Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Structural Consult

Posts

Structural Consult

#1

Structural Consult

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

OK, Here's the scene. Making a fixed-rail crib that must be taken apart as far as the sides, ends, and bed board go. This drawing is the of the bottom 4" rail which will be made from full 1" stock and the leg which is 2" by 3-1/2".

The rails will be set into the legs with 3/4"x3/4" tenons and held by means of a through-bolt into a dowel nut that is drilled in from the under edge of the rail. Both bolt and nut are 1/4x20. The MT will be tight fitting.

And the question is . . .

1 bolt or 2?

My tendency is to use 2 bolts even though the bed board will also be through-bolted in for additional strength.

What say ye-all?

PS: Sorry, but you have to click on the adobe symbol to see the drawing.

Re: Structural Consult

#2

Re: Structural Consult

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've made four queen sized beds using the rail and leg method you propose. Each of the corners is held together with one bolt, and not ever has any of them even loosened.

Re: Structural Consult

#3

Ellis Walentine

One'll do it

Ellis Walentine

Hi Mark,

Your image didn't post, but the answer to your question is that one bolt per joint should be fine. For regular beds, I usually use 3/8" bolts. For a crib, I'd probably use a 5/16" to be on the safe side, but a 1/4" bolt has more than enough holding power for this application.

Ellis

Re: Structural Consult

#4

Re: Structural Consult - Phase 2

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Thanks for reinforcement.

Now a slight change:

4 bolts in each side should work, but if the spindle sides are changed out for a single bed rail to use as a youth (not yute) bed, I'm concerned about the joint racking whereas two bolts might give greater stability. Am I over-engineering?

Re: Structural Consult

#5

Re: Structural Consult

AZ in Colorado Springs

I built a set of bunk beds, and the tenons were about 4" tall (on a 5" side rail), 1-1/2" deep, and 3/4" wide (I used 5/4 stock). The center of the tenon, about one inch of the span, was shallower, only 1/4" deep. So, the tenon reached deeper into the mortice at its ends. (I hope I described all that clearly enough.) I put a threaded insert into the side rail, and used a single 1/4" bolt through the headboard and footboard post at each end of each side rail.

The point is that the anti racking characteristics derive from the M/T joinery, rather than from the bolts used. While using additional bolts will tend to help limit racking, their force is applied in pulling the joint together (directed inward). If racking is a your concern, then ensure the joint addresses the leverage of the racking forces.

In my example, instead of tenon shoulders just at the tops and bottoms of the tenons, there also were shoulders in the central portion of each tenon.

The bunk beds have been in use with teenagers for 19 months now and I'm told it's all solid as a rock.

Re: Structural Consult

#6

I thought the 1st was fine.

Keith Newton

The little critter will probably chew out the pickets first. Just think of this as being like a chain, only as strong as the weakest link. I'd give it my standard one month warranty, and count myself lucky if I got by. he he

Re: Structural Consult

#7

Re: Structural Consult - Phase 2

Barry Irby

I think you are overthinking it. (I'm guilty of that quite often.) I built a Queen sized bed for my son and DIL several years ago and it has a single bolt similar to yours in the ends of the rails. It's rock solid. I did use a 3/8" bolt and I tend to agree with Ellis that a 5/16" bolt might be better. The joint will be solid unless the bolt stretches or loosens. I made my own and they were powerful. The raking forces are resisted by the shoulders of the tenon pulled hard against the frame. The vertical load is resisted by the bottom edge of the tenon and the diameter of the bolt.

Re: Structural Consult

#8

Thanks All

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

As I want low-profile, wide socket-head bolts I'm limited to 1/4x20. I have, however, decided to increase the shoulders from 1/4" to 1/2" and the tenon to 1" depth. That should address any racking.

Thanks again

M

Re: Structural Consult

#9

Ellis Walentine

None of that is necessary

Ellis Walentine

The shoulders only need to be 1/8" wide to resist racking; 1/4" is more than enough. Also, the length of the tenon isn't critical, nor is a longer tenon going to support more weight than a shorter one. I have built many beds using 1/2" long stub tenons and a single bed bolt.

On the subject of bed bolts, I'm not sure what you mean by low-profile, wide socket-head bolts. A 3/8" cap screw only has about a 17/32" diameter head. You can counterbore it flush with the outside of the leg.

Ellis


Re: Structural Consult

#10

Bolts *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Wide head spreads the stress over a wider area where the stress is along the length of the bolt. Less likely to compress the wood and loosen over time.


Bolts

Re: Structural Consult

#11

Ellis Walentine

Similar to shoulder argument

Ellis Walentine

There's no doubt that a wider head (fillister type) bolt like this sex bolt has a lot of pulling power, but so does a cap screw with just a 1/16" shoulder. It's enough for the task at hand plus a safety factor, assuming you're bolting through hardwoods. I'd give a second thought to softwoods. Some kind of washer might be a good investment in either case.

This discussion is analogous to my earlier post about the size (area) of the shoulder. Wider shoulders aren't the issue; it's having shoulders at all that is the issue. The length of the shoulder is far more important than the width. Similarly, you don't need all the bearing surface of that bolt head; just the narrow land is enough to pull that joint together solidly.

Ellis