Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

The physics of resawing *LINK*

Posts

The physics of resawing *LINK*

#1

The physics of resawing *LINK*

Dick Coers

Resaw troubles come up so often on forums, now Mathias has made it simple enough for all to understand. Another great video from him. I check his site every Monday when he updates. It's a must visit site.


Resawing physics

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#2

symptom

Bill Tindall

When the resawed pieces are separated if the kerf is packed with saw dust it is a sign that the gullets were not carrying this dust out of the kerf as should be the case.

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#3

I don't know this man or his site

Gary Smyth

Have you an address?

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#4

link in original post


Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#5

Sorry, I didn't scroll and click

Gary Smyth

as far as I needed to do. It's the "Woodworking for Engineer's" website. Got it. Thanks

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#6

Im not sure about all of this.

Keith Newton

Just for a starter. "Wider blades help in this regard. For the same amount of tension, a blade twice as wide will have twice as much beam strength." I'm not an engineer, or physicist, but i'm pretty sure doubling the depth more than doubles the strength. In a joist, I think it is more like quadrupled.

To not mention taking the proper chip size for each tooth, which takes the heat away with it, seems like an oversite. But I could be wrong.

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#7

Re: Im not sure about all of this.

Sgian Dubh

"... i'm pretty sure doubling the depth more than doubles the strength. In a joist, I think it is more like quadrupled."

Keith, it's purely coincidental but I'm writing about the subject you've just raised for a timber technology manuscript: the relevant references and engineering source materials are sitting open on my desk as I type. I too am not an engineer so I've created spreadsheets to see for myself how two or three of the formulae used in deformation in pure bending actually work in practice.

So, I am convinced that you are correct to say that if you double the depth of a beam the load carrying capacity is four times greater, not double. Slainte.

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#8

It is way more complicated

Bill Tindall

The relevant mechanical factor is what load will cause the blade to twist, not beam strength, which indeed is height squared. We really don't care if the blade simply bends so long as it stays in plane. A deflection out of plane will result in the blade wandering.

For a long thin "beam", in this case a band saw blade, constrained at each end from rotation (tight blade guides) the force necessary to result in buckling is a complex function of both width and thickness of the beam(blade), with the thickness of the blade a more important factor than the width. I don't know enough mechanical engineering to be sure that the analysis of buckling of a loaded beam will be exactly analogous to our band saw situation because the blade is under tension as well as load. But I think in any case the blade thickness will be an important factor, and may or may not be the cubed function of thickness.

The mechanical properties of the material, in this case band saw metal, are indeed relevant. I can easily imagine that a blade steel with more robust mechanical properties, easily achieved by alloying or heat treating, would resist twisting better at a given blade tension.

Now if you want to really tax your brain power, set off on a quest to determine the function that describes a bent thin strip of wood like what we use to make attractive arcs for furniture.

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#9

Ellis Walentine

Re: It is way more complicated

Ellis Walentine

The relevant mechanical factor is what load will cause the blade to twist, not beam strength, which indeed is height squared. We really don't care if the blade simply bends so long as it stays in plane. A deflection out of plane will result in the blade wandering.

The point I thought the guy made was that deflection out of plane is directly related to deflection of the beam, i.e., the width of the blade. That has been my observation as well.

Ellis

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#10

Bob

Re: It is way more complicated

Bob

Doesn't a wider blade also need much higher tension to achieve the same as a narrower blade? I thought thats why wider blades aren't recommended on smaller saws, not enough frame strength to create the necessary tension.

Bob

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#11

Re: It is way more complicated

Keith Newton

Oh, I agree that it is way more important than this guy could ever pretend to illustrate with his wooden blade cutting sawdust. I wouldn't call it physics at that level, maybe the nuts and bolts of bandsawing.

Did you by chance watch the little youtube of the fellow using his home-made sawmill, using a woodmizer blade which broke half way down the log. This guy attributed it to bending around too wheels which were small. I wish I knew how powerful the motor was on that rig. Im guessing less than 1 hp. and wonder how quickly it would have broken with more power, considering that the drive wheel was pushing the blade through, rather than pulling it through the wood. Needless to say, that little frame couldn't stand enough tension to keep the blade tight under that situation.

I have to wonder if the guy didn't know how to reverse the motor, or that the teeth point the other way by flipping it inside out. he he

I don't believe I would put that up on youtube, if it were me.

Re: The physics of resawing *LINK*

#12

Re: It is way more complicated

Bill White

This makes my head hurt. Now let's see....Where is my WoodSlicer blade?

Bill