Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

finishing nightmare!

Posts

finishing nightmare!

#1

finishing nightmare!

eliot d

I am working on a table top of very beautifully figured cherry. I sanded to 180 and then used hand scrapers to get a really nice surface on it and followed up first with Velvet Oil, to bring out the figure, and then a coat of spar varnish, because it will be a vanity top in a bathroom. I let the oil dry over night and the next day applied the first coat of varnish. Tonight I started to sand the finish with 220 -- AND THEN THE NIGHTMARE STARTED! Everything turned a kind of spotty, streaky, white. It was a real mess! I had to hand scrape it all off and start over. (The stuff on the hand scraper looked like fine cheese particles.) It now has a coat of Velvet Oil again, and that's where I left it tonight. Perhaps I should have listed to some of you who suggested polyurathane. But I had the spar varnish and have used it successfully mixed with oil and solvent on turnings. My theory is that I didn't let the spar varnish dry sufficiently, but I really don't know. For the last table top I did, I used multiple coats of Waterlox with fine sanding between all coats except the last one. That worked perfectly. What do you all think went wrong here. Please help!

Re: finishing nightmare!

#2

Ellis Walentine

Sounds like you may have figured it out

Ellis Walentine

If the varnish went on nicely and seemed to be drying properly, you may have rushed the sanding. I'm not sure how bad it is to mix and match all these coats of different products, but it might be fine. At this point, I'd let the finish dry until you can't sink a thumbnail into it easily, then scuff sand and continue with the varnish, or go for a top coat of polyurethane.

Ellis

Re: finishing nightmare!

#3

Must be a hard varnish to sand it

Bill Tindall

Spar varnish is by definition a soft flexible varnish and it may take days to weeks to fully harden. Depending on conditions it may take oil days to fully cure so that it doesn't soften the finish applied upon it. A good rule of thumb on oil, or any varnish, is if it smells like oil or varnish it isn't fully cured and hence not fully hardened.

Bottom line- the oil must be fully cured or it will soften the finish applied to it. The varnish must be cured and it must be a hard varnish to be able to sand it.

Re: finishing nightmare!

#4

Re: Sounds like you may have figured it out

eliot d

There were just two finishes: Velvet Oil and spar varnish.The varnish was McCloskey Man O'WarSpar Marine Varnish. I called Valspar customer service. The guy there pretty much agreed with what I'm hearing here -- he said possibly not dry enough on the oil or the varnish. And he also recommended poly -- Cabot brand, their brand, naturally. It may be useful to some that when I did this a while back with Waterlox, eveything worked perfectly. So I'll wait till I can't smell any oil on the wood and use either Waterlox again or a good brand of polyurethane. The good news is that the surface seems even smoother than before because I had to start over.

Re: finishing nightmare!

#5

Re: Sounds like you may have figured it out

Howard Acheson

Velvit Oil is a just a pretty standard oil/varnish mixture similar to Watco and Minwax Tung Oil Finish. It's a wipe-on wipe-off finish that is absorbed into the wood. It takes 24 - 48 hours to dry enough to be overcoated. Overcoating too soon will greatly reduce the oxygen needed for the Velvit Oil to dry. In addition and overcoat of a soft, oil heavy varnish like spar varnish will have it's drying time extended.

As suggested, give the Velvit Oil longer to dry and let the spar varnish dry for 4-5 days before attempting to sand or rub out.

Re: finishing nightmare!

#6

Re: Must be a hard varnish to sand it

Steve Schoene

I'll mention this again. Spar varnish ISN"T more waterproof than the other oil based varnishes. It fact, it is less because it is formulated to be flexible, not to be waterproof. An interior varnish such as Waterlox or Behlen Rockhard will be considerably more water resistant.

I also doubt that anyone could tell, after all the finish coats have been applied whether you applied a coat of an oil/varnish mix first. Unless the oil/varnish was extremely different in color, the varnish itself would have virtually the same effect on "popping figure" as would oil or an oil/varnish mix.

But, from where you are now, giving plenty of time for cures to occur before over coating or sanding is the way to go, as has already been said.

Re: finishing nightmare!

#7

Re: finishing nightmare!

Richard McComas

Here's a good read about spar varnish. Not what you want in you bathroom.

http://www.hardwoodlumberandmore.com/Articles/ArticleViewPage/tabid/75/ArticleId/1/Marine-Varnish.aspx

Re: finishing nightmare!

#8

Re: finishing nightmare!

eliot d

Well, I finally settled on MinWax satin wipe-on polyurathane. I wipe on a coat, let it dry overnight, rub with 0000 steel wool, and wipe on another coat. I even opted for good rags instead of paper towels. There are three coats now, and I plan one more. I must say it's a beautiful finish. It definitely looks hand rubbed with no sense of anything on top. It has great depth. I agree, now , that I probably didn't need to used the Velvet oil first. This process, once I got it right, was so easy that I can't see why I would ever try the brush varnish, sand, brush varnish, etc., method again. Thanks for your comments.