Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

SawStop on Colbert Report

Posts

SawStop on Colbert Report

#1

SawStop on Colbert Report

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Can't believe no one's posted this yet. Very funny to me, but given pervious threads here, not so funny for all. Show reruns at 6:30 EST on Comedy Central Channel.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#2

"finger coddlers"  *LINK*


cobert

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#3

My Take on the Saw Stop

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

I believe that he went back to the drawing board and came up with a way to integrate this into existing saws rather than force a saw to be re-designed to handle it, then he would end up with less opposition and probably get industry buy in to offer it as an option. A safety feature no matter how good that costs $1000 to add to the saw is a hard thing to sell.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#4

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

Charlie Lenz

Or you can watch it now at this link. http://www.hulu.com/watch/329024/the-colbert-report-people-who-are-destroying-america-sawstop. My feeling on the whole deal is where will it stop ? BandSawStop ? JointerStop ? DrillPressStop ? RouterStop ? CircularSawStop ? Etc. It would get so expensive for most people to start the hobby, that I think it would just about kill the hobby off. Since SawStop came out, the price of just about all the Cabinet saws have made an almost immediate jump of $1000. And with less people being able to retire, which makes up a good percentage of woodworkers, the hobby is already struggling in my opinion. If it wasn't for the DIY home remodeler, things would be even worse. What makes the SawStop even more repulsive in my mind is the fact that they want to shove it down the throat of the American people, but aren't willing to suport American jobs, the saws are made in Taiwan. No thanks, the day I'm forced to buy such nonsense will be the day that I hangup Woodworking. In my opinion there are other things to worry about, such as dust containment. I wonder how many people are sent to the hospital because of a dust related illness or death. Face it, woodworking is a dangerous and some times an unhealthy thing to do. There are risks to everything, if you can't agree to take those risks, then don't do it, stay out of it. The next time I hear about the SissySaw will be too soon.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: My Take on the Saw Stop

Moses Yoder

How much does one trip to the emergency room cost? Last summer a guy in one of the shops building stuff for us cut his arm off on a radial arm saw. You might ask "How does a guy cut his arm off?" and that's a fair question. But you look around and see stupid people all day long. So what did it cost to glue a guy's arm back on? I haven't had the guts to ask.

From what I am hearing, if people have good company insurance and it doesn't cost them much when they cut off a finger they rant against the SawStop's limitation of free speech rights. If they have to pay the hospital visit themselves, they would just rather have the SawStop.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#6

The loss of 10 fingers every day in the USA

Dick Coers

seems like a real good reason to add the technology. If you don't like Sawstop, do you not use seat belts? Not use GFI's in the bathroom? Have smoke detectors in the house? All those are either law or in your building code. Stuff happens. I have only half the use of the middle finger on my left hand. Tangled with a biscuit joiner when it kicked out a small piece of wood from my hand and I couldn't react. Cost my insurance company over $10,000 for emergency room, two surgeries and all those hospital costs, and doctor visits. My next table saw will be a Saw Stop.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#7

Re: Ever hear of a blade guard ?

Charlie Lenz

They actually do work if you install it.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#8

Re: My Take on the Saw Stop

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

I agree, and I also can see that their should be a safety device available to help protect people from injuries, My beef with the inventor is how he's going about it. He creates a good product and yes it's pricey, but instead of working with the industry leaders on coming up with a solution to integrate it into saws, he wants his solution to be mandated by the government.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#9

I propose no more Saw Stop threads

Nat Robison

for the primary reason that there's plenty of gray area to discuss when it comes to SawStop but it rarely remains civil. Everyone has a story or opinion to back up their viewpoint and nothing will sway them, whether they're for or against. I think just about everyone here knows about the technology and its place in the market. Just my opinion.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#10

Bart Goldberg

Agree - This issue has been covered.


Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#11

Problem's Not The Topic

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

But rather the tone and tenor of the comments and the tendency to attack others with a different view. It invariably tends to go hyperbolic and "political" because the issue laps into areas of personal freedom and a perceived loss of personal choice. If sarcasm and pet peeves about the role of government, economic theory, and postulates on foreign or international trade policy can't be "left at the door", the individual posts should be deleted.

Ellis didn't establish this forum to be anyone's bully pulpit or a venue for primordial scream therapy. Either we accept opposing views, agreeing to disagree in a collegial atmosphere, or we don't comment at all.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#12

Another problem

Thomas S Stockton

I think another problem is that issues like this provoke a reaction and that a lot of people who are responding didn't watch the video which is SATIRE and that is the whole point of Cobert's show to poke fun at mainly political things.

Watch the video it is really funny. I'm trying to decide which to give up when the government comes after them my guns or my sawblades.

Tom

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#13

From My Cold Dead Hand

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

even if it does only have two fingers . . . :D

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#14

Re: My Take on the Saw Stop

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Allen - According to the stories I have read, he did approach all of the manufacturers and when they didn't want anything to do with his invention, he went out on his own. Since some of this is sworn testimony, I am going to assume it is correct.

I'm not saying that SawStop is good or bad, or whether or not it should be mandated, just that he did approach the manufacturers.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#15

Re: My Take on the Saw Stop

TomD

His offering SS is cool. But it does feel like an industry grab. He isn't satisfied with letting the market decide.

I've hurt myself on a TS, it was a trivial nick. I also got a bad kickback once, and both of these were well down the road for me. But there are so many dangers in woodworking that I can't possibly switch off my brain just because one category of accidents, not even all risks on a TS is made safer. I really sincerely wonder why people who do not trust themselves around TSs in the hobby realm would even have them in the first place. I have two at the moment, but did without for about 10 years, after selling my General. For a hobby there are many alternatives and it saves money, frees up space, and clean-up time. A lot of the hobby danger of TSs comes from leveraging them for doing every darn thing. This is a fun puzzle, but holds back development elsewhere, and leads to practices that can be unsafe. I brought the TS back, but only use it in ways that are 100% finger safe, so I don't need an SS. The real problem is the unwillingness to just say no to dangerous practices.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#16

Re: From My Cold Dead Hand

Bill White

Mark, I DO admire your command of the language. Your posts are well written and well thought. Kudos.

Bill

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#17

I'm Also

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

adept at stealing other guys' lines. :D

[Sorry Mos . . er, Mr. Heston] ;)

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#18

Mark, Listening to NPR this AM,

Keith Newton

The were talking about the Google auto-pilot or automobiles, and how good the system is and will become, as the technology evolves. They will all be feeding into a system, communicating with cars ahead, and watching out for stuff that human drivers could not keep up with.

At the end of the program, there was a remark, that it would be un-safe to allow humans to drive in the future, compared to the auto-pilot. ha

That may be so in a perfect world, but I had to wonder how well it will go over after some hacker gets his jollies seeing how many cars he can crash in one instant.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#19

Re: My Take on the Saw Stop

Jerry

From what I read some time ago, he went to saw vendors at the time and none were interested. Per that report, Delta told him "safety doesn't sell..."

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#20

Re: My Take on the Saw Stop

Jim Breeden

I don't how people can be stupid enough to cut their arm off in a radial arm saw,

but, I've seeen a stupid person cut two fingers off in a paper cutter. Still - I'm not going to buy a Saw Stop, just because there are stupid people out there.

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#21

"


Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#22

Re: "

Jim Breeden

Hey Steve - Ur msg didn't come thru. Should I run for the hills?

Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#24

now that's funny   


Re: SawStop on Colbert Report

#25

"Ditto"