Re: Interesting idea, Walt
Steve Schoene
Raw linseed oil takes about forever to cure--a month or more? Boiled linseed oil doesn't add petrochemicals to make it cure faster, it adds mineral salts--albeit possibly carried in a trivial amount of solvent. When the oil cures those salts are bound up in the natural plastic resin that results.
Waterlox isn't an oil of course it is a varnish pure and simple not a mix of oil and varnish. The ingredients, as in every oil based varnish, are an oil--in the case of Waterlox Tung Oil, and resin, phenolic. There is a touch of pine rosin as well. Phenolic resin is very tough, and with the tung waterlox is a very water resistant varnish. It is also relatively dark in color, and the phenolic resin has a tentancy to yellow over time. (Remember how yellow old bakelite radio cases are?) Bakelite is a brand name for a phenolic resin
I don't think there would be much, if any visual difference between Waterlox over linseed oil and Waterlox alone. The oil is likely a smaller molecule and might penetrate more deeply (a tiny bit) than Waterlox, but the cured oil would be much softer, probably even softer than the wood, so there wouldn't be any functional benifit from that extra oil.
If you want tough, then I'd go with a schedule of two coats of Bona Kemi deep tone sealer (so it looks a bit oiled) followed by three coats of a really tough floor finish such as the Bona Traffic or Mega. These are waterborne, catalyzed topcoats that wear quite well. If you used them directly over the pine without the deep tone sealer the floor might look almost as if unfinished. The plus is two coats in a day, walk, lightly, the next. Also the odor is much less lingering, though you still want ventilation. Ethylene glycol is still not completely benign.