Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

Posts

Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#1

Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

Guillaume Dery

Hi gang, I usually hang out in the Hand Tools section but I thiink this forum may be better for answers to this question.

Here goes. I am in the middle of finishing the basement/creating my shop. Being in a northern climate, walls are built up in front of the cement. In my case, I have 2" XPS foam to add as a thermal break/moisture barier, glued to concrete and taped joints. In front of that, I have 2X4 walls insulated with mineral wool which also incidentally house all my electrical etc. runs. Drywall on top.

Finally, the question:

Should I be worried about the load-bearing capabilities of those stud walls if I wanted to put my lumber rack on them (lagbolted to the studs)? They are nailed to the joists on top and fastened to the concrete below with 1/4" Tapcons every 3 or so feet. Should I add crossbracing between studs and go through my insulation to tapcon the braces into the concrete? Am I worried for nothing?

As an added piece of info, I don't usually keep a large lumber stash. Let's call it 2-300 BF at any given time.

Thanks in advance for any input. I will be back to pick brains on final electrical layout and lighting configuration at some other time.

Cheers,

Guillaume

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#2

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you haven't drywalled it yet, you should add metal plates to tie the studs firmly to your joists (in the U.S., the dominant company for these is Simpson Strong-Tie; looks like they have a less authoritative presence in Canada, see linky below, but there may be a Maple Leaf equivalent). Lacking metal plates, wooden gussets nailed or, better, bolted through would work too.

With that additional strength, I would think you'd be fine.

Always better to overbuild than to practice your cursing vocabulary later.

Bill, visiting from Hand Tools


http://www.strongtie.com/literature/canada.html

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#3

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

Tom Dunlap

I'm an arborist not a carpenter so my idea might be suspect. :)

If you're concerned about load why not consider skinning the walls with plywood? Compare the price to 'rock and taping, etc. Plywood walls make it much easier to hang 'stuff' later on. Screw and glue would seem to make a powerfully strong wall system.

Tom

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#4

JL

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

JL

What Bill said about the Simpson Strong Ties (or equivalent).

Most of your load will be in a downward direction rather than out. Your load will be spread between several studs. Now if you were to have your lumber storage at the top of your wall, sticking out several feet, there might be a problem.

You'll probably be storing on the order of 2000 lbs of lumber at maximum. If you keep to your idea of 300 board ft, probably on the order of 1300 lbs. I would make sure that your lag bolts were sturdy.

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#5

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

Guillaume Dery

Thanks,

Are you referring to hurricane ties? I will have to look into that. Right now the studs are nailed/screwed into the top plate which is nailed/screwed into the joists but I am sure I could get those to work. Never thought of it.

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#6

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

Guillaume Dery

Hey Tom, I thought about ply and may still do it over the drywall. I need to drywall though as the XPS needs a fire-barrier over it as per code. Apart from the obvious hanging benefits though, I am not seeing how ply vs sheetrock allays my concerns about shearing. Am I missing something?

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#7

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

Guillaume Dery

Last shop was in a garage and the 3" 1/4" lagbolts (3 per post) seemed to hold just fine for about 5 years so I am fairly comfortable with those

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#8

Hurricane ties are one type

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Simpson makes any number of different plates and brackets; again, I don't know if there's an equivalent Canadian company, and what will work best for your application will depend on the layout of the framing.

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#9

Why not just drop a leg or two

Dustmaker Mike

If you have the room just run a front leg down to the floor on each side. If you plan it right you could put a stationary tool under it so you are not loosing floor space. At least that is what I did in my basement, my lathe sits under the wood rack. Have fun

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#10

Re: Why not just drop a leg or two

TomD

In my garden shed, which has 2x4 on 2' centers, I have other 2x4s that canti straight out, and are held by brackets that overlap the studs, and the horizontals.

I have quite a load of lumber on the sheetrocked wall with just my french cleat holding it up, in my shop. I will try and get some photos. Basically it is your specifics, but 2x4s are plenty strong.

I don't quite get your details. I am familiar with poured concrete walls, and foam board forms. Or even stacked walls. Normally the wooden walls inboard of them are not load bearing, except in the dream world of Mike Holmes. So maybe if you could direct us to the online instructions we could better seize what it is you are doing.

Not saying to do the ply, but ply will help load share, and in fact can be structural for main loads. Frank Loyd Wright, who sometimes underspeced, :), Made a lot of his homes with 1" board and battens. The boards were the load bearing walls. So if you wanted to go all Holmes on it you could further tie some serious board onto the studs, up under the floor, and load share all kinds of stuff. Not necessary. Moreso, people put heavy boards between the studs so they can hang stuff anywhere, often in kitchens. But probably not what you want here.

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#11

Re: Shop and shed racks

TomD

The racks on the other side of the shed are so full you can't see them:


Both of these racks are hanging from the same French cleat that is screwed with one hefty screw to each stud in the wall:



Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#12

Tom - the load is not structural, but wood stash

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Tom:

You wrote "Normally the wooden walls inboard of them are not load bearing,..."

Agreed - but the OP is asking about what sort of load the wooden wall inboard can bear - to store his wood stash. So it is not bearing the structural load of the roof and upper stories, just the load of his wood stash.

Hope that makes sense. Your picture below is helpful, that is what I imagine the OP wants to do.

Henry

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#13

Re: Tom - the load is not structural, but wood sta

Guillaume Dery

Entirely correct.

I will take a pic tomorrow but yes. , these are not load bearing walls. I was just wondering about shearing off the joists if I put too big a load on the walls and if anyone knew what that shear point was.

Thanks for clarifying my question. You got it in 1.

Guillaume

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#14

Re: Tom - the load is not structural, but wood sta

Bill Tindall

It doesn't take much to hold up 300 gdft of lumber. At a typical weight of about 40 pounds per cubic ft this amount of lumber weighs about 1000 pounds. I put this amount on two saw horses made from 2 x4's routinely. If you distribute the load over at least 4 supports the stress on any point is trivial.

For larger amounts I like "H" style racks. The advantage is load bearing capacity. the disadvantage is they are only accessed from the ends. Each of these sections holds about 500 bdft of lumber on only three vertical supports.


Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#15

Re: Tom - the load is not structural, but wood sta

TomD

It is OK about the pic.

That lower one is attached to studs through drywall, so it might work for you. It will just come down to how much wood you need. Bill's being an example of a lot of wood. As you may know LV has a product designed to do exactly what you want, assuming you want a canti system. I was thinking you might since if you build out from the wall the studs will hardly need to hold the weight anyway.

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=32145&cat=1,43326

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#17

Re: Thx Bruce! the load is not structural

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Just what I was looking for!

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#18

Re: Tom - the load is not structural, but wood sta

Guillaume Dery

Hey Bruce thanks for the link. I am probably seeing Matthias this wed. Never think to ask local sometimes :)

At any rate, I think I will go with my general overbuild strategy which has never let me down and just put some hurricane ties to tie the studs on that wall to the header plate. My bottom plate is already screwed into the concrete with 1/4 Tapcons so the only thing that could fail is if the 2X4s shattered. That's a chance I can live with :)

PS: Doesn't Matthias come up with neat stuff? A few meetings ago, he brought his bandsaw and showed off his shop-made trolley that converts it to horizontal for sawing logs into lumber and last month he brought his tilting router lift. What an inventive guy!

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#19

Re: Tom - the load is not structural, but wood sta

Guillaume Dery

Ummmm.... would you consider adopting me? I want that wood stash!

Cheers.

And yeah, I realize I am overthinking and overbuilding it. I will just add some hurricane ties and be done with it

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#20

Matthias Wandel

Bruce, a MN Galoot

He's certainly a multi-talented guy! Take a look at his paintings sometime.

I envy you - he's one guy I'd like to meet. I do suspect, however, that you'd have a thing or two to teach him wrt hand tools. I think he picked the right time to bail out on RIM. I'd tell you to say hi for me, but we've never corresponded. I'm a big fan of his site.

Re: Semi-OT: Load bearing question for stud wall

#21

Re: Lumber Rack

Normp

Hi Guillaume,

I built a lumber rack similar to the one you are discussing a few years ago.

The individual shelves are cantilevered with angled supports. This works extremely well.

I had the same concern as you have about the whole rack just falling forward from the top. Since most of the load is downwards I still wanted to feel comfortable that I braced the complete lumber rack to the wall and eliminated any danger of it falling forward. What I did was to use lag bolts through the drywall( wall was sheeted already) and directly into the top plate. I also reinforced the top plate into each joist it intersected.

So bottom line, the upper lag bolts into the reinforced top plate instead of the top of the studs did the trick for me. It's been standing for about 8 yrs. now w/o any issues. Like you, I like to over-engineer these things, especially when heavy weights are involved.

BTW. the jointer is long gone. It was in the process of being sold.

Photo attached...