Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

Posts

OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#1

Ric Taylor

OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

Ric Taylor

I'm planning on a total re-do of my garage to dress it up in a significant way, resulting in 1/2 of the garage being my new shop and still parking the car in the other half.

I plan to cover the concrete floor with either ceramic or porcelain tile. I don't yet know enough about the differences between the two to make a choice (I'm in the very early planning stages).

Being a normal garage floor, there are a few automotive stains on the floor. Nothing major, but they are there, just normal wear and tear. I'm concerned that might effect the adhesion of the tile to the floor. Are there real issues here or is it not significant? Do I have to be concerned with special cleaning treatment of the concrete?

Any thoughts?

Thanks,

Ric

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#2

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, FL

Porcelain and ceramic use different clays. Porcelain is fired at a higher temperature making it vitreous, which is water proof. Ceramic needs some type of coating fired onto it, like a glaze. The last thing I would put on a shop floor is either tile. Drop a tool, like a hammer and the tile will shatter. The groat used to cement it to the floor has to be sealed to prevent moisture and dirt being absorbed into it. And most glazed finishes become as slippery as goose poop when wet.

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#3

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

Neal in San Jose

I'd vote against tile for both of those reasons. The previous owner of my current house had put tile on the back screened-in porch floor, and when it rained, the back door became essentially unusable. It was so slippery it was dangerous. Even walking across wet grass made my shoes wet enough to cause problems. My first "remodel" project was to get that stuff up. I can't imagine what it will be like when you spill a little motor oil.

If you are looking for color to spice it up a little, my vote would be epoxy paint with the texture flakes for traction or vinyl tile, which would resist most dropped tools and maybe even save a chisel edge.

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#4

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor *LINK*

John McGaw

At worst you would have to run a diamond hone on the floor to rough it up and even out any humps (or pay a floor company to do it). This will give enough 'tooth' for the thinset to stick. Porcelain tile would work as a surface but you'd have to be careful to purchase the sort which is rated for wet situations because, as somebody else pointed out, some tile is dangerously slippery when wet. The good stuff has a microscopic grit to it.

If I were doing it, I'd go for one of the plastic/rubber snap-together tile systems made for exactly this sort of use. It is relatively inexpensive and pretty much the only tool needed for installation is a dead-blow mallet. Even better, if you have some spares it is easy to replace pieces which might become damaged in the future.


One example

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#5

How are your feet?

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

I don't believe you'd enjoy working while standing for very long on a surface like tile (of any kind). Over the years, the consensus in shop floor discussions has always led toward softer stuff, like wood, composites, etc. I second whomever suggested an epoxy paint treatment, despite still netting the hard working surface.

Rod

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#6

JL

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

JL

I've got a painted concrete floor with floor mats in strategic locations.

We had a poured epoxy resilient floor at one of the places where I used to work. That was nice. They make similar two part floor systems that would work for your garage.

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#7

I second this

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

Some kind of "raised dot" resilient tile. I was given a sample by a flooring company of some glue down tile in 1 meter squares. It has been in front of the table saw at work for about 5-6 years, not glued down. It is comfortable to stand on, not slick, and dropped edge tools find it very forgiving. Any flooring company can give you info on a variety of brands

glc

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#8

Ric Taylor

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

Ric Taylor

Thanks for the various replies.

I don't mean to be argumentative, but just to show the other sides of the coins that you have offered in your messages:

The hardness of the concrete under my feet is not a problem. My shop has been on that concrete floor for 10 years. I wear Crocs and stand on a rubber matt. Even after being out there all day, my feet are good.

I have previously considered painting the floor and having an epoxy surface applied. I discarded those ideas because I have seen them in place in other shops. They do look good, but the heavy vibrating feet of heavy tools such as a lathe eventually work their way through both of those surfaces, revealing the concrete. Even commercially-applied epoxy systems, which I have learned are about 10 times stronger than the DIY brands, will not stand up to that punishment over time.

The snap-together tiles look great, but I'm concerned about moisture getting underneath them and causing a mold problem. I also doubt if that surface is firm enough for my lathe. It is important for the lathe movement/vibration to transfer to the concrete. Wood won't work because the car will still be parked in there, and that causes other moisture problems.

Sealing grout around tiles is not a problem. I have learned that porcelain would be better because if it became chipped, it is colored all the way through, whereas ceramic is colored only on the surface. The information about tiles with a gritty surface to reduce slickness is appreciated.

So, I'm still back to my original question about what surface prep or cleaning might be needed, if any, on the concrete to insure there are no adhesion issues with the thinset. The floor is level, so no problems there, and I will look into the suggestion about roughing the surface.

Many thanks, other thoughts will still be appreciated.

Ric

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#9

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

wooden leg

I don't know about prep work but I do know about tile. Normal tile is very slick when wet, even a slight moisture, they do make a tile that is designed for wet areas, that is what I have in my bathroom. When I am on my crutches, there is no slippage. Those tiles have little bumps that prevent slippage. Good Luck. Dave

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#10

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

George Koch

Ric, As you have stated that you have read and considered all the above post I'll only recommend that before proceeding with the tile on thinset cement, that you scrub the floor using a strong solution of muriatic acid/water mix with a stiff brush on a broom handle and rinse with clear water. This will not only clean but will also etch the concrete for a better bond of the thinset. George

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#11

Ric Taylor

Thanks, Dave, I'll look into that.


Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#12

Ric Taylor

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

Ric Taylor

Thanks, George. It seems that muriatic acid is good for many things.

Ric

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#13

JL

Floor cleaning

JL

Cleaning the floor.

In the old days I would have recommended TSP (Tri Sodium Phosphate).

Heavy oil stains - paint thinner, naphta, mineral spirits to somewhat dissolve and loosen the stain. Followed by a clay kitty litter or clay absorbent material. Repeat as necessary. Leave the kitty litter dry outside.

Light oil stains, anti-freeze, brake fluid stains - make a slurry of powdered detergent and dish detergent. Let it set on the stain for a while. Scrape it up. Rinse. Repeat as necessary.

Muriatic acid wash - household muriatic (hydrochloric acid) is about 31% as you get it from most stores. I usually dilute it 1:10 for etching concrete. Some people go for a bit more dilute (1:20). Wear gloves and old clothes, rubber boots and possibly a Tyvek coverall. Rinse the floor afterwards to clean up any residual "flaking" of the concrete. The acid is neutralized by the cement in the concrete.

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#14

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor *LINK*

walta

If there are any oil stains I would want the floor shot blasted. You may want to look at the concrete stain finishes.

Walta


video

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#15

Ric Taylor

Thanks to Everyone For Your Thoughts


Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

#16

Re: OT - Tiles on a Garage Floor

Jason Waters

Lastly,

Buy premium thinset with latex (I think it's latex, can't remember) modifier which increases the bond. Last time I did floors, they cheap grey stuff was like $4 per bag, the white premium (which I used, but you don't have to pay for white, unless you need it dues to light color grout like me) was like $18 per bag. I imagine premium grey is in between. Sometimes you can buy a liquid modifier you add too. Applying it right helps a lot too in getting a good bond. You just have to do it a while to get used to what needs to be done.

The others have covered the prep.

I wouldn't tile my shop, but that's me, and a personal decision. But I do wish I had painted mine when I moved in........

I have many runners of anti-fatigue mats on my concrete floor.

Jason