Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

Posts

OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#1

OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

Royce Meritt

After many years of trying, I finally won the fancy-shmancy Ducks Unlimited Dinner gun at our DU banquet last Saturday. For those of you unfamiliar with this gun, it is a Browning Maxus 12 ga. Semi-Auto. Limited edition #0177. Lots of fancy engraving, gold plating, etc.. etc. Seeking advice. What would you do with it?

1. Shoot the heck out of it? (it's only a gun, after all.)

2. Sell it a buy a more "practical" gun?

3. Tuck it away in the gun safe.

I'm actually leaning toward #1. It is after all, just a gun. I doubt it will actually increase in value over the years. It isn't really a "rare" gun. Every DU chapter gets one. I don't like the idea of tucking it away just to have my wife sell it 20 years from now. For the record, that model, without the fancy DU engraving, retails for about $1200.

What do you think?

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#2

#2

Bill Tindall

I used to hunt ducks and it wasn't an activity that was kind to guns. Personally I can't imagine hunting with a "presentation grade" shotgun. I would sell it and buy a used gun for ducks; but then I'm notoriously frugal.

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#3

Bang Bang

Dustmaker Mike

Use it enjoy it. Sounds like you are a Duck hunter anyway. I have a few older guns that came from my Great Grandfather and then my Grandfather and my father. My father never used it neither did my Grand Father so I took it to a gunsmith had it checked out and I am now using it for at least targets.

Drive By Galoot(-; Sounds like a nice gun

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#4

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

Jason Waters

I think you will find by looking in the books that many guns like these don't hold value as well as a standard model that is mint. Most people don't buy a standard model and tuck it in a safe. but guns like this they do. So there tends to be many out there in great condition. If you aren't going to shoot it, and you are just going to sell it in 20 years, why not get something you will shoot. Bad thing it's not a good time to sell anything for a good price.

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#5

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

bob murphy

#2 NM

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: #1

Moses Yoder

It seems strange to me that you would try to win this thing for many years, then finally accomplish that, then sell it. Really. One thing I have learned with rare tools I have sold, I always regret it. I spend the money, then I don't have either the money or the tool any more, and I can't just go buy another tool. I would suggest using it as a trap gun and having fun with it, then eventually passing it on to the next generation. It may not be worth much now, but I bet it will be in a thousand years.

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#7

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

John E. in SC

If it were me, I'd probably shoot it, with the intention of taking reasonable good care of it (as I do with all my guns), and passing it on down to another generation one day, assuming you have kids. If you do, I would imagine that gun would one day mean way more to them than any money you might get for it now.

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#8

#1 or #2....

John in NM

Depending on if you like shooting it or not. If you enjoy the thing use it, if not sell it and get one you'll like.

I've never understood the "keep it mint" mentality, from a financial point of view. There are far better ways to make money than collectables of any kind - there's as much luck involved as with horse racing :D

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#9

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

TomD

Only you can tell how much it means to you that it is DU. My thought would be do you want to be stuck using a Browning Maxus 12 ga. Semi-Auto from now on? If that is your dream gun, then go for it. I don't know how much you could get for it "second hand". Doesn't sound like there is a Parker in your future. Kinda oddball: probably too nice to shoot, and too shiny, and probably not nice enough to cherish, unless the DU part is a big deal.

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#10

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

My youngest son and I both collect guns - do target shoot, used to hunt but wife won't eat game & I won't shoot anything I don't eat. However it is hard for us to let loose of any gun. As others have said I doubt the shotgun will gain much more than inflation value in the near future as almost all are preserved. I think I would see what you are offered for the gun, then what it would cost to replace it with a hunting grade gun you really like. If there is enough difference to buy something else you want, then I would sell it and use the money. (Or keep it and buy the hunting gun anyway :>) ) I really think you could come out ahead selling it if others in your club want it badly enough. Side note: Another son of mine won a Benelli shotgun at a raffle about 3 months ago. It had a retail value estimated at $1400, he was going to sell it but ended up his wife loved it for skeet shooting so he lost it. (Don't let your wife see it)

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#11

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

While I am not a hunter (I won't shoot it if I won't eat it and I am not a big fan of game), I would use the gun as a target gun. Just think how intimidated all of the newbies will be when they see it - Wow! He must be good! Look at that gun! It must have cost him a fortune!

Of course, then you have to shoot well or the game is up.....

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#12

Re: Decision Made!

Royce Meritt

Thanks for all of your input. I decided to keep the gun and shoot it! I realized that this particular gun will mean more to me every time I take it out because it is a special gun that I won while I was supporting an organization that I like supporting, Ducks Unlimited.

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#13

Uh Oh!  Everyone . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

DUCK!!!!!!

:D

Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#14

Duck Duck Goose


Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#15

You guys are birds of a feather!   


Re: OT: Any hunters/DU members out there?

#16

Well

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Given this board, we do flock together . . .