Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

wood movement

Posts

wood movement

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

wood movement

Jack Guzman from Maine

I am building a table in red oak. The legs will consist of a 2x8 butt jointed to 2x6 for each leg.I will have 5/4 oak aprons mortised to the legs. My question concerns one of the 2x6s.I ripped an inch off the edge of it to bring it to finish width as it was 7" wide.This wood all came from the same source,bought rough. All pieces at 6% moisture content and acclimated to my shop. When I was passing the piece through the saw blade,the board pinched.The cut closed up. The thin piece didn't curve as it came off the saw.The 6" board ended up with just a slight bow to it. I could straighten it with one swipe from a plane.This is rift sawn wood. Should I worry about this piece warping in the future?---Jack

Re: wood movement

#2

Re: wood movement

del schisler

i don't think it will move any more . You just releved stress in the board. I get that sometimes.

Re: wood movement

#3

I agree to a point- where stress comes from

Bill Tindall

First, I don't understand the construction so I can't speculate on how sensitive it will be to movement. The piece of lumber you ripped was probably not properly dried and it is under stress (or it could be under stress from how the tree grew). What remains after ripping is likely to remain largely as it is. But, this piece may respond to moisture changes in the future differently than a stress-free piece of lumber. I would not use it in a critical location.

As little as I cared to please the occasional retail customer buying a board or two when we ran a hardwood lumber business, I considered drying defects intolerable and I stood behind the lumber we sold in this regard. Some suppliers tried to weasel out of being responsible for drying defects with the disclaimer that the grading was done before drying. I never accepted this premise. That said, you might try to get that piece of lumber exchanged by your supplier.

Drying defects can be sporadic or catastrophic. It can happen that a board or two (out of 100,000 bdft being loaded into the kiln) get into the kiln at a moisture content much higher than the bulk. These boards then dry too fast and become stressed. It is a particular problem with oak which is picky to dry properly. Or, in the case of smaller poorly managed kilns, the whole load may be dried too fast and get stressed. Or, the kiln can be improperly loaded or have improper air circulation and a portion of the stacks dry too fast. These situations lead to more of less defective lumber. I once got a whole load of stressed lumber and it went right back on the truck and back to the supplier. It was not rare to get an occasional piece and if the customer couldn't work it into something I exchanged it. One surely doesn't want to try to rip cabinet facing from stressed lumber, but a shelf is not risky.

Re: wood movement

#4

Ellis Walentine

Another possibility

Ellis Walentine

... besides improper kiln drying, which Bill suggested, is that the board was properly dried but then was stored in a moist environment for a while, so the outer fibers have expanded while the inner ones are still dry. This would result in the board pinching together around the saw kerf.

This board is likely to keep moving as the moisture content equalizes throughout the wood. I'd suggest stickering it for a while before trying to straighten it again.

Ellis

Re: wood movement

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

another clue

Jack Guzman from Maine

I looked at that board a little more carefully. I noticed that the grain runs straight through most of the board(36" long)but takes a jag toward one corner. Around that area the wood is a little lighter in color and has ripples through it. I'm thinking this piece was near the base of the trunk where the tree spreads out. I believe this would account for the stresses. I'm only guessing here. What causes ripples in wood?---Jack

Re: wood movement

#6

Re: another clue

Bill Tindall

Need more information on these ripples. If you mean that the surface of the rough lumber is wavy that is a classic symptom of KD stress resulting from too rapid drying. But if the ripples are the result of curly wood it just means that this area was cut from near a large limb. The grain orientation changes in such an area will generate KD stress even in perfectly dried lumber. I have not noticed any particular problems with lumber cut from the "butt swell" in oak.

Re: wood movement

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: another clue

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

The rough lumber had no waviness. The ripples didn't appear until the wood was planed smooth. It is curly grain. I've never seen it in red oak before. I think you are correct that this board was cut near the intersection of a large branch. It fits the look of the grain pattern.---Jack