Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Toilet bowl ring

Posts

Toilet bowl ring

#1

Toilet bowl ring

Doug Ridley

Does a handicapped bowl need a high wax ring or will a small one be better? Also do I need one with the rubber insert that sticks down into the pipe?

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#2

Re: Toilet bowl ring

Mike in NC

Doesn't matter whether its a standard toilet or an ADA, the ring should be the same. What does matter is the elevation of the flange to the floor. If it is at or below floor level (say, if you have added tile since the flange was set) you may consider the thicker ring. As for a standard ring or one with a "funnel", it's all in preference. Some folks like the funnel because they think it reduces the chance of leaks. I personally prefer the standard, have set countless toilets with them, and never had a problem.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#3

Re: Toilet bowl ring

Doug Ridley

Thanks, Mike. I'll wait 'til I remove the commode and check the flange before I buy the ring.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#4

Re: Toilet bowl ring

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I much prefer the ring with the funnel. It is much easier to get the ring centered on the flange. You can do a little location centering without impacting the ring.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#5

Re: Toilet bowl ring

Doug Ridley

Thanks, Bill. That makes sense. It should help keep from messing up the ring.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#6

Re: Toilet bowl ring

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I like the rubber seal type. A little more expensive, but a lot less messy. You do have to follow the instructions carefully. Disclaimer: I'm not a plumber, just a homeowner kind of guy who's replaced a toilet or two in my house.

Also, get some of the plastic wedges for seating the toilet, and spend a little time getting it so it doesn't rock. They are a great solution for what's otherwise an irritating problem that will cause more maintenance issues in future.

One last tip that I picked up from somewhere (Fine Homebuilding?): once the toilet's all bolted down and tested for function., use an appropriate caulk around the base, leaving the back uncaulked so that, if you ever get a leak, the water has somewhere to exit, thus signaling that you've got a leak.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#7

Re: Toilet bowl ring

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

In my previous life as a contractor I have set numerous toilets. I have used many different styles of rings and they have changed over time. The one I currently prefer is the ring with the funnel and the urethane ring under a thin layer of wax - I believe it is advertized as to be used in commercial applications. It is somewhat more expensive - about $10 but the advantage is that if the stool "rocks" or is moved the urethane compresses and then re-expands to prevent leaks. I have these on both stools in my home. I NEVER recommend calking around the base of the stool. I have seen several bathroom floors require replacement due to the fact the stool seal failed and the leakage was confined to the area under the stool. The homeowner did not realize there was a problem until the stool became "loose" due to the floor rotting out around the sewer line and out to the periphery of the stool. One other thing - I have seen many stools cracked during installation due to over tightening of the base bolts. Remember this is brittle porcelain and has zero flex.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#8

Save the old wax

Jerry Gibbs

it is great for screws

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#9

That bubblegum

GolfSteve in Calgary

...not only can you re-use the wax from old toilet rings to lubricate screws, but I've found that the bubblegum left by people, usually stuck under restaurant tables, can be reused as a handy denture adhesive...

Yuck. :\

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#10

I'm with GolfSteve...

Dick Coers

I usually want a HazMat suit when I pull a toilet. Can't imagine reusing a wax ring.

Funny toilet story;

When my son was around 3, he yelled out to Mom that he dropped an apple that he was eating into the toilet. Mom yells back, just flush it. When I get home, the toilet has to be pulled since it won't flush right. There at the bottom of the white toilet is wedged a bright red apple with one bite missing. Always laugh about it since the wife equated eating an apple as a lot more than one bite gone.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#11

Re: I'm with GolfSteve...

Nat Robison

I recently had to pull a toilet to retrieve a toothbrush that got flushed and the toilet wasn't flushing correctly. Trying to fish something out of the inner workings of a toilet smells just like you think it would.

If I wanted to use a wax ring for other things, I'd probably just buy a new one.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#12

Spare ring

Jerry Nicholson

When I have to set a toilet, I always make sure I have two rings. That way if I screw one up (been there, done that) I don't have to make an emergency trip to the home center with the toilet still sitting in the middle of the bathroom floor.

In my in-laws house the plumber mislocated the flange and the toilet was offset nearly half the diameter of the hole. About 30 years later, new vinyl tile was installed in the bathroom, right over the linoleum. For the next 12 years, the toilet would leak various amount of water into the basement. When I was fixing up the house to sell after both my in-laws had passed away, I discovered the offset problem and also discovered that the old wax ring had been reused (big no-no) when the toilet was re-set after the new vinyl tile had been installed. I had to replace about 9 square feet of flooring and subflooring because of the water damage. I corrected the flange offset problem in the process. Fortunately, there were enough left over floor tiles to cover the new flooring.

Jerry

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#13

Re: That bubblegum

Mark Nowicki

In Canada this advise actually makes sense, because a new ring costs $2.49, whereas the hospital stay to cure septic shock is "free" :D

Mark

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#14

Re: I'm with GolfSteve...

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

I wish I'd kept track of all the things we've pulled out of toilets here at the rockpile. Just to name few, toothbrushes, cameras (what on earth were taking pictures of anyway) sunglasses and a Harry Potter doll, oh yeah a windbreaker coat.

I can't get the old wax ring to the garbage fast enough, I have about thirty toilets to replace starting next week, oh joy

glc

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#15

Re: Toilet bowl ring - Ask Terry Love

DON in STL

This is a great forum for woodworking, but you might want to try a plumbing site for what may be more accurate information. I suggest a DIY plumbing site by a professional plummer, which is available at: http://terrylove.com/forums

I hope this helps you out.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#16

Re: Toilet bowl ring - Ask Terry Love

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I just looked at that site to see if they recommended the same system as I did. After looking I found many of the answers were given by non-professionals. By the was many people here are or were professionals in many fields and are usually willing to give honest answers to all type questions. As to being a pro, I held an Indiana State Contractor Plumbing license for a few years and was a licensed and insured contractor. I worked as an Engineer at Mallory Controls (later Emerson Electric) for about 40 years and contracted on the side with my crew for over 20 years. I think you will find many others on this site as, or more qualified than I in many fields when you ask!

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#17

Re: Toilet bowl ring

Jason Waters

You can buy a steel repair flange if the plastic ring is cracked from overtightening.

I use one wax ring with a funnel for flanges that go straight down.

For offset flanges, I buy standard rings without the funnel so as not to impede any turn it's making with the offset flange. If you don't know what I'm talking about, look at an offset flange at the store and you'll understand.

Don't stack rings. I saw this on a home show years ago, where it was completely unecessary, and it's a sure way to have a mess, not be able to tighten the toilet well, and have it rock. I have seen those results where that was done. Buy a thick ring IF you need it.

Use REAL brass toilet bolts. It's highly unlikely you'll overtighten and crack the toilet (though you still can do it) before snapping a brass bolt or tearing the head off. After you tear up a few, you'll know how far not to go. Brass is a lot easier to cut with a hacksaw blade too.

I'm not a plumber, just my experience.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#18

Re: Toilet bowl ring - Ask Terry Love

DON in STL

Mr. Clinton,

While I have no interest in pursuing this further, I feel I must respond.

I am not sure why you felt it necessary to respond to my posting to Mr. Ridley, especially in such a defensive manner. I did not in any way question the honesty of you or any of the other posters. I simply suggested that there would be more opportunity to obtain correct information from a plumbing forum than from a woodworking forum. After all, I would never suggest that Mr. Ridley use the Terry Love plumbing forum for woodworking advice.

Your credentials sound impressive. However, in your earlier post you stated, “I NEVER recommend calking around the base of the stool”. Surely, if you held an Indiana State Contractor Plumbing license, you are aware that this contradicts what the International Code Council (ICC) states, what the International Residential Code (IRC) states, and what many municipalities require. There is good reason for this, which is quite easy to verify via the Internet.

My experience with forums is that many people are willing to respond very sincerely, but some of them may be sincerely wrong. It’s up to me to filter out the good information from the bad.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#19

Re: Don, I apoligize if I offended you

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I did feel the site you sent him to was did not give any better information than this site - as I said several of the posts I read were actually from Laypersons - not professional plumbers. I do feel this site often is less biased (sometimes the other sites have advertisers contributing to the site) - and members here don't have any motive other than helping each other. As to the caulking of the stool - it may be a spec. in some areas - not in my locale. I was speaking from experience, and feel the detrimental effects of "hiding" any leak certainly override any sanitary benefits from attempting to seal the toilet. I personally feel it would be far more dangerous as far as disease to have sewage leaking under your house undetected for a lengthy period than to have some short exposure on the floor and having it repaired quickly. I have received a lot of good advice on several topics - Forestry, painting - even automobile repair among others, I didn't mean my comment as a personal attack.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#20

You're certainly one of my all time fave resources

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

Knowing your background (electrical—I didn't know about the plumbing) always has made it comforting when your answer to an electrical question confirmed my thoughts on it. I am an amateur, after all.

Just because I haven't been particularly active for the past couple of years, doesn't mean I've forgotten all the very knowledgeable and friendly folks I've met here (and on the ole Pond).

I have recommended the John Bridge forum in the past on tiling issues—not because we might not have some good mud people lurking here—but because they're much like we are: friendly, eager to help, and easily discernible professionals giving tips and advice.

Rod

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#21

Re: You're certainly one of my all time fave resou

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Thanks Rod, I'm sure some of the things I knew are now obsolete or at least behind the times, but I would never give advice on installations I hadn't used over the years - been probably 10~15 years since I have installed professionally (paid for the work) - still do some plumbing, electrical, furnace & minor central air trouble shooting / repair and installation for family & friends. Just helped my son and step grandson's fix up a couple houses for the kids to move into. Had to install a new furnace and quite a bit of plumbing, some electrical and some wood working to make the places livable. My son purchased 2 homes at a "certificate sale". This was somewhat like a tax sale but had less restrictions - bought the houses for less than 10% of their value. He did it to sell the homes to his stepson's families at his cost. Of course they will end up with a lot of free labor :>). Have to hang a couple doors in a week or so in one of the houses. By the way you also have been a good source of knowledge and advice on this site.

Re: Toilet bowl ring

#22

Interesting....

Barry Irby

I'm in VA and generally attend the Code training sessions offered by the local county each year. This is "internal' training for their inspectors but they encourage local builders and Home Inspectors to attend so we are all on the same page. The Local Code used to be based on BOCA and CABO but about ten years ago we adopted the IRC along with the rest of the country. At least my understanding is we now have a national or international building code. Somewhere in the process they told us toilets now have to be caulked to the floor. As I recall, that was several years ago, maybe three or four. At the time the local Building Official made it clear he was skeptical of the requirement for exactly the reasons discussed here. He made it clear he would rather have the water run out in the floor than to be trapped and rot it out. I tend to agree with him. As an inspector, I can not even guess at the number of toilets I have seen rotted underneath.