We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I have battled with this machine since I bought it 10 years ago and am about to sell it for scrap.
After yet again trying to tune it up I am still not able to get two sides perpendicular when using the jointer. For 4/4 stock it isn't such a problem, but with a 3.5" thick piece there is a gap of about 1/16" at one corner when I use a square. I have some projects coming up where I will be glueing up thicker stock and this amount of error will become a problem.
For the tune up I have:
Confirmed that the tables are parallel to the cutterhead (within 0.001")
Confirmed that the tables are parallel to each other (within 0.001")
Confirmed that the fence is parallel to the tables
I discovered about two years ago that the cutterhead on the machine has the knife slots milled at slightly different depths. I am using the ESTA knife change system with the magnets at the bottom of the knife slots. I have tried to use paper shims to get them evened out to varying degrees of success.
At this point, as I see it, my options are:
1) replace the cutterhead (Shelix one runs $1K-ouch)
2) remove the cutterhead and have it drilled so I am use the old style ESTA set screw system (which I also have). about $100, but I have to remove the cutterhead which isn't a trivial matter.
3) try the newest ESTA system, Self-set, which hooks over the edge of the top of the cutterhead knife slots.
Advice and opinions greatly appreciated!
Re: help fixing a 12" Robland J/P cutterhead problem
Re: help fixing a 12" Robland J/P cutterhead probl
John McGaw
I'm having a problem understanding your question. I have a Robland and, although some of the machining is a bit sketchy I never had that much problem getting the jointer aligned. I'm having even more trouble understanding how the thickness of a workpiece going across the jointer could cause variations. At most a piece of wood, regardless of thickness is in contact with the infeed table, the spinning blades, the outfeed table, and (sometimes) the fence. If the first three are properly aligned then whether the workpiece if 1" or 5" thick, then the bottom surface is the only thing in play and should come out identically. If the fence is being used to obtain a right-angle corner and if the fence is at 90-degrees to the tables (which are coplanar) and the reference surface is tight against the fence then the surface being jointed will be square after a pass or two -- can't help but be. Can you help me out with my misunderstanding?
Re: help fixing a 12" Robland J/P cutterhead problem
Re: help fixing a 12" Robland J/P cutterhead probl
Dick Coers
Is the fence flexing? My Minimax is held at one end of a really long fence. If I don't brace it back at the indeed side, it will move. Are you keeping your hands on the out feed side only? I see TV woodworkers switching their hands back and forth over the cutter head, some even using push sticks, WRONG! Once the board crosses over the cutter head enough for you to safely hold on to the board, you always keep all you pressure on that side. Never go back to the infeed side. For gluing up panels, I make sure that one board has the good face to the fence, the second board with the bad face to the fence. I may machine one at 89 deg. and the other to 91 deg., but they add up to 180. It cancels out fence error.
Re: help fixing a 12" Robland J/P cutterhead problem
Re: help fixing a 12" Robland J/P cutterhead probl
Ellis Walentine
I have battled with this machine since I bought it 10 years ago and am about to sell it for scrap.
Let me know when you decide to sell. I might be interested.
After yet again trying to tune it up I am still not able to get two sides perpendicular when using the jointer. For 4/4 stock it isn't such a problem, but with a 3.5" thick piece there is a gap of about 1/16" at one corner when I use a square. I have some projects coming up where I will be glueing up thicker stock and this amount of error will become a problem.
When you say two sides perpendicular, I'm understanding that you're talking about getting an edge square to the face of the workpiece. Right?
For the tune up I have:
Confirmed that the tables are parallel to the cutterhead (within 0.001")
Confirmed that the tables are parallel to each other (within 0.001")
Confirmed that the fence is parallel to the tables
There could be only two things going wrong here. Either the knives aren't parallel to the cutterhead or the fence isn't perpendicular to the table. You should be able to determine both of those things with a straightedge and a square.
I discovered about two years ago that the cutterhead on the machine has the knife slots milled at slightly different depths. I am using the ESTA knife change system with the magnets at the bottom of the knife slots. I have tried to use paper shims to get them evened out to varying degrees of success.
It is really unlikely that your knife slots are that far out of parallel with the surface of the cutterhead. 1/16" in 3 1/2" is HUGE. Your knives might not be parallel with the cutterhead, but they can't be off by that much.
At this point, as I see it, my options are:
1) replace the cutterhead (Shelix one runs $1K-ouch)
2) remove the cutterhead and have it drilled so I am use the old style ESTA set screw system (which I also have). about $100, but I have to remove the cutterhead which isn't a trivial matter.
3) try the newest ESTA system, Self-set, which hooks over the edge of the top of the cutterhead knife slots.
A Shelix head isn't necessary. Either #2 or #3 should straighten out the knife problem, although I don't know why you would need/want to remove the cutterhead under any circumstances. I had a similar problem with my Powermatic jointer and the Esta magnet system. I couldn't use the magnets to set the knife height accurately, so I went back to using the jack screws. Problem solved. The new Esta self-set system is another way around this situation. The knife holder hooks onto the edge of the slot, which by definition is parallel to the cutterhead.
The upshot is that I think this issue must be fence-related, and if the fence is square to the table and not warped, you need to check your stock feeding technique. To square a board, you need to be sure you are using a flat face against the fence, and that it actually is against the fence. This seems obvious, but if the edge is out of square to begin with, you have to tilt the board against the fence to square it. I can see this being an issue with thick stock, as there is a nice wide edge riding on the table. You have to be really conscious of maintaining contact of the face of the board to the fence.
Please report back when you've checked this stuff.
Ellis Walentine, Host
Re: help fixing a 12" Robland J/P cutterhead problem
Re: help fixing a 12" Robland J/P cutterhead probl
John McGaw
A number of years ago Robland changed the jointer fence arrangement on the X-31 combination machine switching from an independent fence to one supported by the saw's rip fence. I believe that the change was due to some rigidity/alignment problems with the old fence arrangement. I don't know from the original post here what sort of fence (or what sort of machine, J/P or full-out combination machine?) is involved. Your suspicion about the fence being the problem is probably well founded -- there is little else that could go wrong to make non-square faces if the stock is being run in proper contact with the fence.
Re: help fixing a 12" Robland J/P cutterhead problem
Thanks for the thoughtful responses to my semi-rant.
I double checked everything and it was indeed the fence (again). Unfortunately I have the original fence that attaches at the back of the machine and has WAY too many pivot points. I didn't get the upgraded retrofit fence when Laguna was selling them and they haven't wanted to sell me a new fence.
The slots for the three knives in my cutterhead are indeed of differing depths which made it necessary to shim the Posi-set magnets--I, of course, bought those 6-8 months before the new Self-set came out. When I first installed the Posi-set and had trouble they sent me some Accu-set parts, but now that I've looked closely at them I don't know what model of jointer they go to--certainly not mine.
The Robland originally used two little springs to hold the blades up and then this metal thing-a-ma-jig to supposedly hold them down at a uniform height while the screws were tightened--which didn't work. Switching to the Accuset system is nontrivial, at least according to the article in the Badger Pond archives. http://www.woodcentral.com/bparticles/esta.shtml