Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

chairs

Posts

chairs

#1

chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Went to HF and bought their 8" carbide dado blade setup, installed it today on my Shopsmith along with the blade guard with vacuum nozzle built into it. Have to get a sheet of sheetmetal to lay on top of the saw table to extend over and thru the extension table I made for the runout of the seats when sculpting.

Am going to be using Charles Neiul's method of scul[ting the seats with the table sqw and dado blade setup. You can watch this also on YOUTUBE/CharlesNeil/spooningaseat.

He has come up with a more rathonal method of doing the seats without the drills and a lot of sanding

Re: chairs

#2

Re: chairs

Barry Irby

I am interested in your progress. I feel some chairs coming in my future.

Could you post an exact search or description of the Charles Neil post on You Tube. I tried and could not find it.

Re: chairs

#3

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

To watch Charles Neil produce his sculpted chair seat in a newer fashion go to:

www.youtube.com/charlesneil/sculpting the seat. The video is 33 minutes long.

He setsup the tablesaw using his dados, sculpts out the lines smoothly, then uses his Saburr Carbice donut to round off the seat sides, and sands and smooths out the lines with his cabinet blades... Very informative and a good time saver in making the seats too.

Re: chairs

#4

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

You can also go to "www.windsorchairsresources.com" to view several other guys making the chairs using the hand tools...spokeshaves, spores, travisers, log splitting and shaping the pieces to use in the chairs,etc.

Re: chairs

#7

Re: chairs

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I'm not impressed with Neil's technique (frankly not impressed with much of anything he does). I think a router mounted to a sled does a quicker and better job with initial sculpting. Been thinking about trying out a bowl sled- a router mounted inside a shallow curved bowl- and a template.

Re: chairs

#8

JL

Re: chairs

JL

I'm not a traditionalist - though I have carved my seats out using an adze, scorp and travisher.

I usually use my angle grinder. I start with a Lancelot chainsaw attachment if I'm doing harder wood or just the tungsten donut if I'm doing softer wood.

It typically takes me a couple of hours to rough out a seat blank and get it to the point where I use a ROS.

While I may go with a router and a bowl bit, I don't think I want to go the table saw method.

Re: chairs

#9

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Alan, I had one of those sleds and was not impressed with it at all. Just wasted the material I was trying to use and tried using a sander to make some improvements to the mess. It looked like a good de3al...having control of the depths etc, but it did not work out for me. I am going to try using Neil's technique this week to do a seat and shall report how it comes out.

Re: chairs

#10

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

To each in his/her own way.....I am trying out newer techniques is all.

Re: chairs

#11

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Also, I am not going to be using any handtool equipment...am using my Shopsmith 5-in-one-saw, drill press, lathe, sander etc and the regular drills and bits needed...but no spokeshaves, travishers etc.

Do not have them and will not buy any...have no need to have them.

Re: chairs

#12

link to chair seat scooping Charles neil

del schisler

http://www.youtube.com/profile?user=InTheWorkshop#p/u/40/g6DaDGE_FJI

Re: chairs

#13

Re: chairs

Barry Irby

I have to say I don't care for the appearance of his seats. In my mind what makes "Windsor" seats so comfortable is that the seats are sculpted to fit your anatomy. A rounded out shape that fits the butt. Neal's seats are too flat bottomed to look appealing to me. I would want to sit in one for a while before I cast further aspersions, though. And you could use the method to create the more rounded profile I prefer, but that would eliminate a lot of the speed.

I would set a stop block on the far side to align the ends of the cuts and to prevent running past the stop line ans ruining the blank. I am sure I would lose my concentration and run one too far.

I did use my RAS as a sort of over arm router and did a seat on it. Worked very well and allowed you to see exactly what the blade was doing.

The last three I did I used a 36 grit disk on a disk sander without a backup plate and did the sculpting by eye after drilling out what I could with forstner bits. That was quick, less than two hours start to finish.

Re: chairs

#14

Re: chairs

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'd be interested in giving his method a shot. I've made sculpted chair seats with angle grinders and by hand with spokeshaves and scrapers, albeit in hardwoods. His method might work pretty well for hogging a lot of wood. It's worth a try.

Re: chairs

#15

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Barry, I did try doing the Fortsner bits at various depths from rear to front...it was a disaster and needs tooo much sanding to level out. The Sanburr carbide donut did work very well for me though on the sides and rear seat curving. This was the first seat I had tried and I shall sand it again and eventually get the seat to where I can live with it. But, I am going to be trying out Charles Neil's method on the other seats....at least one of them this week. If I like it and find the seating to sit well I shall continue with the others. Hey, these are Xmas presents I am making for my family members to have something I had made after I am gone from this world....I am going to be 78 in May 2012..... and expect many more years to live...if family history in the clan has any relavence to lide span....probably in my 90s to 100s.

But, I am only 20 in my mind and thinking.... Joe Mulherin

Re: chairs

#16

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

That is exactly why he came up with his method of ridding the seats...hogging out... of the harder woods used. As Barry mentioned, he thought the seatsw had tooo flat a sitting bottom, but it could be used with some contouring of the depths. I am just going to try Neil's method on at least one seat and if it "sits well" I shall do some more of them the same. Using the angle sander with the Sanburr carbide donut sander does help a great deal in forning the seat curves for the butt and legs...then use a flap sander to finalize the smoothing for finishing.

Re: chairs

#17

Re: chairs

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The first chair seat I did like that was made of red oak, a Windsor in the style of Thomas Moser. I hollowed it out with an angle grinder and a coarse sanding disk with maybe 4 rocks on it. It went pretty fast and actually provided pretty good control, but there was still a lot of guess work in determining depth.

Re: chairs

#18

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Bruce, I am starting off with a 1/4" depth in front with the dado set for 3/4". With the blocks glued to the fron of the seat that gives me control of the descending depth at the rear also because the seat will advance to the 3/4" depth of the dado setting. This should be a good starting position to see how the seat "sits well" or should have some more hogging out to a greater depth aqt the start.

Anyway, I am using the Shopsmith tool and the table is a little short, so I mad34 an extension table I shall use for swculpting the seats. This is needed so the blocks do not fall off the rear edge of the saw table and gouge out the center of the seat. I have to buy a piece of sheet metal ...2'x4' to lay on top for evenness of the surface....this I shall do tomorrow...than start on the first seat.

Re: chairs

#19

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

OK, I setup my Shopsmith saw table with the extension table I made covered with some sheetmetal for levelness. Ran the first seat doing as Charles Neil suggested....it really came out rather nice....gentle slope from front to rear, but I am going to have to find a supplier for some chair seats....solid material...not glued up boards. Need blanks 24" sq x 2" thick. Will continue with the Saburr carbide donut to make the curves and then use my ROS to finish sand.

Re: chairs

#20

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Have two seats ready for the final sanding and sculpting the edges slopes. Setup the lathe and tried to turn some of the spindles, but the DF seems to not turn as well as I had hoped. Got one finally done and shall use it for a pattern for the rest of the legs. First arm spindle I almost had finished turning ready for the sanding to smooth when all of a sudden the end cracked and ruined the piece....so will have to try again. Each chair has 14 turnings, so I have to find a very good way to do the work without distroying the pieces in the process. I am turning very lightly and smoothly, but the wood seems to have some faults I do not see at the time of working. Guess DF is not a good wood for turnings. Arms, rockers, seat middle designed piece, splats are fine and smooth to touch. Spindles are going to take some time...

Re: chairs

#21

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Does anyone have any knowledge of making a "trammel" to use with a router for sculpting seats?

Like two boards lengthwise on which the router sits on another two boards in an arc fashion to form the outside edges with a roundnose router bit? The two router boards move up and down the two outside boards to form the grooves and depths. I had one several years ago, but for got how it was made. Thanks

Re: chairs

#22

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Set up the Shopsmith in lathe duplicator mode and turned five spindles this morning...nice and smooth using the DF materials I chose glued together to make thickness an no knots in this materials. Will buy some more and do the rest of the 14 spndles for each chair. Have two chairs under construction foir this period...four more to follow later in the year...maybe a few more if time is available.

Re: chairs

#23

Re: chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Have turned 8 spindles so far and they turned out smooth and well sanded. Am using spruce for them.

I remembered viewing a video many years ago about making spindles in your own shop without having to use the regular tools.... You take an angle iron and have a tool/dyemaker carve out the edge you desire onto one side of the angle....sharp too. Then mount the angle on the tail end of the lathe on a swing bolt so that all you have to do is lower the angle from the tail end down onto your dowel slowly and the angle design is carved onto the dowel in a full sweep..... once.... no having to go over and over the dowel to shape. Saw this when they were making some stairway spindles. Once you haqve the design carved onto the angle you can make any number of the dowel shapes you desire quickly.

Of course if you have several designs to do you will have to have different angles for each design.

But, I am using my Shopsmith lathe duplicator and things are progressing well...

just have to wait for the funds to get some more material so I can at least finish two chairs before Easter.

Seats came out nice using Charles Neil's method. More later... Joe