Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

Posts

Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#1

Folding Table, Pop. Wood.  Oct. 2011

Bill Tindall



I have an aluminum version of this table. Figuring I could make minimum wage making one from wood (WAY too optimistc as it turned out) I set about making one from cypress.

What follows are my impressions.

There are a boggling number of non-obvious details that impact fitting- what gets in the way of whatever, etc. If you really need one you will likely be building two to get one right. I would never have gotten it built without the aluminum one as a guide. It took a long time to figure stuff out(I'm slow when it comes to reading magazine plans which is why I never build from them). There is an error corrected in the Dec issue. From cypress and using very thin stock for all but legs it still weighs nearly 7 pounds.

Changes I recommend

I bushed the bolt holes with a metal bushing; Nylon would have been better but I didn't have any. Flat head stainless steel screws and lock nuts would be best for assembly, or the flanged panel joining devices available from McFeeley. The complexity of the dowel handle is unnecessary. Just put a third cross piece across the inner leg pair that are closest together as seen in picture of folded version. I used fender washers between legs where the bolts go through. 1 3/4" by 3/4" legs are adequate, as is 3/8" top and cross bracing. Don't put the top slats on till the rest is assembled, then nail them in place with legs assembled. The clearance of the outer top supports and the legs is critical and I wasn't successful in getting it right without having the legs in place to go by.

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#2

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood.  Oct. 2011

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

I actually bought plans for the same, or similar table, from Lee Valley. I've not had the time to make one yet, so your insights are helpful. I've always wondered if the leg braces couldn't be inset into the legs instead of being stuck onto their edge. From your photo, it looks like they can, although the table probably wouldn't fold up quite as tightly.

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood.  Oct. 2011

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for the discussion of this project. I'd be interested to know why you think you have difficulty working from magazine plans?

Ellis

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#4

On why I avoid magazine plans

Bill Tindall

This question required some reflection but I think I have come up with the answer-errors and omissions.

Typically there is much print wasted describing the project and insufficient details on how to put it together and what parts of the construction project involve peril. When I design something as part of the design I am unconsciously working out the details of the construction, the corresponding problems of construction that need to be solve, and the critical areas of fit. These details are often lacking in a magazine article plan and description of the construction.

Take the table in question. There was an error in the article that didn't get fixed until 2 months later. Fortunately, that didn't create any problems for me. What did create problems was not appreciating how it all folded together and what had to slide by what when it was all done. The description of construction steps didn't include details of critical importance, which I would have figured out had I done my own drawings. I don't get the big picture of construction nor the theory of construction for the these magazine articles.

I don't work well from cookbooks either. The first thing I do with a recipe that I intend to use in the future is rewrite it. My pet peeve are directions like "mix the flour and baking powder". How much!?! I have to go find that information somewhere else in the text. My recipes read "mix 500 grams of flour with 5 grams of baking powder". And rarely are there details of where things can go wrong to be watched for. You get to discover these the first time and correct the next. My cookbooks are lavishly annotated with useful notes about the pages that I have added to make a repeat more reliable.

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#5

Re: On why I avoid magazine plans

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

I think I'd like to pop in here as well. I have rarely, very rarely, ever built something from magazine plans. Nowadays, I am so busy that drawing my own has gone by the wayside. Recently I found a clever panel shuttle devise from a magazine I thought would be useful to preserve my ailing back. It has features I would not thought of, but plan to find more than useful. In other words, a good idea.

However, lack of critical information, too much fluff about how wonderful it is, and in this case, confusing drawings and misinformation. And as is the case, I needed to make a size adjustment to accommodate this items integration with other tools in the shop. That I sketched out. That part has worked. Like Bill, I want the relevance of information, or as he put it, "how much." As an example, if the wheels need to be located specifically, tell me why. Don't just tell it is critical and then use more words to remind me it is critical. Use those words to tell me why. From my point of view, knowing why is just as important as knowing what which is just as important as knowing how. In fact, since there are multiple ways to accomplish the same thing in woodworking, perhaps dwelling on the why is more important

As you know, Ellis, I did the show circuit for a number of years. Many attendees told me the thing they liked best about my presentations was I told them why I did things a particular why. In the nine years since my book came out, I have received numerous emails that thank me for explaining why. I find that is still true today when participating on forums. If I had the interest, I would pursue writing for magazines, but my interests have migrated. I still love woodworking and try to do some from time to time. I am fighting giving it up due to physical limitations. In fact, I think from time to time to write an article or three about adjusting the shop to allow working with physical impairment due to aging.

Well, you asked, so just sayin...

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#6

Better said than I did

Bill Tindall

And I agree enthusiastically with everything said.

I just bought a cookbook published in memory of Chief Justice Ginsberg's husband who was an accomplished amateur chef. Reviews of the book criticize the detail, providing as an example five pages devoted to the Baguette. He justified his recipes by saying that he devoted a great deal of effort to perfect a recipe and he wanted to document what he learned so that others would not have to waste time discovering these details. This philosophy would apply to magazine articles on making something. It would have helped on the folding table.

BTW, I have made dozens of baguettes before, but the results from this recipe were the most spectacular. (However, an overnight fermentation in the refrig. improves flavor.


Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#7

My gosh, those look good, Bill!!


Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#8

Cookbook

mdclor

Bill, what is the title of the book? I checked Amazon and there are a few cook books authored by Ginsberg.

Thanks,

Merle

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#9

where to get it

Bill Tindall

It is only available from the gift shop at the Supreme Court. They will mail it and it comes quickly. So Google the gift shop and the rest will be obvious. I have tried other recipes and they have all been exceptional. It was sold out for a bit but they did a second printing.

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#10

Thanks Bill...

John in NM

Just in time for Mom's birthday.... just the type of cookbook she likes :D

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#11

How many book projects really get made?

Tom Dunlap

Something that I'd like to know is how many of the plans published over the decades...going on a century of DIY stuff now...actually get made? After hiking a trail, especially a hard or obscure one, its fun to read the trail register.

Would there ever be a way to do a poll to see how many WC denizens have 'followed book plans' even pretty close?

Tom

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#12

Re: Thanks Bill...

Jesse Cloud

Can't remember the last time I followed a printed plan. I do look at magazine plans closely though and almost always pick up a neat feature or method that I will "borrow" for a future project.

BTW, can remember the last time I followed a cookbook recipe closely either.

Carol hit it on the head when she said the "Why" is what's important. I think most of us make a piece to fit a particular space, so we will change the dimensions. Usually the important stuff is that piece A must be exactly the same length as piece B or this assembly really needs to be square.

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#13

Re: How many book projects really get made?

Stephen Kirk

I have followed a number of magazine plans in the past, and I'm using one for some bookshelves right now, but I'm starting to shy away from them. For one, even most plans for a hobby shop still seem to require the need of big machines. Sure, such and such is simple with a drum sander, but I dont have one. I agree with everything said about the lack of "why". For instance, on the bookshelves I'm making, the construction is frame and panel. The panels are 56" tall by 5/8" thick. Since most of us have access to 8 or 10 foot stock, that means a lot of wasted wood. Didn't realize that till I got into it. Plus, why 5/8" thick? I'm modifying the design, adding a midde rail to create an upper/lower panel, limit wasting wood, and switching to 3/4" ply. Seems like by the time I finish I've nearly redesigned the whole thing anyway. The top called for 1 5/8" thick stock, which means 8/4 stock and planing/resawing and waste ( yeah, I don't like wasting stuff).

Also, cost of a piece is never discussed. When I'm working on pieces for myself, it'd be nice to have a ballpark on cost, since I don't want to break the bank. This is a big reason I like cut lists (Yeah, Popwood, keep 'em OK?) because it's easy to do a quick calculation and get my lumber needs and determine cost.

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#14

Books, plans & Ol' Norm . . .

steve mackay

I tend to buy a book or plan in order to get a "technique". I picked up a book on veneering just to see how it worked in order to do repairs. The toolbox plans from LV just to get the general idea for the carcas and runners. And I know, deep in my heart, I'll never build anything Ol' Norm does (nor own a biscut machine !) but I do use many, many of his gags (but I use hand tools). It IS a funny idea to think how many folks are building Rockler's "gazebo" (by the book) in their backyard though.

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#15

Re: How many book projects really get made?

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

When I first started out I followed the books pretty close, over the years I've found that I'm more using the books as guides and ideas for designs and features, but make the work more custom and my own.

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#16

Mark me down for zero.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I can honestly say that I have never followed a single plan in all my years of woodworking. And if a client came to me with a plan I would decline the job. Must be a right side of brain thing.

T.

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#17

Re: How many book projects really get made?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I have made a couple of items from Popular Woodworking -- Roy Underhill joiner's chest (x2) and the mini-blanket chest that followed a few issues later. But, I altered the dimensions to more useful sizes (for the joiner's chests) and altered the interior compartment of the blanket chest to suit materials I had on hand.

The next year, I combined elements of both designs to make a toy box for my grandson. (I'm certain he and his parents have not yet noticed the hidden compartment ... )

Everything else is mostly sized to suit the current needs or the stock I have on hand, and designed from things I've seen already (they say there are no new ideas anymore, it's just re-hashing things that have gone before).

When I see plans for kids' toys (like the series of construction vehicles that have been coming out in Wood magazine) I follow along pretty closely. I share the complaint/observation that the instructions often are vague or misleading. (That's why I voted to retain cut lists.)

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#18

Same here...

John in NM

At least as far as books go. The shop I worked for did give you a plan to follow, first step was to add up all the dimensions and make sure everything was correct. The draftsman was not exactly a math wizz :D

I love books and magazines for inspiration, general style, and for learning about details I may want to incorporate, but I doubt I would ever replicate a project exactly. Too many things I think I can "improve" :D

Re: Folding Table, Pop. Wood. Oct. 2011

#19

Re: Never - But

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have reviewed many and used some dimensions such as height, joinery methods etc.