Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

Posts

Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#1

JL

Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

JL

My old Dewalt 18 V drill driver may be finally giving up the ghost. You pull the trigger and essentially nothing happens. You pull the trigger and then it runs. It does this with both battery packs. I am going to take it apart and clean it. The drill driver is over 8 years old, possibly more - it has seen a lot of use, so it doesn't "owe" me anything.

Amazon has nearly the same model for $130 or so. If I by that, I can reuse my old battery packs for a while before even charging up the new ones.

Or - I can get another model or another brand. Lithium ion even. I don't really need an impact driver.

Any recommendations or thoughts?

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#2

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

John McGaw

Old-style tool with brushes? After that amount of use I'd be in there at least checking them out since, once they become worn and short, the spring tension no longer holds them to the commutator firmly and the motor may become intermittent. On top of that, loose brushes can cause serious damage to the commutator.

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#3

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

Don Orr

Lowe's has a Dewalt 18V drill/driver on sale right now for $99 while they last. Might even be the same batteries as you have . Drill, charger, 2 batts. case. Good Deal. Got the last one at my local store yesterday. Regular price was listed as $189.

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#4

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

Ralph Lipeles

I had the same problem on my Dewalt 12V. I took off the covers and played with the parts until I could duplicate the problem. I found that one of the push-ons that was crimped to a wire going to the switch had a bad crimp. I squeezed it in Vise Grip and the problem went away.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#5

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Well, after tossing at least 4 battery powered drills/drivers due to the batteries going bad and finding that replacement of the batteries was over 80% of the cost of a new drill kit on sale, I went with the Ridged Drill and Impact driver. They have a lifetime warranty on both the tool and the batteries. It was a real hassle to get them registered, but I did it - I am now having some problems with the batteries so will let you know how the warranty is honored in the near future. I will say the tools have performed to my satisfaction so far. I didn't like the style or weight of the 18V drill so bought the 12V. It has done everything I needed - I use a tailed drill or drill press for heavy work and like a lighter drill for its convenience. I did purchase the 18V impact driver and it works well.

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#6

Second your experience with Ridgid 12 volt

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

I foolishly took a replacement on the first one I bought instead of a refund. the battery charger indicates the battery is faulty when you try to charge it when the battery is not fully discharged. Even fully charged, the drill can be stopped dead doing even easy drilling if set on the "high speed" setting. At the low speed setting, it takes forever to punch a hole in 4/4 white oak. Mine did come with a 1 watt flashlight that is ultra bright, but it has a very awkward shape that limits its usefulness.

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#7

Ridgid - on the third set of batteries now

Hoa in Alameda

I picked up a Ridgid 12V drill kit 6 years ago from my local HD's clearance table. It's compared favorably against my 12V Dewalt (the heavy duty model with metal clutch).

I'm on my third set of Ridgid batteries. There is a Ridgid authorized service center near my house. Each time the batteries went bad, I dropped the whole set (drill, batteries, charger) off and pick it up in about 7 - 10 days. No hassle at all.

With the Ridgid, I have no reason to spend money replacing the batteries for the Dewalt. It's been unused for the last 3 years.

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#8

I didn't think I needed an Impact Driver..

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

either. My wife thought I did, when she said buy a more expensive tool I did. The impact driver is the most used tool I own. The worst part of the whole deal is that she often reminds me that I didn't think I needed it, she thought I did, and SHE was right. She it talking about buy a second impact driver now. I have hex shanked drills, drill/countersinks and a selection of drivers includeing 1/4 and 3/8 socket drivers. I use it for practically every driver task (includeing changing tires, break-em lose and final tighten by hand and the rest...) and most drilling tasks as well. Makita 18v Li-ion. I love it

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#9

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

I have a set of the new 12 volt Lithium Ion Dewalts. The set has a drill, screwdriver and impact driver. I am surprised at the power they have and the batteries last a long time for the type of work I do. The part I like best is how small and light they are.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, Ca

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#10

Re: I didn't think I needed an Impact Driver..

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I wasn't sure either - until I bought one. I love it, it has probably prevented more stripped / broken screws than I could count. I really haven't seen any tool that can do the same work near as well. It will remove old screws that couldn't be removed with conventional means other than drilling them out.

Re: Drill Driver acting up - recommendations?

#11

JL

Thanks for the information!

JL

I bought one today. It isn't the XRP with the large battery - but my old ones batteries are compatible and I can use them with this drill driver.