others here have done, and I've fitted every table saw I've ever had with a kick-paddle on the off switch just as you can see in the photo.

Your addition of the barrel separator to your mobile collector unit is worthwhile and others who have viewed your post can benefit from your effort. I never said otherwise.

So what reaction to your post were you expecting that you didn't get?

Re: ot cabin air filter

#42

Re: Yeah, I think that I'm done ...

Charlie Lenz

I did the best I can, but I just can't take much more of the aggrevation, especially if the rewards are so small to non existant. And I don't want to hear how you or anyone else did this, or did that way before I did without being able to back it up.