Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Laminated bendings

Posts

Laminated bendings

#1

Laminated bendings

Philip Duffy

Searched the Articles and came up empty. Anyone got the "gouge" on bending laminated pieces? My first attempt was a 50% loss so even tho I did exactly the same thing for each of the two. I am at a loss as to why one has a section that sprung back to nearly straight while the other has a lovely curve. Any ideas? Thanks in advance. Phil

Re: Laminated bendings

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Laminated bendings

Moses Yoder

A couple questions.

What is the wood type?

Moisture content of the wood?

Thickness and number of laminations?

Type of glue used?

Length of time in clamps?

These are all items that affect springback in bent laminations.

Re: Laminated bendings

#3

I used to have that problem

Bruce, a MN Galoot

then a friend told me that in order to have very little or no springback, you need to use at least six laminations. I did that and haven't had a problem since.

If you're using yellow glue, give it at least a day in the clamps before removing.

Re: Laminated bendings

#4

Add to that, Radius of bend.

Keith Newton

Besides that, I would like to add, that whenever you are bending, 8 times the thickness from each end, will be straight, so always have some extra length.

Then, if you have finished a laminated bend, then go back and cut off the ends in the bend, you should expect some springback, once those straights are removed.

As a rule. The more, and thinner the plies, the less likelihood there will be springbuck.

As a general rule, I normally strive to use thin enough plies, that the whole bundle can be bent around the form by hand.

I normally use thickened epoxy for the adhesive. I usually mix it in solo drink cups, then pour a thin stream just ahead of the roller, as I walk down the length. It acts like a lubricant between plies, and has plenty of open time, taking the worry out of getting it clamped to the form.

Re: Laminated bendings

#5

I've only ever done it one way...

John in NM

With Weldwood plastic resin glue. No springback on the six or so different ones I did. Thinnest was around 1/2" total using 1/16" veneer for laminating, it was a 5' long piece with an elliptical curve. That was the one where I expected problems, but it behaved beautifully.

The glue was hard to find 10 years ago, no idea if you can still get it at all. If you do try it, use a postal scale to measure the water and glue powder amounts, it's more accurate than by volume and you end up with better results. Too much water and the glue is weak.

Re: Laminated bendings

#6

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Add to that, Air or Kiln dried.

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Especially for steam bending, but I've found it differs for glu-lamming, too. Air dried stock works better than stuff that's been kiln dried.

The more lams, the better, too. The thinner the final bent piece will be, the thinner I try to make my individual lams. Seems to work. YMMV...

Re: Laminated bendings

#7

JL

Re: Laminated bendings

JL

When I do glue lamination, I typically do 1/16" - 1/8" plies. I try for at least six plies per lamination for less spring back.

Re: Laminated bendings

#8

Besides which,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It has a really long open time.

Re: Laminated bendings

#9

Re: Laminated bendings

Philip Duffy

Well, kiln dried white oak, 3 layers of 3/16th, shallow bend for a foot stool seat and 26 hrs of drying on TB-3 glue. The odd thing to me was that one side held its form and the other flattened out after the center of the curve. But, I can see where I did a bunch of things in "violation of the rules" so I will re-do the one that flattened. Next time I will follow the rules. Not sure if I can get thin enough with that bandsaw of mine. I could use a good table saw for that kind of precision. Many thanks for all the good words, Moses, et al. Phil

Re: Laminated bendings

#10

Ellis Walentine

Lamination tips

Ellis Walentine

...and, as several have said here, the more gluelines the better. The ideal thickness and number of laminations, though, will be proportionate to the radius of the bend and the stiffness of the material. Like Keith, I like to be able to bend the radius of the individual laminations around the form by hand; if it's too stiff for that, it's going to want to spring back.

Springback is idiosyncratic, as you've noted. I'd recommend making your form with a slightly tighter curve than the desired one in anticipation of some degree of springback. I've seen people try to calculate it scientifically, but I prefer trial and error. Make your form, prepare test laminates in the thickness and number you want to try, then glue it all up and see what happens. Make any necessary adjustments and try it again.

I have a technique I've always used to help distribute clamping pressure around a laminated glue-up, and that is to make several extra laminates out of Masonite and use them as a curved caul around your laminate stack. For a 9-ply, 7/8" thick lamination, I might use 1" of these Masonite strips to even out the curve. Otherwise, the clamps want to put flats all around the outside of your curve.

Like John, I'm a fan of Weldwood Plastic Resin Glue for laminating, as it dries hard as glass and doesn't creep. It does have a brown color and it doesn't span gaps well, so tight seams are a must. Unibond 800 two-part urea resin glue is another perennial favorite, and boatbuilder's epoxy.

Ellis Walentine, Host


Re: Laminated bendings

#11

Moses Yoder

Hey Ellis?

Moses Yoder

Is that what you looked like before they had color photography? :b

Re: Laminated bendings

#12

Ellis Walentine

ar ar

Ellis Walentine

That's what I looked like when I could still twist 50 clamps around a form. Mid 70s -- the good old days. I couldn't afford color film then. :)

Ellis

Re: Laminated bendings

#13

Re: ar ar

Jason Waters

And just a few years later, B&W was more expensive than color!

Nice pic from the past, cool with all the clamps. That picture definately goes with the saying, you can't enough clamps.

Do you remember what you were making?

Jason

Re: Laminated bendings

#14

Remembering

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

the 70's?

O-o-o this aughta be good . . .

Re: Laminated bendings

#15

Cool pic Ellis,

Keith Newton

Seems like that should have been the center-fold shot for some magazine, though I am struggling to figure out which one. ha

Re: Laminated bendings

#16

Weldwood plastic resin glue

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

I get mine at the local ACE Hardware; don't know if it's available nation-wide with them, though. What's it's shelf life?

Re: Laminated bendings

#17

Re: I've only ever done it one way... *LINK*

Thomas S Stockton

I use the glue from this company it is a low formaldehyde plastic resin with shorter clamping times than weldwood, which comes in handy for veneering.

Tom


http://www.pro-glue.com

Re: Laminated bendings

#18

Shelf life

John in NM

It's supposed to be fairly short, though I can't remember what it says on the label now. I've had it last a long time though, more than 5 years, dry as it is out here. I would bet that like portland cement, if it's still powder, it's likely still good.

Re: Laminated bendings

#19

The 1970's? We were younger men then.