Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

I hate Woodworkers!!

Posts

I hate Woodworkers!!

#1

I hate Woodworkers!!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Ok....ok....not true. But there are exceptions! So my gallery lady calls me the other day about a piece I made that was in her gallery. Turns out some "woodworker" came into her gallery and spent a bunch of time going over my work with a fine toothed comb.

After I made this piece a small crack developed at the top....hey, it happens. So I repaired it but depite the repair being successful you could still see where the crack was. I'm pretty picky about my stuff but I did not think this was a big deal.

The gallery lady became paranoid after "Mr. Woodworker" proclaimed it to be a flawed piece. Fine. I retrieved the piece and am making some kind of decorative "saddle" that will be on all 4 sides of the top and cover over the crack.

Ok, yes, I HATE fixing my work! For all I know "Mr. Woodwoker" did me a favor. I'd rather fix it now then after a sale. Harrrumpf! I can't grumble to my gallery so thanks for letting me grumble here.


Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#2

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

Barry

Maybe "Mr. Woodworker" ought to just knock out a couple himself and see if he can do a better job. Nice piece!

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#3

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Thanks. Yes, that thought crossed my mind. I'll be honest though, I think it's hard for woodworkers not to scrutinize other work. I admit I have. But the difference is that I keep my pie hole closed. ;-)

I recently looked over a couple of Maloof pieces. Of course they were perfect. Must have been "beginner's luck". ;-)

T.

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#4

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

Jim Breeden

It seems "Mr. Woodworker" >( was extremely jealous of what you accomplished. What I see is beauty in action.

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#5

Chalk It All Up to Experience/Ignorance

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Tommy,

I've been in similar situations, and it does make a person feel uncomfortable. Count on your unqualified successes, and let the "qualified" successes speak for themselves. Your piece speaks volumes about beauty and craftsmanship and imagination.

George

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#6

You Got Reminded . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"No piece is perfect. Everybody makes mistakes. The real test of the craftsman is how well he hides them."

ps: Change the language for gender neutrality if you're so inclined ;)

pps: Everybody's a freakin' critic :D

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#7

Wood can humble us

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

In this case there were actually 2 cracks. One much smaller than the other. The box is 1/2" thick. Cutting the large circular openings was risky but went well. I finished construction and before I could deliver the piece the two cracks appeared. I know why they happened but I was still surprised. Both cracks were perpendicular to the grain...the wood simply relieved tension at points of least resistance. It happens.

But it is testament to the fact that wood is a natural material that we cannot fully control like other materials. Much as we work to join wood to allow for movement and other techniques, wood can find ways of humbling us.

This is a minor thing. I have heard some real horror stories from other woodworkers. I bet most woodworkers have gotten that dreaded call from a customer 6 mos. later.

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#8

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

Barry

It's a rare piece that has no visible flaws whatsoever! I had a couple of woodworking classes at the college level many years ago. The instructor was simply put, a hard ass, a stickler for detail. He pretty much hated people who registered for his class thinking it was going to be an easy three (3) hours of credit. I think he tried his very best to weed those folks out early in the semester. He had two hard and fast rules. No exceptions.

Rule # 1. No mill marks were to remain on any component of a project. He insisted that all pieces be well-sanded to remove any rotary mill marks. He said, "If I find mill marks on your project, you get an automatic failure." In his view, failure to sand a project well was an indicator of laziness, sloppy work and maybe even a lack of moral character.

Rule # 2. All defects must be filled with wood. If they were tiny, he could tolerate shellac stick. He had a hatred of Plastic Wood or any other wood filler product. He stated, "If I find evidence of Plastic Wood being used on your project, you get an automatic failure."

Needless to say, I learned more in his class than any other. I appreciated his attention to detail and his striving for perfection.

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#9

That Call

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I got one of those informing me that the piece I'd carved from a full elm log, which included the pith of course, had split the night before with such force that the sound prompted the people in the next apartment to call the NYPD to report a gunshot. The customer had placed the piece on top of a steam radiator cabinet, effectively "cooking" it. :O

I thought the story a bit exaggerated until I met the neighbor who confirmed the noise, and spoke to a wood guy who explained about elm's interlocking grain and the energy required. This is the piece after the fact


Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#10

Re: That Call

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I delivered a piece that is made of black walnut. I colored the wood to warm the tone. When I delivered it the client promptly placed in front of a large western window. I warned them that walnut can fade in bright sun and that a shadier place would be better but they wanted to keep it their. I have a feeling I'll eventually get a call.

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#11

Warn Them Again

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

in writing ;)

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#12

Re: Warn Them Again

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I probably should. In fact this discussion might inspire me to write a general guideline and care sheet for all my work. No silicone dust spray!! Cherry not dark enough?....Just wait! etc.

T.

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#13

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

Thomas S Stockton

Thomas

I feel your pain. I had a client who was an amateur woodworker and professional ego maniac, made something small for him and he was fine with it and then came back and showed me every perceived flaw in it. I finally just gave him back his money. Part of the job included tuning a plane iron and he wondered why it was so expensive when he just sent all his chisels and planes out to be sharpened. This from a guy who was always saying his work was finer than most students of Krenov's.

The guy was completely clueless but had a big checkbook.

The funny thing about it is almost all gallery people can spot a woodworker the minute they walk through the door.

This being said I have done some work for some pretty good amateur woodworkers who where the best clients because they understood what was involved

Tom

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#14

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

Ed O'Neill

Tom, I had to laugh when I read your response as it brought back an experience I had with a client and the solution I came up with. Everytime I delivered a peice of furniture to this client he would go over it with a fine tooth comb and would always find something to complain about. The solution I came up with was very simple. I would purposely leave a drip, easily fixed, in a place where he would notice . It gave him the fullfilment he needed and I didn't have to spend much time correcting the blemish. I added to my price a pain in the a--- factor with him and laughed all the way home. Ed

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#15

Re: That Call

Alex Grigoriev

That piece gave a middle finger.

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#16

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

charlie belden

The Put An Obvious Flaw (that's easily fixed) in the first paragraph of a memo, report or other document and you can put even outrageous recomendations after in - and after correcting the obvious mistake at the top, you can get what you really wanted signed off on. Some bosses just want to show off that they're better than you or any underlings by finding fault with everything they do. Give them an obvious fault - and they'll give you almost anything you want ; )

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#17

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

Gary Bindel

My late uncle years ago told me how when he worked as a pipe coverer, he learned to always leave an obvious defect in an easily accessible place for the inspector to find. The inspectors felt they hadn't done their job if they didn't find anything, so he made it easy to satisfiy their need without creating a problem and a lot of work for himself.

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#18

Re: That Call

Bill White

Next thing we'll see is a gov. mandate requiring disclaimers on all woodworking products that will absolve buyers from any responsibility of ownership. Care and maintainance will be a lifelong maker's guarantee.

Now, I've gotta go find the makers of our antiques that have some cracks. Maybe they'll fix 'em. Sure....

Hey! Even trees split.

Bill

Re: I hate Woodworkers!!

#19

Re: That Call

Hal

It appears that personal responsibility is a thing of the past. 'Nuff said!