We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I plan to put marble tile on part of a bathroom wall. Is it advisable to put backerboard on the wall first or, on a vertical surface, is it OK to attach the tile directly to the painted drywall ? What does the backerboard do that the drywall doesn't ?
There is a lot to consider here. Drywall is not often very flat, so if the tile are large you will want as flat a surface as possible to install upon. Is direct contact with water a factor?
The answer probably depends somewhat on your project. Yes, you can adhere tile directly to drywall but I probably wouldn't do it in an area that might see any water. I believe that backerboard provides for better adhesion and resistance to water and mold.
I have used Hardiboard...available at Lowe's and HD.... and I like it. Check out jameshardie.com for more info and reasons to consider it, I'm sure there are more than I know.
If the wall, in normal "use" will be dry, s'rock is fine, but for a shower or tub surround or backsplash, it will fail as water infiltrates through the grout joints. You need to check your wall for dishes and bellies if your tile is much over 6" as it won't lay flat. I used an 8' straight edge to find defects both horizontally and vertically. Unless serious, you can resolve the issues with a skim coat. Also suggest you use a wallpaper perforater tool to penetrate the paint film so your mastic gets a better grip.
The tiles aren't small. They're 6" X 12", except for some edging around the top edge of the tub where I will cut it to 6" X 6". Of course, the drywall isn't perfectly flat. The largest gap is 3/64" at one outside corner. I intend to add maple trim but, then again, what about the gap between the trim and the wall ? That will be there whether I put backerboard or not. Waves in walls are a never-ending problem.
A couple of years ago I spoke to a gentleman at Lowes - He worked in the contractor service section. I asked him just about the same question. He stated he had been a contractor for over 30 years and that the only reason to use the backer board was if you didn't do a proper job of installation. he said he had applied tile directly over drywall for many years and never had a callback. I do know I installed 12" tile directly on plywood on my front porch 4 or 5 years ago, it is covered but open to rain / snow blowing in - I have had no problems yet. The porch has had snow covering portions of it for several days and often wet with water. If you do a good job of grouting and seal it I would have to agree with the advice he gave. I would speak to your tile / thinset supplier and determine what thinset you should use to make up for irregularities in the wall - I am sure that you can make up for up to 1/2 inch. I would not use wood trim in the corners if you expect water to infiltrate, instead I would use inside ceramic corner trim and grout.
As I'm beginning to understand, the crux of the question is : will it be possible for water to be splashed in such a way that it could get to the cement and, if so, it will make the paper covering on the dry wall mushy and defeat the adhesion between the paper and the cement ?
I don't know that the issue is necessarily water being splashed on the walls as it is moisture generally finding its way through a wall. In a high-humidity environment like a bathroom, that moisture might be working its way through faster than most other rooms in a house.
I don't disagree with Larry's assertion below that tile can be properly laid over drywall (and with good proper grouting and sealing) you probably won't have any problems. However, if this is your first tiling job and you're doing shower walls, backerboard is relatively cheap insurance against future problems.
I lived in an apartment many years ago and they were probably 25-30 years old at the time, maybe older. I don't know if the shower walls were original but they were tile laid over drywall. How do I know? A week or so before we moved out, I leaned on the wall with my hand while in the shower and put my hand right through the tile wall. The drywall was so saturated, it gave out. These were porcelain glazed tiles and small grout joints.....both good for resisting water and still the moisture ruined the walls behind it.
Disclaimer: I'm not a tile pro but I've done two shower surrounds in my house, both with Hardiboard.
Water will infiltrate from the bottom edge and wick up the wall, rotting out plain wallboard. That's why a cementacious board is used. Hardibacker is somewhat more stable than Durock, but both are far better than sheetrock, including "green-board" which is water resistant sheetrock.
On a wet wall (shower/backsplash) water will penetrate the grout joints. If it hits cement board it has no effect, but sheetrock will turn to mush, swell, and fail, causing the tile to separate.
There's a woman here at work that was suffering flu-like symptoms for many months. Her doctor mis-diagnosed it as Lyme disease. Just about a month ago, they finally realized it is a reaction to mold in her house. They tracked the mold to just such a tile installation. The water had penetrated the tile and sheet rock and invaded the framing wood. Mold began to grow and eventually she started having health issues. She is still out so I can't ask her how much this is costing her, but they are tearing out all of the affected framing, re-sheetrocking on the other side of the wall and doing the tile installation correctly. During this "remodeling" she and her family are renting.
A correct tile installation will have a waterproof membrane (tar paper or equavilent) protecting the framing, either cement tile board or water-resistant sheet rock with waterproof tape on all joints and screw holes, then tile. Think of the tile as the beauty layer and the sub layers do all the actuall work. A very experienced tile setter told me one time: "There are only two kinds of tile: Tile that's leaking, and tile that' going to leak."
Don't take a chance, there is more to this that meets the eye.