Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Abrasive life expectancy.

Posts

Abrasive life expectancy.

#1

Abrasive life expectancy.

Keith Newton

Still trying to get accustom to my new Bosch sander. One thing that I like and yet don't like, is that it does a fine job of collecting the dust, but without seeing the dust flying away, I suspect I will be wasting time burnishing with a worn out disk.

Have any of you done any test, or know of any charts which show the time relative to wood type or density, for given abrasives? I can't claim that sanding is one of my favorite parts of woodworking, so I really don't want to be wasting time going through the motions, now that I have lost that visual cue.

Also, I paired it with a little 4 gallon Rigid WD 4070 shop-vac, wired into a switch which turns it on whenever I start the sander. But I had to adapt the hose with an old one from another older small one, which is falling off regularly. Have any of you dealt with the hoses and found the best? This one seems too stiff, and probably a bit smaller than it should be.

I am kinda thinking I could rig a over-arm, spring loaded lift, that would take a lot of the weight off the first few feet of hose. It might include an old fishing rod worked into the equation. he he, No more fish than I normally bring home, I ought to find a better use for them.

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

#2

JL

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

JL

I usually use an aluminum oxide sandpaper. I've had reasonable luck with Norton and Klingspor.

I bought one of the Ridgid vacuums as part of the Black Friday specials a couple years back. The hose was pretty poor. I bought one of the Ridgid aftermarket hoses (sort of a "rust" color) - excellent quite flexible hose. I also purchase some adapters. They work well with my 5" ROS.

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

#3

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

DizD

I picked up Dec 2011 (No222) issue of FWW mag from the library last week. It has article evaluating 6 brands of sanding disks, including endurance, fastest removal and most economical. Seems it would be a good place to start.

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

#4

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

Keith Newton

Thanks Diz, but I couldn't get access to it. I find that site seriously frustrating. I used to contribute to that forum regularly, but it is just not fun anymore.

So what was your takeaway? Was there a clear cut winner?

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

#5

The summary

DizD

came up with two recommendations. Norton 3X best overall for fastest stock removal (grams removed per minute) and Klingspor VD900 for best overall and most economical (grams removed per penny). Looks like the results also varied between grits - 80 -220 tested. You can check w/ your library like I do for checking out past issues.

Also, we're having the Mirka rep present program for our club next month. I'm sure he will tell us why Mirka is best.

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

#6

Abrasive life expectancy; give me some lip

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

While there are tests that measure sandpaper longevity, how do you actually know when to switch disks? I've taken to lightly pulling the disk across my lower lip and comparing that level of abrasiveness to a new disk. There is a "catchiness" that disappears after the disk is too worn. My hands are too tough to actually feel the grit very well but my lip is pretty sensitive.

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

#7

Re: Abrasive life expectancy; give me some lip

Jesse Cloud

I change paper when the process feels slower. It seems pretty consistent.

Your paper will last much longer with good dust collection (you will be sanding fresh wood instead of the buildup from the last few minutes of sanding.

The process will be much faster if you take the time to clean off the workpiece before you change grits - otherwise you pick up coarser grits from the previous session and make new coarse scratches while you are trying to remove the coarse scratches from the previous session. A good blast of compressed air or a few swipes with a vac brush will do the trick.

Re: Abrasive life expectancy.

#8

Thanks DizD

Keith Newton

I'll give those a try after these Mirkas are gone. I got a box of 150, 220, 320. Not sure why I got the 150, i usually start at 180, and feel there is too much jump between 150 to 220.