Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

trouble making a jig for 5 sided handle

Posts

trouble making a jig for 5 sided handle

#1

trouble making a jig for 5 sided handle

eliotandmax

I just felt like making a five sided handle. I found out that it's not so easy! what I did was to square up a block about six inches long and drill a hole down the middle of it 1 1/2 inches in diameter. I then cut this block lengthwise parallel to the center line at the correct distance from the center line to create a chord on the hole circle of very close to 11/16 inches in length. I then turned a cylinder of just under 1 1/2 inches dia. to fit into the hole. (In other words the cylinder protrudes the right amount so that when cut even with the jig the length of the cord is 11/16 in.) This cord length is the correct length for a regular pentagon. Next, the jig was set up on a router table with a straight bit and a bearing to cut the protruding part of the cylinder to the first flat of the pentagon. The cylinder is then rotated so that the resulting edge lines up with the edge of the cutout part of the jig. When done five times a five-sided handle comes out. To tell the truth, the method didn't work so well with a router. So I tried it on the band saw. I had trouble with that too because the downward pressure of the blade tended to turn the cylinder inside the jig. I figured a way to keep it from rotating, and that worked better. But accumulation of slight errors caused trouble here too. I intend to keep at it. But there must be a better way! Any thoughts?

Re: trouble making a jig for 5 sided handle

#2

Re: trouble making a jig for 5 sided handle

eliotandmax

Whoops! I meant to WRITE 13/16 inches -- not 11/16. I did USE 13/16 . But I just realized (in the middle of the night!) that this is most of my problem. The true mathematical length of the cord is a tiny bit different than that (1.5. x sin 36 deg). I knew that, but I thought it won't matter if the faces of the pentagon are a tiny bit off, so long as the pentagon is a nice regular one centered on the axis. My error was that the method I used for the AMOUNT OF ROTATION of the cylinder for each new cut was not good enough. With the value 13/16, the rotation of the cylinder inside the jig for each new cut was off a bit using my method. I should have marked out the ANGLE of rotation and used that! Duh! I'm still thinking there is a better way. How would you do it? I may ask the hand tool workers , too.

Re: trouble making a jig for 5 sided handle

#3

Not too fond of your method.

Keith Newton

I like to keep these things simple, and not sure why you are going to round first, but I would approach the geometry differently.

First, lets look at the pentagon as 5 triangles joined together in the middle. Their top angle is 72º. Subtract that from 180º for each triangle, leaves 108º. You could divide that by half, to find the other two corners is 54, but then each corner of your pentagon is two of them , so 108º is your angle for each corner.

Since your table saw reads 0º when it is cutting 90º, you need to tilt it over to 18º to just saw them out of a square, if you have a left tilt table saw.

If you start with a 1.5" square, and you want each facet to be say 3/4", you need that to be centered on the base of this first cut, so add another 3/8", so set your fence 1 1/8, and make your first cut. Then rotate so your new cut is down, and the bottom is now against the fence, and cut again, and again and again, and I guess one more time gets you around.

You may need to adjust the fence after that first rip, to hit your target side width, and i would think it would be a bit safer to start with a length of a couple of feet long, than a short 6" piece, then you will have 4 of them when you finish.

Re: trouble making a jig for 5 sided handle

#4

Re: Not too fond of your method.

Orion Thomas

If your making only one or two how about a simple pentagon template on either end of a squared blank, connect the points with lines running the length and plane to shape. Should be a quick and painless procedure.

Re: trouble making a jig for 5 sided handle

#5

Re: Not too fond of your method.

eliotandmax

Your method is superior. I thought of it but was worried about having to change the distance from the blade after the cuts. Also there would be a lot of waste if the type of wood is expensive -- unless one makes numerous handles. But you're right on.Thanks!

Re: trouble making a jig for 5 sided handle

#6

Re: Not too fond of your method.

eliotandmax

You know, after I got in trouble, I more or less did it this way --except I used a sanding center instead of a plane. I don't know what's wrong with me lately; I do know the KISS rule.