Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Why is my resawed wood bowing?

Posts

Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#1

Why is my resawed wood bowing?

Ed in NY

Last night I was resawing 8/4 oak boards in half and just when the bandsaw blade was through the entire board the two pieces popped apart both sides bowed away from the direction of the cut. To make it clearer, if I put the two pieces back together , the ends would touch but in the center they were about 1/2" apart over a 48" length. Before anyone asks....these are really old, very dry pieces of wood. I got them from Grizzly in the late 90's and they have been sitting in my shop which is heated and airconditioned since then. I cut apart six of them last night and it happened on all of them, I have another 6 to do. Could it be from the heat of the blade? I'm using a 3/4" blade in the saw and I'm feeding the wood at a normal rate, not overloading the saw at all. This happened before when I resawed some pieces from this lot. I can't understand it. Any insight into this would be helpful. I have the boards clamped flat to my workbench but I hold little hope they'll straighten out. Any advice on how to straighten them would be appreciated too!

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#2

resaw bowing

Bill Tindall

There is stress locked into these lumber. It is common with thick oak because oak must be dried very slowly and sometimes it isn't. Because you see it on most all of the lumber it is a drying defect not stress as a result of some aspect of how the tree grew. This sort of stress can only be relieved by steaming the lumber, a process that will soften the fibers and let the lumber relax.

I discussed some of the reasons how lumber gets stressed in a post about a week ago but I don't recall the post title.

I hope I am interpreting your question correctly. You are in fact ripping the board into two more narrow pieces? Rsawing usually means ripping the board into two thinner pieces of the same width.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#3

David Barnett

Wood can store up quite an attitude

David Barnett

Depends on how the wood was sawn into lumber, its drying profile (air dried? in what conditions, kiln dried? too fast, too hot, etc.), and what's happened since (RH cycles, storage, etc.) -- so many factors. For older oak and a few other species, I take skim passes over the jointer and set it aside for a couple weeks or more (ideally) before resawing.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#4

Re: resaw bowing

Ed in NY

Yes Bill, that's what I'm doing, making the 8/4 board into a 4/4 board. Steaming is probably out of the question. Some boards are better than others so maybe I can salvage something out of these.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#5

Re: Wood can store up quite an attitude

Ed in NY

Thanks, maybe I'll try that with the remaining 6 pieces...

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#6

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

John in NM

Hi Ed,

Since your lumber is likely as dry as it gets, I don't think letting them sit for a week will see any change. If you have the same problem with lumber fresh from the yard that will sometimes do it if the bowing is caused by being wetter on the inside than outside.

You can build a steam box really easily. Just knocked together out of CD plywood with a pipe or hose going to a steam kettle. Hose has to be able to resist the heat of the steam, and should be fairly short to keep from losing all the heat. If you use metal pipe you can super heat the steam by applying a torch to the pipe (saw a neat demonstration in the 8th grade, teacher burned paper with steam by doing this).

You also may not need to remove the bow, depending on how bad it is and what the boards will be used for. Table tops and case work are far more forgiving than door panels :D

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#7

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

Ed in NY

Thanks for the info John...Maybe I'll put this wood aside and try and straighten it out in the future with a steam box. You hit the nail on the head...I am building door panels! I guess I'll have to make a trip to the lumber yard.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#8

white oak or red oak?

Dick Coers

White oak can be a lot tougher to dry than red. The cellular structure of white oak makes it tougher for water to get out. That said, in that amount of time, it should not still had drying issues. It can depend on the type of tree as well. If it was a leaner, it can have what is called reaction wood. There are lots of stresses in reaction wood. I would stand the boards up so air can get all around it and see if it calms down over a week or so.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#9

Re: white oak or red oak?

Ed in NY

It is red oak Dick. I'll try you suggestion as I have nothing to lose. I have it clamped really tight right now and i'll see what it looks like when I get home tonight.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#10

Causes of cupping

Bill Tindall

Again if I understand correctly Ed was in fact resawing the board into two thinner boards and the resulting thinner boards cupped. Cup is across the width of a board; bow is along the length.

Cupping can result from two processes that can be distinguished by how quick it occurs.

If the resawed pieces cup immediately after resawing it is a result of the lumber being stressed. The most common cause of stress is drying, (either air or kiln) the lumber too fast. When dried too fast the interior of the lumber is under tension. When resawed this tension pulls the thinner boards into a cupped configuration. It is very easy to dry oak too fast because of how it dries and the requirement to dry oak very slowly. Stress can also occur from how a tree grew but this isn't the cause of Ed's problem.

If the lumber cups after a day or more, it is because the lumber is gaining or loosing moisture from one side faster than the other. There may have been a moisture gradient across the thickness of the thick piece. Or the resawed lumber may have been stored in a way where one side gained or lost moisture faster than the other.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#11

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

Mike in Suffolk Virginia

I have some curly birdseye maple that cups when I resaw it. How long would you steam it?

Mike in Suffolk Virginia

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#12

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

John in NM

From what I've read about steam bending, you shoot for 1 hour per inch of thickness - I'll admit to having never tried it, but straightening a board would be the same principle as steam bending, you're just clamping against a straight caul rather than a curved one :D

I looked at building a set up a few years ago for making two curved door jambs, and was surprised at how easy it is to do - hard part is building the form and accommodating spring back. Due to my application I ended up making the curves from laminations rather than bent solid.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#13

My advice is to save this for when you need 8/4

Keith Newton

And go buy some more 4/4, when you need it. I don't think you are going to wrestle this wood back to flat, without reducing it to 1/2" on the jointer, turning most of it into shavings.

It probably will be fine for projects where you need 8/4, if you use good techniques, like sawing oversize, letting it settle, then straightening it at full thickness, or taking equal amounts off each face.

It is harder to find thick oak here sometimes, but I can always get 4/4.

You are just buying yourself head aches doing this.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#14

Re: My advice is to save this for when you need 8/

Ed in NY

I was thinking along those lines too, saving it for when I needed some 8/4 stock but that's exactly what I've been doing for the past 13 years or so. Some are worse than others so I might be able to salvage a few pieces.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#15

steaming to relieve stress

Bill Tindall

The wood must become plastic to relax the stress. This will occur as soon as it reaches a moist heat temperature of something near the boiling point of water. Actually it will occur before this temperature but I don't know exactly what temperature and it will depend on humidity. So to be sure sock the steam to it until the wood temperature reaches about 100 C. Then of course the wood needs to be carefully dried so as to not reestablish the stress. The wood will dry quicker than it did the first time because the cells are already largely collapsed and the wood will not hold as much water as it once did.

I have relaxed the stress from a piece of mahogany with a steam iron but it was tedious.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#16

door panels

Bill Tindall

They don't need to be 3/4" thick and maybe they don't need to be perfect on the back side. Can you flatten the cup on the jointer and still have enough thickness to make a panel?

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#17

Re: door panels

Ed in NY

I think I can with some of the pieces, others are too far gone.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#18

Re: resaw bowing

Howard Acheson

>>>> Steaming is probably out of the question. Some boards are better than others so maybe I can salvage something out of these.

Try stacking and stickering the boards as soon as you finish resawing them. Be sure there is some air movement through the stack. Give it two weeks and see if there is any improvement.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#19

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

Yonak

Can you vent a clothes dryer through the box for a heat and moisture treatment ?

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#20

Probably too dry...

John in NM

But you could try with an electric one. Gas dryer has a CO detector or some such to shut off the flame if there is too much back pressure on the vent.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#21

Yes I know. But resaw it today,

Keith Newton

You will need it before the month has passed. Ha

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#22

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

Gary Bindel

That's an interesting idea. We recently got a dryer that has a steam option. You would have to minimize the bends in the ducting, but I don't think it would create any more back pressure than the lint build-up in the lint filter from a load of towels.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#23

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

Eaton474

I didn't read all the comments, but, I will tell you why your wood is cupping, and how to stop it and/or fix it. I will be repeating what a friend and very well known and highly talented woodworker told me.

First, think of wood as a loaf of fresh bread. It can never be as dry on the inside as the outside. Even when kiln dried, the inside will still have a higher MC (moisture content), just like the outer crust of bread is drier than the moist, fluffy inside.

The one difference with wood, is it will always be this way to some degree. It may dry a bit more over time, but the inside will always have more MC, even 250 years from now.

Now, here is how to stop it from cupping after being resawn. There are several ways of dealing with this, each better suited to differing situations. You will need to learn over time which method to use and when, based on the MC content of the wood, it's stress level, how it acts while being sawn, etc.

First, you will need to allow all resawn wood to acclimate for at least 3-5 days after sawing, and a bit longer is better in certain cases.

Now, in general, if it's coming off the saw pretty straight and your just ripping it down the middle, just flip it back to back (the old outsides facing inward) and tightly tape the pieces together. Now, let them acclimate like this. They will pull against each other, and basically remain straight.

If there is a large difference in MC from inside to outside, lightly misting the original outside with water prior to taping them together will help equalize everything and allow it all to dry at a more even rate and keep the wood from pulling too hard. You can also mist the outside with water prior to resawing if it's cupping badlly due to the outside being so much drier than the inside. Using hot water, or even steam, will help the wood absorb the water faster and will work better in many cases.

If the wood cups coming off the saw, you can add a shim at the middle of the boards when taping them together to reverse bend them a bit. This will actually pull the cup out as they dry, and if you used a large enough shim, they will spring back straight after releasing the tape once acclimated. Again, you can mist the outside of the boards and combine the methods.

It may take some trial and error, but it's worth it to learn how to deal with the wood and keep it as straight as possible. Remember, it's easier to hold wood and keep it from cupping, than it is to reverse a cup once it's happened. And the straighter the wood after resawing and acclimation, the less you will need to machine away to get it back to perfect. Just remember, no matter how straight you get the wood to stay, it's almost always going to need some flattening via machines (ie: surfacing sander, jointer or planer) or with handtool methods.

There are other methods too. But the basic principal is to allow the moisture to equalize, and possibly help it along if needed. Wood will cup to the driest side of the board, as dry wood contracts and shrinks. Remember this, and you will soon have this figured out. Well, as much as is possible. Every piece of wood will act differently to some degree. It's just a matter of learning to deal with each situation in the best way for that unique situation. Understanding that wood cups to the dry side is the first step, after that, it will come to you in time and experience.

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

#24

Re: Why is my resawed wood bowing?

Ed in NY

Thanks so much for that detailed solution. I have to say that after this happened I did do some of what you suggested, I clamped the bowed pieces, resawn side out, for about 5 days and when I pulled them apart the cupping was much reduced significantly but not totally gone. It was off about 1/8" over a 4' board, which isn't too bad.

I have a few more pieces I have to resaw, I will try your technique of wetting the outsides of the board prior to cutting.