Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Trim Finish Suggestion?

Posts

Trim Finish Suggestion?

#1

Trim Finish Suggestion?

Andygr2

Long time reader of all the expertise on this board, but I've got a quick question around finishing some trim on a basement project.

I plan on using all maple to trim it out and go for a natural finish look. I've got a 1 and 3 year old so my wife wanted the doors hang ASAP ........so they're already hung.

I was leaning towards using a hand rubbed product of some sort that i could apply as I have time vs spraying everything and stinking up the house big time. I also thought I could reapply when needed as my kids beat everything up.

Any thoughts or suggestions going this route. I'd like to bring the grain out a little and I'm ok with more of a low gloss or matte finish.

Thanks in advance for your advice and any specific products you'd recommend.

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

#2

you can't have it all......

Bill Tindall

Guiding principals to a decision....

1.It is a hell of a lot easier to do trim right the first time than to try to do it over. You have used maple for trim, not painted whatever. Not a good plan to short change the finish now and wind up painting it later.

2. Most oil based finishes yellow with time and make maple look yellow. Not my favorite maple finish. If you want to preserve the color then you must use a non-yellowing finish. The wood will eventually turn brownish with time and there is nothing you can do about that.

3. Trim around doors gets grungy and will need washing or at least some sort of cleaning. Hence, a durable finish is required. Paint is best. A water based non-yellowing urethane would be good for this application. Target Finishes makes a fine urethane material for maple trim. I have used it to good effect on maple. Prefinishing the trim with this material would have been a good idea. I always prefinish trim.

4. Shellac might be an acceptable choice. It is easy to renew. It is not the easiest material to brush on, especially vertical surfaces.

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

#3

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

As Bill has suggested I would use Shellac. You can purchase premixed (Sealcoat) or buy flake and mix your own. If you don't want any yellow - you would have to use either the Sealcoat or purchase blond flake. You can "pad" it on but may have to "cut" the shellac to a fairly thin material (I have used a 1 ~1 1/2 pound cut and applied several coats. Shellac is real easy to work with and can be easily renewed if it gets scratched or dirty. I like a satin surface so usually rub it out with 4-0 steel wool lubed with Minwax or Briwax after it is fully dry/cured. My son and I made all the wood work in his house in my shop using white oak, then finished with Amber shellac and rubbed out as above. That was about 4 years ago and the finish is still very nice looking. There will be some odor of alcohol so you would have to ventilate while finishing.

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

#4

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

Jim Hager

apply your finish before putting the trim on. After application of the trim fill nail holes and repair finish as necessary.

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

#5

What about tried and true original finish?

Andygr2

Appears to be a natural product, would something like this yellow over time?

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

#6

Re: What about tried and true original finish?

Bill Tindall

"Appears to be a natural product"........so is poison ivy.

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

#7

Not a good choice....

John in NM

Linseed oil starts out very yellow :D

I have used tried and true some, and you'll also find it a bit labor intesive for trim work I'd guess. Stuff is thick and gooey and won't really give you the results I think you're expecting.

I would suggest either a semi-gloss polyurethane or Danish oil, depending on if you want a film or not. Personally, I'd probably do the poly, good quality brush and thin coats and you won't have to worry about spraying. Wiping on a couple coats of Danish oil will be less work, but won't be quite as good a protectant as poly.

Once finishes are dry, they are pretty much all "food safe" or whatever, as long as they aren't pigmented with cadmium or lead or something like that :D

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

#8

Re: Trim Finish Suggestion?

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I would recommend Varathane Diamond floor finish for a clear non-yellowing wood finish. This is a water based urethane and it dries clear, doesn't raise the grain much and is very durable. Finish the trim first, then mount it. If you aren't sure of the lengths you can cut the finished trim and just touch up the mail holes and joints after it is hung.

Lee