We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Bought a couple Wusthof knives about 6 months ago. When they were new just the threat of the knife would cause a tomato to split in two; not so much any more.
I can get plane irons and chisels to shave hairs quite readily, but for some reason it just doesn't translate to knives.
I would appreciate it if you guys could share your methods for getting that super-sharp, brand new edge back.
I hang around with an avid hunter who's father collects knives. They both use the Lansky jig. It allows you to hold the same angle each time you sharpen.
I have the basic system, which puts a very sharp, even, repeatable edge on my knives. If I had it to do over, and was feeling wealthy, I might spring for the diamond version.
+1 on the Lansky. You can even get a ceramic stone that works well on serrated blades. In fact, I have to warn my wife when I've redone the bread knife so she is a little more careful with it than she was the first time I sharpened it. Nobody likes blood on their bread.
I have a system made by Norton. It is 2 ceramic rods, maybe 5/16 diameter that are place in drilled holes in a wooden base. The holes are at a slight angle, maybe +15 degrees for one and -15 degrees for the other. All I have to do is pass the blades a few times across one stone and then the other stone and the knives are honed razor sharp. I do this 2 times a year. It takes less then 10 minutes to sharpen the entire set of 7. I was given a set of Cuisinart knives about 20 years ago, by the man that started the company, and they cut as well today as when I first got them.
If I have to sharpen some other knife that has not been maintained and needs a lot, I first use my 1 by 42 belt sander with a 320 grit sleeve to do the roughing before I finish with the ceramic stones.
Sharpening and refining edges are different objectives. I sharpen for a kitchen supply company, and use my Makita horizontal waterstone rig.
My personal Wusthofs are sharpened on the same rig.
When I get knives that have been used to change tires instead of cutting, I'll use the coarse stone to reshape the edge. Then follow up with the fine stone to sharpen. The steel will refine the sharpened edge.
I do not stone any edges unless they are to be used for sushi. The sushi knife is very flexible, and is used for light cutting.
I always put a note with the finished knives telling the owner NOT to put them in a dishwasher.
My edges are finished at about 5 degrees. VERY sharp.
Boning knives @ about 10 degrees 'cause the blades are thicker.
I've only tried a sharpening steel once or twice, but I don't remember getting a jagged edge, and can't envision how it could happen. What am I missing?
In the late 1990s, I went to the American Woodworker show in King of Prussia, PA. That was back when AW was (IMHO) a very fine magazine and getting better with each issue. The show was huge and had many well known presenters at free seminars: Mike Dunbar, Ian Kirby, Frank Klaus, and...Leonard Lee!
Mr. Lee gave an excellent 2 hour seminar on sharpening. When it came to sharpening knives, he showed his technique for quickly sharpening knives using Lee Valley's narrow belt sander. I have no idea if the story he told was true, or just for entertainment. But he said that when he was invited to someone's house for dinner, he sometimes...instead of bringing a bottle of wine for a hostess gift...would bring his narrow belt sander and offer to sharpen the hostess' knives. He said it was always a hit.
I was so impressed, I ordered one of the belt sanders a few weeks later. It does an amazing job of sharpening knives and carving tools. You can buy almost an unlimited variety of belts for it, including leather strops.
Mr. Lee was a wonderful teacher and was not there to hawk his products. His focus was to show lots of tricks to make sharpening easier. I learned so much from him and the other woodworking giants at that show.
My father has been gone now for almost 4 years. But when he was alive, every time he came to visit me he would bring his knives (and sometimes his neighbors knives) for me to sharpen. Now, every time I see the sander in my shop I smile and think of Mr. Lee and my dad.
Disclaimer: No financial interest in Lee Valley, just a very satisfied customer for about the last 20 years.
Using a sharpening steel doesn't remove steel. but reforms the edge. It does indeed leave a microscopically serrated edged, all the better for slicing a tomato. I suppose all knives could harbor bacteria if you don't wash them, but to think a steel sharpened blade is going to harbor bacteria any more than any other blade is silly. It does leave a better cutting edge on carbon steel than any other method I've tried. I did take a microscopic photo of my favorite slicing knife after steel sharpening one time and that's how I know it leaves a serration.
I have a Delta machine that includes a small disk sander as well. The narrow belt does an excellent job of sharpening knives as you said. I keep a variety of belts here all purchased, except the original one, from Lee Valley.
Leonard Lee wrote an excellent book on sharpening. I highly recommend it.
The 1"x42" belt sander is a versatile workhorse in my shop. With a light touch and a charged cork belt I have no qualms whatsoever in honing my pre-war J.A. Henckels knives. And that's pre-WWI, by the way.
I've got the Delta with 8" combo disc, but the Viel belt sander LV carries is excellent, as is the Kalamazoo. With the LV/Viel, especially for knife sharpening, it's nice to wire the motor to run clockwise (running the belt upward from the toolrest).