Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Design ratios

Posts

Design ratios

#1

Design ratios

Carol

Math not my thing, so...but there a few math kinda guys here.

An object ~41" high would be around ~25" wide, using 1.62 as the divider of the total height to get the width.

How close to that ratio do I have to be before the eye says quirky? Anything under 1/4" OK in either direction?

Second question. Do overhangs count? In other words, the top will have an overhang ~1 1/2". Should the footprint be ~25" or should the top? My thinking and doodling says footprint. What say you?

And we haven't even considered the depth yet! This is a pulpit. People lean on them. And they tend to be top heavy, literally and visually. So I am thinking no less that 4/5 of the width, or ~20". Thoughts? Sketched, it looks OK, but sometimes when finished, it can look a little 'off.' Thus the reason for the questions.

Thanks.

Re: Design ratios

#2

Re: Design ratios

John Veerkamp

Carol,

Since the "ideal" ratios are just approximations, my thought is that anything within 5% would be just fine. It doesn't have to be exact. Since the eye will see primarily the body of the pulpit, I'd use that rather than the top with overhang. The depth won't be seen directly so I'd make it deep enough to be stable.

One or our professional furniture makers may have other advice , but this is my take.

John

Re: Design ratios

#3

Re: Design ratios

John McGaw

I'd say that you want to balance the visual bulk so, unless the overhang is a truly massive slab, you can pretty much ignore it. More important might be the depth. Depending on where the box (to me, most furniture like this is nothing but a box with embellishments) is being viewed from the depth might become more prominent than you expect. What will it look like from the 'cheap seats' -- the front row pews extreme left and extreme right? If the depth of the box is too great then the proportion might be thrown off more than you'd like. For a paying job I'd make a model, physical or virtual, and see how it looks from various angles before committing.

Re: Design ratios

#4

Re: Design ratios

John Lucas

Make a cardboard mock up, either full size or some smaller scale. I do things visually rather than mathematically. Your talking about something that appears to have some lift but at the same time needs to appear solid. I would certainly start with the math (although I am as much or more challenged than you). Then I would build a mock up out of some material that is easy and quick.

Re: Design ratios

#5

draw it to scale

Bill Tindall

Personally I have not found this 1.6 ratio to be very useful in making something of practical proportions, nor necessary to get a pleasing appearance. I find I can achieve a proportion that turns out well if the scaled drawing looks good. Or you could cut the piece from cardboard or some such full scale. Bottom line, don't feel constrained by this 1.6 "rule".

Re: Design ratios

#6

Re: draw it to scale

Thomas S Stockton

Carol

I'm with Bill and John, make a mock up it will be more useful than trying to figure it out on paper using a design ratio. I have found that designing by eye is way more important than trying to use some of the design ratios that are out there. It is just as easy to make something look weird using them as it is by not using them. I personally found that they never worked real well for what I was designing and that coming up with pleasing proportions was much easier by feel than math.

I also always ran into the problem you are having, does the top count, what about overhang, if your making a cabinet on feet or a stand do you include the complete outline of the piece or are the base and top figured separately, it just drove me nuts and I found that full scale drawings and mock ups were quicker and easier.

So to answer your question, on an alter the size you want nobody is ever going to say it off by about a 1/4" in width. So grab some cardboard boxes, tape and a knife and mess around and see what happens, it will be a lot more fun than doing it on paper.

Good luck

Tom

Re: Design ratios

#7

Adjustable?

Pat Evans

41" is kinda tall for a short person and kinda short for a tall person. Why not make it adjustable? Obviously, ratios go out the window.

Re: Design ratios

#8

Pay No Attention . . .

Bob Lang

. . . to that man behind the curtain.

Make it a practical height for an average person and check some existing pulpit somewhere to see if you're off the mark. Make it wide enough so that whoever is using it can spread out their notes and a book. Make it deep enough so that it won't tip over when leaned on. If you can't decide based on a drawing or a SketchUp model, cobble together a mock up out of cardboard or something similar.

On something like this the finished appearance will be far more affected by how far the top overhangs, trim around the bottom, treatment of the vertical elements, than by sprinkling the fairy dust of the golden mean over it. Your eye will tell you what looks right, and looking for numbers that aren't really there will only hold you back from developing a good eye.

Bob Lang

Re: Design ratios

#9

David Barnett

Proven designs and proportions *LINK*

David Barnett

I'm with everyone who, in my opinion, says scrap the formulae and go for the intuitively and/or traditionally proportioned. Remember, there are ready-made or made-to-order pulpits available from liturgical supply houses -- many styles, most including measurements that provide good starting parameters. So search on church supply, church furniture and you're sure to find plenty of measurements and design features to 'inspire' you.


A few to start you off

Re: Design ratios

#10

Re: Design ratios

Carol

Interesting replies.

Some of you know I have been building custom furniture since the '80's. I have done all the things and considered all the things you have mentioned.

I was wondering how much credence one puts in 'math' when building. You have answered that question with 'not much.'

FWIW, catalog furniture is not custom furniture. This is not a spec piece. The client specified the height.

It is not a 'box' either. Again, the customer specified the general design. Since this design is essential a shallow box on four legs, I have some concern about visual weight and mass.

Some of you who responded I recognize as 'pro' designers and builders. I appreciate your thoughts.

Thanks, everyone.