Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Floor finish question

Posts

Floor finish question

#1

Ellis Walentine

Floor finish question

Ellis Walentine

I'm debating whether to finish some pine flooring in our house with Waterlox rather than polyurethane. For all the Waterlox I've used in the past 30 years, I have never had occasion to use it on a softwood floor. I'm thinking that its flexibility might be an asset, but I'm concerned about its relative lack of abrasion resistance. I think it will scuff too easily.

Any thoughts?

Ellis

Re: Floor finish question

#2

Re: Floor finish question

Chuck in Mtl.

is it possible the floor may need refinishing more often if this product is used? I would be concerned that pine will dent and wear more easily than hardwood.

Re: Floor finish question

#3

Re: Floor finish question

Jim Dillon

Hi Ellis,

I have no experience with Waterlox, but I used four coats of Park's satin polyurethane on new heartwood pine flooring. I should mention that we also have three 70-80 pound dogs that have really scratched up the soft pine, but I can see no flaking of the polyurethane after seven years or so. So I guess the polyurethane is flexible enough to hold up, yet the underlying soft wood takes a beating. As you might guess, the oil-based PU adds an amber color which I like, but you may like a more neutral color. I diluted the first coat with mineral spirits, then brushed on the remaining three coats straight from the pail. I have read of a technique where gloss PU is used for all except the final coat, then a satin PU is used as the final coat (if one wants a satin finish). The rational is that gloss PU has a higher solids content so will hold up better. As I found out, don't dilute the first coat of satin PU too much or the silica will precipitate out leaving a cloudy surface. Fortunately, the second coat of PU solved the problem. I have read good revies for BonaKema (sp?) floor finishes, but have no experience with them. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Floor finish question

#4

Re: Floor finish question

steve mackay

Don't know about that stuff but 40 years ago we put Varathane (tough enough to skate on) on Mom & Dad's yellow pine floors in their 120 year old home. Its still there and still looks good. While I've swtched to MinWax for my models (because of cost and viscosity) if I were doing floors, I'd spend the big bucks for the original. I'd have a warm fuzzy knowing I wouldn't be doing it again. : )

(just the ARMY think'n out loud)

Re: Floor finish question

#5

Re: Floor finish question

Walter

If it is soft white pine... the best finish is raw oil like Linseed... as many coats as you can until it stops accepting oil. Then buff dry.

You could if you want a surface coating... go back a month or so lather, then put the Waterlox on.

Pine will easily scratch and dent no matter what you do. I have never in 40 years used Poly... it is like putting a plastic bag on wood and stripping it in the future is a pain.

Anything I would do from now on would only get oil then a Beeswax Buff.

Re: Floor finish question

#6

Ellis Walentine

Interesting idea, Walt

Ellis Walentine

I will try oiling some samples today to see how it looks and how it acts. The thing I like about the idea of starting with long oil is that you can varnish over it with Waterlox or other standard varnish later, and even put poly over it in the future. You can't do those things in reverse order though.

We refinished these floors with poly about 20 years ago and they looked great, as someone else suggested, for 5-10 years with no maintenance or recoating. But they did get dented up, as you'd expect with white pine, and the heavy foot traffic through our old farmhouse eventually broke through the poly film and started wearing into the wood. I suppose we could have spot-stained and overcoated the existing finish, but poly doesn't lend itself to repairs very well. That's why we are considering Waterlox. It will offer the moisture- and stain-resistance of a varnish, but it is not plastic like polyurethane, so repairs should be a lot easier.

I had never heard of the linseed oil approach. My first thought is that it might darken the wood too much, especially over time. If you say otherwise, it might be worth a try. Nothing to lose. I'd kinda like the matte finish appearance for a change. It might look really rich and original.

Thanks for the tips, everyone.

Ellis

Re: Floor finish question

#7

Re: Interesting idea, Walt

Walter

If you want to wood to remain as light in color as possible... then skip the oil and look at an Acrylic Clear Floor Finish. You will need 3-4 good coats to do it right.

Yes, oils will darken woods and yes over time it will reach that Honey color. But... Linseed Oil is amazing... Especially Raw... as it contains no chemical additives.

While "Boiled" will dry faster because it has driers added... I am staying away from anything with petrochemicals in it.

Pure Turps is my solvent of choice.

If I were doing this on raw wood I would cut the Raw oil by 10% with Turps for the first 2-3 coats. Then Straight Raw oil, and then once I have seen that evey area of the floor has soaked up all it can. After a long cure time (preferrably during a hot time or year or with added heat... Then you can buff the floor with ultra fine scotchbrite or steel wool with a little Beeswax.

Re: Floor finish question

#8

Ellis Walentine

What about the logistics of an oil finish?

Ellis Walentine

Let's say I wanted to go for this raw oil treatment, wouldn't I have to wipe off the excess after every coat? And wouldn't it be oily and sticky? What if it just happened to get some footprints, or paw prints, or mud, or canary feathers or dog hair on it? (You can see where this is going...)

The nice thing about a film-forming finish (or even boiled linseed oil) is that it does dry in some finite amount of time. I'm going to make some samples of various options. Thanks for the inspiration.

Ellis

Re: Floor finish question

#9

Re: What about the logistics of an oil finish?

Walter

I never said it was an easy finish to deal with. The solution for you IF you hwant to live in and on the finish is a thinned version, putting real thin coats on over and over... buffing out after 15-30 min to remove any excess.

I've done this with Furniture while in use and over a long period of time, it stopped accepting more oil and we used the furniture all the time.

Oil finished will collect dust and darken, but... not that much if you use turps and not petroleum products. Petroleum solvents actually attract dust.

Re: Floor finish question

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: What about the logistics of an oil finish?

Moses Yoder

I was reading the Waterlox guide to floor finishing this morning, on the Waterlox site. With their finish they suggest going 24 hours with no contact on the floor, I think another 48 with just socks, and then you can put area rugs down but they need to be taken off every night for 7 days. So basically it takes 7 days to cure. Oil would never actually cure, and I think you would take the same precautions maybe stretched out a little. Waterlox suggested that their finish is used for very high end clients. I think it would be interesting to try it and see what happens. I think it would soak in enough that a scratch wouldn't penetrate the finish so wouldn't be very visible. Plus with a low luster scratches aren't as visible.

Re: Floor finish question

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: This will take a leap of Faith to accept, but.

Jesper, Denmark

We have soft pine floors. Old ones, like from the origin of the house, built in 1923. They have no doubt been mistreated several times in their lifetime, and then sanded down to raw wood.

The now (and then too) traditional finish is to wash with a strong soapflake solution, say ½ pound of flakes in a half bucket of hot water. Apply with a mop, and mop damp after and let dry. Cleaning is done with damp mopping with a ½ strenghth solution.

The soap penetrates the wood and leaves a sorta non-stick surface.

I was sceptical at first, too, but have now lived in this house for 10 years, and just love it. The floors have a raw look to them - not shiny, but REAL wood, which woodnuts just go crazy over.

I would be very interested to hear of anybody across the pond, who has the wherewithall to try it.

Re: Floor finish question

#12

Re: This will take a leap of Faith to accept, but.

Walter

Yup, that is the way old floors were treated, just soap and water, scrubbed clean and let dry. They eventually get a look that cannot be replicated. Not for me though. I like Raw Linseed oil.

We did a Parquet Oak floor once where we used 55 Gal of Oil on it and basically saturated the old dry wood completely. Then buffed clean and lightly sanded vbefore putting a Gloss Floor varnish on it.

It stopped all the squeaks in the floor sealed every crack and gave a good base for the varnish. That was over 30 years ago, and I have not heard of any changes or problems.

Many methods and paths lead to a desired outcome. We all just have different desires and end results.

I would at least recommend one coat of 90% Raw Linseed Oil and 10% Turps for a sealer coat, buffed dry over the peroiod of a week before puttong a Floor Varnisjh on.

NOTE: Floor Finishes are very different than Furniture Finishes. They have more grab (less slippery)

Re: Floor finish question

#13

JL

Another leap of faith...

JL

An alternative to waiting longer times to dry - ozone generators.

The ozone reacts with the unsaturated fatty acids in the raw linseed oil - essentially causing the formation of a more reactive species. The fatty acids can then cross-link more quickly.

Ozone generators can sometimes be rented. They are also effective in getting rid of odors and the like.

Yet another alternative (DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME!) is ionizing radiation. Gamma rays and low X-rays work quite well.

Re: Floor finish question

#14

Re: Floor finish question

Dick Coers

The smell of that much Waterlox would drive me out of the house. But with that canary around, you would have a perfect alarm of when to leave the house for fresh air!

Re: Floor finish question

#15

Rick L

Re: Woca oil *LINK*

Rick L

Look at the Woca oil.

http://www.bloglines.com/company/33272488/post/665676


Woca oil

Re: Floor finish question

#16

Re: Floor finish question

Thomas S Stockton

Ellis

My wife and I used waterlox on our floors and it has held up OK. Our floors are old growth vg redwood and because the floor is thick lumber laid directly on beams like in a barn there was no way we were going to get a pristine look, so we went for more of a well worn warehouse floor idea. The waterlox was perfect after drum sanding the floors it went on really easy and the hardest part about reapplication will be moving furniture around.

I think it would work fine, but the trade off seems to be that it won't last as long as poly but should be pretty easy to redo.

Tom

Re: Floor finish question

#17

Re: Interesting idea, Walt

Steve Schoene

Raw linseed oil takes about forever to cure--a month or more? Boiled linseed oil doesn't add petrochemicals to make it cure faster, it adds mineral salts--albeit possibly carried in a trivial amount of solvent. When the oil cures those salts are bound up in the natural plastic resin that results.

Waterlox isn't an oil of course it is a varnish pure and simple not a mix of oil and varnish. The ingredients, as in every oil based varnish, are an oil--in the case of Waterlox Tung Oil, and resin, phenolic. There is a touch of pine rosin as well. Phenolic resin is very tough, and with the tung waterlox is a very water resistant varnish. It is also relatively dark in color, and the phenolic resin has a tentancy to yellow over time. (Remember how yellow old bakelite radio cases are?) Bakelite is a brand name for a phenolic resin

I don't think there would be much, if any visual difference between Waterlox over linseed oil and Waterlox alone. The oil is likely a smaller molecule and might penetrate more deeply (a tiny bit) than Waterlox, but the cured oil would be much softer, probably even softer than the wood, so there wouldn't be any functional benifit from that extra oil.

If you want tough, then I'd go with a schedule of two coats of Bona Kemi deep tone sealer (so it looks a bit oiled) followed by three coats of a really tough floor finish such as the Bona Traffic or Mega. These are waterborne, catalyzed topcoats that wear quite well. If you used them directly over the pine without the deep tone sealer the floor might look almost as if unfinished. The plus is two coats in a day, walk, lightly, the next. Also the odor is much less lingering, though you still want ventilation. Ethylene glycol is still not completely benign.

Re: Floor finish question

#18

Re: Floor finish question

Brad

I put down 1100 sq ft red oak two years ago and finished with waterlox. I did all the work myself and saved alot. I feared using poly and screwing up the application. Waterlox is almost fool proof. Lessons learned though: 1) vent the house with a fan per instructions - you need the air exchanges to get the finish to dry properly (otherwise you could get bubbles in the finish), 2) three coats will not be enough on red oak, needed four - instructions say four coats for pine - may need five. 3) highly recommend final coats in satin vs. semi gloss - I used semi gloss and one can see the scuff marks around the house. 4) try to use the orginal formula not VOC compliant. Cheaper and better. 5) most important, clean any new lamb's wool applicator with mineral spirits first - you may find, as I did, an applicator that has very fine grit in it. Not cleaning first per instuctions means it ends up on the floor in the finish.

I have a very particular builder friend that stated he has never see a floor as good as mine. Yes the dog will scratch the finish, but I've seen dogs scratch through poly too. If you use the pre finished flooring, almost nothing will scratch through that finish, but I don't like the look.

Re: Floor finish question

#19

Re: Interesting idea, Walt

eliot d

Steve, you have confused me: you say that Waterlox has tung oil in it, but you also say it is not a mixture of oil and varnish. I always thought Waterlox is a long oil varnish. What am I missing?

Re: Floor finish question

#20

David Barnett

Not that big a leap *LINK*

David Barnett

It's a nice finish, Jesper. I've used it to avoid the dirty look some oils produce in woods like aspen. Beautiful on pine. Some throw in a bit of potash to grey it slightly.


Flexner on soap treatment

Re: Floor finish question

#21

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Not that big a leap

Jesper, Denmark

Surprisingly, it is quite durable. I have heád this on my kitchen and living room floors for ten years now, and regular vacuuming with a monthly or so damp mopping with the soap solution does the trick.

Not shiny like a film finish, but very easy to manitain.

Re: Floor finish question

#22

David Barnett

Apparently durable enough for floors and tables...

David Barnett

...and if you don't let spills sit too long, easy to keep stain-free.

I love it on bleached woods. My pair of floor-standing speakers is bone bleached eucalptus with soap. Beautiful. As I mostly eschew shine on pale woods - a dry application of rubbed beeswax is almost too much for me - soap suits me perfectly. I've no personal experience with floors (mine are all terrazzo), but I've seen soap treated floors and really like the look.

Although soap flakes aren't as common in the U.S. these days, you can still find them at a few stores and all over the net. One can also shave or grate bar castile, either commercial or homemade (it's easy - it's fun). Pure olive oil makes a harder bar, but many use palm and coconut in addition to mostly olive. I can't tell the difference on wood as a finish, although a pure olive bar makes a somewhat slimy gel to the touch when water is added.