Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Future estate sale

Posts

Future estate sale

#1

Future estate sale

John Pappas

I've reached an age where it's probably a good idea to think about the time when someone in the family will need to dispose of my woodworking tools. So, I put together a book about my tools. At this point, I consider it a good start, but I know that it's not a finished product. I have sections on chisels, planes, saws, measuring and marking, sharpening, books and magazines, and a miscellaneous section. I need to add information about my limited power tools.

Each section contains an inventory of my tools, and other information such as pages from catalogs, original invoices, or even reference to some web site that might contain helpful information. I also have special notes about certain items, such as a book autographed by James Krenov in 1980, and a small backsaw with a "Disston and Son" medallilon.

I would like to include what might be a reasonable selling price. And in this regard, I am clueless. I suppose some time on Ebay would be helpful. Not sure about antique stores, but maybe. Any suggestions in this regard will be useful and appreciated.

Re: Future estate sale

#2

Re: Future estate sale

John McGaw

I don't know how you could make a SWAG as to the future value of some item. Fads come and go and prices peak and dip and, assuming that you are intending to hang around for a while, any guesses you make now will need updating.

I'm considering simply willing all woodworking tools, equipment, wood, books, magazines, etc to the local guild, assuming that they are willing to commit to emptying the shop when the time comes. Perhaps a bit of money included to sweeten the deal will make them more willing to move the big iron in a timely manner? I'm doing a similar thing with the local library to empty the remaining library contents. I may even do a deal for the wine society to empty the 'wine cellar' so that they can either have a drunken orgy in my memory or at least hold an auction at one of their meetings.

Re: Future estate sale

#3

Re: Future estate sidestep

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I don't have the problem as my two Heirs have taken to learning to make stuff. Consequently, my daughter gets the "turning suite" and my son takes the flatwork stuff.

Re: Future estate sale

#4

Where do you live?

Gary Smyth

Tools ought to last several lifetimes. That's why there are a lot out there. Also to me it seems newer generations are less interested in tools than past ones. If clearing out a lifetime of accumulating good tools if you live in a big city or wealthy suburbs for select items you may get 50 cents on the dollar. If you live solid middle class count on 30 cents on the dollar. Anything more than that the tool searchers I see every week will walk away. When they buy they in turn will increase by 50% whatever price they paid so that they can make a resale profit. I see fewer and fewer users at tool sales - mostly resellers. Unless there is something really special AND you can get it to a good auction house with top clientele don't plan on making a profit. If you aren't a celebrity or a top quality collector big auction houses don't want you. They may, if you're lucky, cherry pick your best stuff and bundle it with someone elses to make a larger sale. Don't count on it. Remember that they take typically 30% as their cut of the total as their fee. You will be better served selling to friends who will pay higher prices because they will be embarrased to nickel dime you. Stranger's don't care. The best overall value solution is finding a approved charity or non profit and donating everything then taking a write off. They then have to solve the dilemma of getting rid of the stuff. They'll take almost nothing when they sell because to them it's all profit. It will break your heart, but it isn't your problem. (Avoid the hurt, go away/stay away once they have the tools) And since you have all the references, reciepts, research done the IRS won't do much unless you attempt to deduct current or inflated retail prices for the deduction. Speaking from one time experience of clearing a relative's home shop the best that can be deducted is what you paid at the time of purchase subtracting depreciation. Keep in mind that except to you tools rarely go up in value unless you sell them privately. There are simply too many tools out there. Even on ebay, tools like Bridge City rarely get more than 80% of the original price even when pristine. Why do you think that they stop production on their tools -- it's to try to keep the value high. They don't make them anymore so there is a percieved rareity. Good luck. You are entering a deep pit. Keep the records, but if you find a buyer, don't think for a moment that you will be able to refer to a reference to quote a price. That's a a sure fire method of having the buyer depart.

Re: Future estate sale

#5

prices for used tools

Bill Tindall

There are "three prices" for used tools First, the price someone is willing to pay that needs the tool now and the alternative is buying a new tool. These customers are rare, but they will pay the best price. At any one time you may be able to find this kind of local buyer, or two, for a tool, or two, in a collection.

At some price you can sell anything to the person buying that might use the tool someday. I just bought a $100 Bostitch nailer on Ebayfor $15. There was one other bidder only willing to pay $14 and I would have gone $20. It was a steal but $15 was apparently better than any alternative the owener had.

Third are the persons looking to buy to resell. They are often the bottom of the bottom feeders, but they will "buy the lot" and the is selling is done.

I have been to numerous estate sales. Sometimes a few things go for a lot if there are several buyers that need that item. But overall the lot of stuff sells for embarrassingly cheap prices. At the most recent sale stuff was priced at 50% of new and a tiny fraction sold. A dealer made a lower price for all that remained and took it away.

An auction will take 30% of sales price.

My advice is to sell/give away stuff before it becomes a burden on the estate.

Re: Future estate sale

#6

Re: Estate Sale

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The term usually equates with "good stuff, cheap" to people in my area. I've gone to several and found that the d-i-y sellers had an inflated sense of what the items were worth. When it came to tools, I'd see price tags that were easily above 50% of retail, and would often see shoppers leaving empty-handed commenting that the sellers were "nuts" to be asking such prices.

As already mentioned, an estate may get more financial benefit by donating to a charity for the tax deduction.

"Special" tools with high personal or sentimental value should simply be given to someone who will appreciate the meaning, and use the tool as intended.

Tool junkies aside, the value of a tool is what we can make with it.

Re: Future estate sale

#7

Re: Future estate sale

Jason Waters

I agree with the other posters. I have seen it in my own family. I was offered to buy several nice used woodworking tools, but the tool reseller was offering a package deal, take it or leave it, and the few really worthwhile pieces basically added up to the total. So to him, a radial arm and tablesaw used price got him a bait of handplanes, hammers, etc. to resell for the profit after quickly breaking even on the two mentioned items. I didn't want to get in the middle of that, so I declined. I'll bet the package went for 20% of the value if new for a comparable tool, or maybe even less.

I've also seen the opposite, where someone is asking 10-15% below retail for a used piece of equipment, which is too much in my opinion.

It's really tricky as previously mentioned. If you don't have someone to will it to, maybe getting rid of what you don't need slowly as time goes is best in the interim. And then having a means to dispose of later, such as donation, or a prearranged sale with another interested party possibly.

Re: Future estate sale

#8

Thanks for the responses

John Pappas

I appreciate the time and thought that you all put into your responses. The whole exercise is about minimizing, or not leaving a problem to the family. Making some arrangement now to give everything away (except for a couple of sentimental items) probably makes the most sense. I'll explore my options in that regard. Thanks again.

Re: Future estate sale

#9

Re: Future estate sale

mdclor

How about using the WC classifieds and donating a portion (say 10-30%) of the proceeds to WC? This would likely work best for smaller items, but you might be surprised by being able to sell something larger. The advantages are that you have an audience that would know and appreciate your tools so you might get a price a little better than scrap metal (which is getting higher all the time) and you will be helping support a site that helps so many of us on a daily basis.

Re: Future estate sale

#10

Reminder

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

'Tis far better to give by a warm hand than a cold one.

Re: Future estate sale

#11

I like that, Mark