Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Laminated vs solid wood

Posts

Laminated vs solid wood

#1

Laminated vs solid wood

paul woolson

I'm having a discussion/argument about the strength and stability of laminated wood vs identical solid wood. Keep in mind that I'm not talking about plywood where the grain direction is alternated but something like a GluLam beam. Anyone have a link to some experiments where the two are tested side by side?

Re: Laminated vs solid wood

#2

JL

Re: Laminated vs solid wood *LINK*

JL

Try "Wood as an Engineering Material"

Download part or the whole. It is free.

I think you might look at Chapter 11.


Forest Products Laboratory

Re: Laminated vs solid wood

#3

So, What is the specific issue?

Keith Newton

Each can have advantages and disadvantages, making one better or riskier, more time consuming or difficult. I'm not sure that the strength of one over the other ought to be such an issue, when both are done properly.

Re: Laminated vs solid wood

#4

Re: Laminated vs solid wood

Hal

As a structural engineer (long since retired), I have designed with both solid timber and glulams. The codes generally allow higher working stresses with glulams. Just think of the difficulty in finding a 4 or 6x 14 or 16 as an example. And then think of the likely quality of a timber that size. Probably will have checks and splits, warps, etc. On the other hand, glulams are typically made of 2x (or even 1x for some applications) material which can be quality controlled and produce a beam of uniform quality. Dimensional stability of glulams is also more dependable. I would venture to say that subject to the same testing, a glulam of the same dimensions as a solid timber will accept a greater load before failure. I may have told you how to make a watch when all you asked for was the time of day, but perhaps the foregoing will satisfy some curiosity. Hal