Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

Posts

Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#1

Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

Philip Duffy

Having spent a considerable amount of time, and money, reaching my decision to upgrade my Jet 14in with new Carter guides I was severely disappointed in the Instructions sheet, lack of descent photos and the company's failure to even mention that the use of metric Allen wrenches was required. My expectation was that a high quality product would have high quality instructions. NOT so! Sad. When I called to provide feedback to the company the receptionist could not get me off the phone soon enough. He sounded like he needed to go make a "head call".

If you are contemplating this change to your bandsaw give me a holler and I will give you some "lessons learned". Philip

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#2

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

Brian in SLO

I have to agree with you on the instructions or lack thereof. But, once you do get it set-up correctly they do work well. I did my fair share of grumbling when they were first installed but I've since quieted down and they work just fine.

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#3

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

Chuck Bjorgen

I went through the upgrade on my Jet 14" saw a few weeks ago with similar frustrations about the instructions. I found myself referring to Carter's web site illustrations for clarification on some details. Through trial and error I concluded metric wrenches were needed. Nice upgrade though although it's expensive.

Technical writing for instruction sheets and manuals seems to be a much neglected field.

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#4

Instructions? Seriously?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You read them, eh? ;)

When I put Carters on my 18" Jet it was a pretty straight forward deal. I obviously don't know about the 14" kit, but my set was largely self-evident as far as what-went-where.

Any time I work on my machines, I expect a mix of metric and SAE nuts, bolts and cap screws so I've got two sets of sockets and allen keys set out for use.

Took me all of half an hour to put mine on and get them adjusted.

Nice guides. Improved the saw's performance.

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#5

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

Barry Irby

I bought a set of Carter guides for my Delta 14" bandsaw and I assume they are extremely similar to yours. I wish you had asked me before you pulled the trigger. My personal opinion is they are crap. The instructions were poor, but that did not bother me much. The metric wrenches were no problem. My problem is they lack any sort of threaded adjustment. The idea I am supposed to set the rollers within a few thousands of the blade by loosening a screw with an Allen Wrench and then twiddling it into position with my fingers and then tighten the screw and expect them to stay where I put them is ridiculous if you consider what I paid for them.

Also, I find the lower wheels in particular have a tendency to roller press sawdust onto the blade, particularly if you are sawing something sticky like old growth pine. I am seriously considering going back to the cool blocks on the lower set at least.

I would have sold you my set Cheap and felt bad about taking your money.

One of my least favorite purchases.

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#6

Geez, Barry

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Don't hold back. You're among friends here so you can tell us how you really feel! :D

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#7

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

Howard Acheson

Fine Woodworking did a review of guides for use on 14" band saws a few years ago. They didn't like the large roller guides like the Carters. They did not control the blade that well primarily because of the large diameter which moved the point of blade support down on the lower support and up on the upper. They were also quite noisy. They had some other issues. They were expensive, they damaged the blade if the blade miss-tracked as well as damaging the roller guides themselves.

Their bottom line was that the Cool Blocks were the best. They provided the best support, didn't damage the blade or themselves in the event of miss tracking and, maybe best of all, they Cool Blocks were the cheapest.

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#8

Mine came with a similar set up...

John in NM

Not Carters, but a copy of them.

I more or less share your sentiments. They work ok, but I've seen better. The one good thing I'll say is that the bearings are very commonly available, so you can keep them on hand for frequent replacement. The thrust bearings wear out fast, they get full of dust and seize after a couple years of moderate use, maybe 6 months of heavy use. Next time I buy replacements (mine are 6200's IIRC) I plan to try the rubber sealed type, probably last a hair longer than the metal sheilded ones. I'm considering taking the sheilds off the lower thrust bearing and cleaning out all the dust holding grease to run it dry. Loads are so brief that it might end up surviving longer that way - theory is its the dust/grease combination that kills them fast.

Great source for bearings is VXB, they should have spares for $1-$2 each, depending on the quality you want. I was tempted to try their full ceramic open bearing as a thrust bearing, but at $60 a pop I'd hate to be wrong :D

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#9

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

TomD

My Laguna had the special Carter upgrade, that for the most part just gets in the way. Not a complex install though.

In general there wasn't that much wrong with my fixed bearings, they were a lot faster to set, though the Laguna does not require as much resetting, which is good.

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#10

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

wilbur

Michael Fortune dislikes ball bearing wheel bandsaw guides for that very reason: the spinning of the bearings tends to draw sawdust into the gap between the bearings and the blade. Best case scenario is that it adds vibration to the blade. Worst case scenario is the sawdust packing that you describe.

My bandsaw has steel guide blocks. I took a file and put the slightest bit of a crown on them to minimize the contact area. I don't have a threaded adjustment either for the guide blocks, but it's easy to set them by wrapping a thin sheet of paper around the blade, and pushing the guide up against the paper. That way the paper sets the guides about 0.002" or so away from the blade.

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#11

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

My Jet 14" bandsaw came with some ridiculously soft plastic blocks that scored almost immediately. I put on a set of Carter guides and I don't have much bad to say about them. I could agree with the lower guide problem, but so far, it hasn't been a problem for me. I just set that guide with a bit more slop and the sawdust goes right through.

The one thing I really like is that the thrust bearing is set up so the blade runs on the outside of the bearing, not against one face. I have never understood why so many guides have the thrust bearing face running against the blade. That creates a scraping motion that digs a groove in the bearing if it ever hangs up.

I would love a set of ceramic style guides like Laguna. They weren't available when I got the Carters or I probably would have them.

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#12

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

Philip Duffy

Obviously, Carter co. has no shame, otherwise, they would have fixed their problems by now, not just with the instructions but with their products and reputation. Sorry bunch. Philip

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

#13

Re: Carter Bandsaw guide upgrade

Howard Acheson

>>>> My Jet 14" bandsaw came with some ridiculously soft plastic blocks that scored almost immediately.

Yes, they were junk. They were an Asian knock-off of the Cool Blocks. Cool Blocks were made with materials that were not affected by heat.

Most just substituted the real Cool Blocks.