Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

Posts

Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#1

Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

Phil

I am planning a set of built-in cabinets, and am considering doors on the order of 22” wide by 96” high (think the kind of door that is on those big IKEA wardrobes). The style will be shaker (plain rails/stiles with flat plywood panels) in cherry. I was planning on using 3/4” stock. The panels, being plywood, will be glued into the frames. The tallest cabinet doors I’ve ever constructed have been around 1/3 this height. My concern is being able to fabricate an 8’ door that is flat, and ending up with a door that stays flat. I am wondering if there are any tricks/techniques that can be used to end up with flat doors. The overall size of this project is 8’ high by 19’ wide. Will quarter-sawn stock do it for the stiles, or maybe laminating the stiles by splitting into 3/8” thick parts and gluing together so grain is in opposing directions? There has to be a right way to do this?

Your expert guidance would be appreciated.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#2

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

Ralph Lipeles

My experience is that if the boards are straight and flat they will stay that way. Your doors are symetrical so you will not be introducing any stresses that will want the boards to bend or twist. Just make your wood is good and dry

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#3

JL

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

JL

Some thoughts.

I am presuming you are using 1/4" plywood for the panels.

How about making your rails and stiles a bit thicker? Say 7/8" or even 1" thick? That way you can easily have some cross braces on the inside that are 3/8" thick or so. This would give your doors a bit more rack stability against racking and twisting. Your outside would still show just one piece.

I would mill the lumber and let it set for a while (several days at least) before you work it. That way if it twists or anything, you can correct the situation. You don't want to have your lumber under any "stress".

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#4

Ellis Walentine

Another thing to watch out for...

Ellis Walentine

... is your joinery. I'm assuming you plan to use either mortise and tenon or loose tenon joinery for the rail/stile joints. (I would also like to think there will be a middle rail or two, but you didn't mention it.)

In any event, here are a couple thoughts:

I agree with the advice to go thicker if you can. I just finished a cherry kitchen where I was able to get 13/16"-thick parts from 4/4 material. For 96" doors, I would consider trying to go even thicker, possibly even starting with 5/4 material and shooting for 1"

I also agree that you want to harvest your parts, then sticker them for a few days to see if any of them twist or warp in any way. Make a few extras of each size so you can have backups in case some piece goes awry.

I personally don't care for thin plywood as panel material. Plywood itself can warp, and the stress of that warping may be enough to exert a twisting force on the frames. Plus, 1/4" plywood has a tinny-sounding quality that I don't care for. If you don't want the extra effort or expense of making solid wood panels, you might want to look into Mende-core plywood, which is veneer core center with 1/8" MDF on both sides under the face veneers. It is sold mostly as 3/4" material, but you can get it in 1/2", usually with birch veneer on the B side. It has the advantage of being about 25% lighter than MDF, which is the flattest core material you can get.

Finally, a huge factor in frame-and-panel door flatness is the joinery itself. Your mortise and tenon cheeks must be perfectly parallel to the faces of the stiles and rails or else the joints won't be flat. If you don't have a horizontal mortiser, you'll have to devise a good way to ensure that the mortises and tenons are straight. Also be sure that the shoulders are at 90º to the faces of the stiles and rails. I advise dry assembly with all tenons installed, to make sure the assembly lays flat on a flat assembly surface without clamps. Then, when you actually glue up the doors, make sure that your clamps are not putting any kind of torquing forces on the joints or the doors themselves. K-body-style clamps seem to have less of a tendency to torque assemblies than pipe clamps do.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#5

Let us know if it works

Bill Tindall

Personally I would not risk fabricating a door that large from frail 3/4" material and a single panel. I have never seen a piece of 1/4" plywood that stayed flat in such a large size so I would plan on a frame sturdy enough to hold the panel flat. I have made 3 panel doors (raised solid wood panels) that large with 1 1/8" frames and they have stayed flat. I am guessing most shops would make a 3 panel door for this application similar to a bifold closet door.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#6

Re: Another thing to watch out for...

Phil

Lots of food for thought here. 5/4 quarter-sawn might yield 1" or a little less final thickness (assuming I get nice flat rough stock to begin with). I keep wondering if I re-saw stock to end up with a lamination of 3 layers 3/8" each: total 1 1/8" door thickness: the question is will a lamination yield a flatter end product?

Joinery: maybe its folly to consider, but I was honestly considering either 1/2" stub tenons (just like I've built all my kitchen cabinet doors) with 1/4 cherry ply (mdf core) glued full perimeter into frame of door, or cope/stick joint (typical rail/stile router bit set) again with same glued-in cherry panel. I think I will have to make some compromises in order to have a fighting chance of finishing 19 linear feet of cabinets/window seat. One compromise is the 1/4 ply doors. I agree, solid doors feel and look better, but making all those solid panels is not something I relish, and the one additional advantage of the ply is that its structural, rather than just floating, and adding weight to the door. So I guess the question is: will stub tenon/cope stick with glued panels yield a door that will be structurally sound? If no way, then I would forget the cope/stick with the thumbnail profile, just go with simple Shaker square edge stiles/rails, and go with full mortise/tenons using FMT jig.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#7

Re: Let us know if it works

Phil

I have these aforementioned IKEA wardrobes with doors that are about 6 1/2 feet tall and about 18" wide. They are 3/4" thick, made of some indeterminate material, and have been flat for about (no exaggeration) 30 years! I was assuming that my doors are modestly larger in scale, but could be built roughly the same way. What I lack is the recipe they used to engineer the material for these doors. Lacking that, I guess I will have to make up in mass/scale what I will be lacking in an engineered material. I am re-thinking the 3/4" thick approach: maybe 1" quarter-sawn with full mortise/tenon is Plan B.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#8

Definitely use rift or quatersawn for the stiles


Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#9

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

Jerry Gibbs

Stiles are critical. Start with flat stock, not stock that you have made flat.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#10

not necessary

Bill Tindall

The model for such a door is a typical folding door which are of this size. These are successfully made from randomly oriented lumber and normal sized M&T joinery and typically 2 or three panels. There is nothing about qtr. sawed lumber that would make it any less apt to bow or bend. It is only more stable to cupping, something of no consequence in a narrow frame.

In principal any lumber that stays straight for a few days after being prepared to size will remain so forever unless stressed by some other factor...in your case the crappy plywood we have to endure now days. Thicker stock will resist more stress and that is the only reason to use thicker stock; it is not inherently more apt to stay straight.

These doors are made 2 or 3 panel to reduce and average the potential stress from the panel moving. The panel may move in response to moisture changes; the frame won't to any significant amount. If you are confident you can find plywood that will stay flat the 3/4" frame and one panel will be fine.

PS this week I saw one sheet of plywood in a stack that was the shape of a potato chip and bent out of plane 6". The rest remained mostly flat. I suspect they were all flat when the left the Chinese factory.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#11

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

Phil

The rough stock has been in a climate controlled (dry) environment for a number of years, all stickered, just waiting to be turned into something: I have that aspect of the job covered.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#12

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

Phil

Cross bracing: I did that on a big garden gate I built years ago, but never on furniture, interesting idea. Since I am one of the slowest woodworkers I know, I normally mill in stages over a period of days, leaving everything stickered between milling sessions. No lumber goes into a project in my shop until it is well rested.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#13

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

Phil

Good point. I will have to sort through the wood stash to see just what I have available.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#14

Re: not necessary

Phil

Ok, the dissenting opinion is making me rethink the plan, again. I was assuming that rift/quarter-sawn stock was a step in the right direction. Very good point: it may not buy me much in terms of producing a flat door that stays flat. Treating the plywood (mdf core) as a structural element of the design, with panels supporting the frame, can you envision the successful use of cope/stick or stub tenons in such a door (as opposed to standard MT joints)? I can certainly do MTs, but I was hoping to do a thumbnail profile with a cope/stick router bit set, and I was making a bold assumption that the panels would make up for the structural rigidity that traditional mortise and tenon joints would have provided.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#15

Ellis Walentine

Materials and scale

Ellis Walentine

The short answer is that, yes, you can rely on a glued-in, man-made board panel to reinforce a less-than-structural frame. The more complicated answer is that for this approach to work, the man-made-board (MDF or ply or Mende-core or whatever) has to be structurally adequate to the task, as it isn't getting much help from the frame. Imagine a door made from a 1/2" x 22 x 96 piece of MDF. Even if it stays flat, it would feel floppy, as it has very little structural stiffness. For a door this size, a single 3/4" thickness of MDF might be stiff enough, depending on the dimensions and number of frame members, but you'd have a couple other issues to deal with: First, the doors would weigh about 50 lbs. each. (MDF weighs about 45 lbs./cu. ft., or about 100lb. per sheet of 3/4" material.) I don't know if these doors are inset or overlay, or how you plan to hinge them; but if you plan to use European hinges, you'd need at least five hinges per door. I wouldn't recommend inset doors with butt hinges for this job. Second, in order for your flat panel to be recessed from the front and back faces, say 3/16" and 1/16" respectively, your rails and stiles would need to be at least 1" thick.

Regarding your proposal to rely on cope-and-stick cutters to provide a structural frame, I never do this, ever. A lot of people do, and they get away with it most of the time. But, if someone closes the door wrong, or falls into it when it's open, or otherwise twists it, that glueline is next to useless. If you reinforce the corners with slip tenons, which isn't as tough as it might appear, you can still use your cope and stick cutters yet have a much stronger joint. And, regardless of what kinds of hinges you use, they will be attached to the hinge stiles of your door. I would recommend that those stiles be really well attached to the panel and rails.

Finally, if your design can possibly stand one or more additional rails, the added shoulder strength will contribute more to flatness than just about anything else. In fact, you didn't mention the width of your rails, but the taller you make them, the more shoulder (and/or cope and stick interaction) you will have and the more the door will resist racking in the flat plane.

To recap, personally, I'd go with at least a 1" frame, with at least one middle rail, and use 1/2" Mende-core ply for the panels, glued in, with five self-closing Euro hinges per door. And I'd use loose tenons in the stile-rail joints.

Ellis

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#16

Re: Materials and scale

Phil

All points well taken: maybe it is time to graduate to the big leagues. I've used stub tenons for all my cabinet/built-in doors. Once I find a technique I can master, I generally stick with it. It may be time to expand my horizons and get my Mortise and Tenon merit badge. I will investigate combining the cope/stick profile with loose tenons, and if I can't make this work, then square edge profile and regulation MT joints are the order of the day.

As far as rails, there will be, at this stage of the design, top, bottom, and 3 intermediate. Rail/stile width is on the order of 2 1/4" +/-. These were going to be full overlay (can't imagine trying to fit inset 8' doors), with Blum soft close hinges. I will have to calculate the weight of the combined rail/stile material and the plywood just to make sure I am well within the load rating of these hinges.

Rail/stile thickness: agree that there are a multitude of reasons to go bigger on this dimension, not the least of which is simply the look: after some reflection, those IKEA doors (which have been flat for about 30 years) just look flimsy, and I'd like to get the look right on these, given the vast of expanse of this installation. Fatter it is.

Side note: thanks to Ellis and all contributors: I have learned, and continue to learn so much from this forum, which is why I continue to hang around this neighborhood. I will provide updates (whether I am triumphant, or simply go down in flames).

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#17

Butt hinges? Why not?

Bill Tindall

Three hold up bi-fold, entry or passage doors just fine. A tightly mortised butt hinge provides exceptional support for a door. The vertical load is mostly supported by the wood with the screws just holding the assembly in place.

I agree on the cope and stick. I have seen numerous busted joints on large doors made this way.

The space this door is to fill is exactly the kind of space traditionally filled by a bi-fold door. If it is treated that way with a door made and hinged like a bi-fold the result will be successful.

I do agree that dividing the opening into two or better 3 sections would result in a more robust and stable construction and maybe look better too.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#18

Re: Materials and scale

NickinMass

Now that you've gotten over the hump on going to thicker stock for the frame, you might also consider thicker ply for the panel. 1/2" ply wil get rid of that hollow sound/feel that you get from 1/4" ply panels (I did a kitchen with 1/4" plywood panel doors years ago - I wouldn't do it again because of that problem).

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#19

coping the M&T door

Bill Tindall


This picture shows one way to gain the appearance of a coped door with molding. The molding is ripped away, ending in a miter on the mortise piece. The tenon piece has the molded portion mitered to join the miter of the mortise piece.

There is another way that involves carving a short section of the cope but I could not explain it readily. Personally I find the mitered approach more reliable to achieve a good joint.

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#20

Ellis Walentine

Mason's miter

Ellis Walentine

The "mason's miter" that you describe is commonly used when the frame members have a molding profile. It is a tidy way to get the molding profile to turn the corner continuously.

Ellis

Re: Making Big Built-In Cabinet Doors

#21

Ellis Walentine

You're right....

Ellis Walentine

.... about butt hinges being structurally ideal for hanging heavy doors. But, you can't hang an overlay door with butt hinges. There are wrap around hinges that would do the trick, but they don't allow the three-axis adjustment of European hinges. And I really think that overlay is the way to go here, with the very real possibility that there will be some need for adjustments on doors this size, regardless of how hard you try to keep them flat.

Ellis