Re: Shop update
John McGaw
Depending on the details of the shop -- attached to living space etc. there may be no alternative to drywall somewhere in the process. My 'shop', which is half of a largish two-car garage which I divided with a wall, is part of my home and is directly underneath two bedrooms. There is absolutely no leeway with drywall in a situation like this where there are enforced building codes: I must have at least 1/2" drywall on the walls and I must have at least 5/8" drywall on the ceiling and everything must be sealed to prevent car exhaust leakage into the living space. I am just finishing up a retrofit which included closed-cell foam in the garage and shop ceilings and hanging of 5/8" drywall. This was a real PITA since the original 1964 builders did some things like not enclosing all of the wiring and plumbing in the joists and leaving odd bits of framing sticking out. It is all closed and sealed now but it took a lot of fiddly work.
On a related note, I never realized how much storage space I would be giving up since I could no longer stow my cutoffs and small exotics between the ceiling joists as I had been. Having all of that excess stock in an already cramped space made all of the work there painful. I was like a juggler trying to keep five balls in the air at the same time with all of the moving and shifting of tools and wood and miscellaneous crap to do any simple thing. It is better now, at least somewhat, but it will be a while before I can walk in a straight line across the shop.