Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Drill press failure

Posts

Drill press failure

#1

Drill press failure

iew

My Jet JDP-17 base failed and nearly fell on me. I don't know if a crack developed in the casting and been there for a long time or if it just let go. It broke around the flange where it was bolted. Suggest if you have one of these inspect the base around the bolts for cracks.

Re: Drill press failure

#2

Hope you weren't hurt!  Scary.

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you haven't already, you should contact Jet. I don't know how they are about warranties or about failures like that following warranty, but it's hard to believe that a home shop could stress a drill press that much.

Re: Drill press failure

#3

Re: Drill press failure

steve mackay

Never even HEARD of that one ! Eh Gods, lemme go look !

Re: Drill press failure

#4

Wow!

John in NM

Glad you're ok, drill presses tend to be really top heavy!

Re: Drill press failure

#5

Re: Drill press failure

John Lucas

Wow I've never seen that happen and I've seen alot of old drill presses. Must have had a problem in the casting.

Re: Drill press failure

#6

Re: Drill press failure

Ralph Lipeles

I had the same thing on a Craftsman drill press many years ago. When I unpacked it, I saw small cracks just where yours failed. I was lucky that I spotted them and got it replaced earl in the game.

Re: Drill press failure

#7

Re: Drill press failure

Bill White

I'll bet that got your attention. You're one lucky guy.

Bill

Re: Drill press failure

#8

Re: Drill press failure

JMOHNIKE

I have seen this on two other DPs. Question, was your bolted to the floor? I was told a long time ago that if they are bolted to the floor any vibration will cause a thin cast base to fail. It was suggested to not bolt them to the floor which allows the vibration to "leave" the base. Does that make any sence? Any way mine is not bolted to the floor. Glad no body was hurt.

Re: Drill press failure

#9

Re: Drill press failure

woody

I feel that if there is a set in the base it should be loosened so the column drops. It should then be tightened to take weight off the casting.

Re: Drill press failure

#10

Re: You might be onto something there Woody

Charlie Lenz

I'll have to check mine. I allways read the Owners Manuals, so if they suggested that I would of done it. But I will have to look into it, because it's been awhile since I bought and assembled the Drill Press ( Craftsman 17" )

Re: Drill press failure

#11

Re: You might be onto something there Woody

Iw

The press was not bolted to the floor. Interesting idea letting shaft sit on floor. That would not have prevented the failure, all the weight would still be on the front of the base.

Re: Drill press failure

#12

Re: I disagree

Charlie Lenz

How would all the weight be on the front of the base ? With the motor hanging out the back I think that it's fairly close to balanced until you use it and start pulling down on the handle, and or have something thats really heavy sitting on the table. Do you move the drill press around by walking it across the floor ? For some reason I don't think we are hearing the hole story as to why it failed, and I hate guessing what happened. Generally these things do not happen by themselves.

Re: Drill press failure

#13

My best guesses

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

If that was a new drill press, which I'm assuming it isn't since there is no white paint on the base, I'll bet it and others with similar failures of the the cast iron base around the column, were shipped partially or fully assembled from China/Taiwan in crates packed in a larger crate or shipping container in the VERTICAL position. Sometime during shipment or handling the smaller crate or larger container was dropped. The weight of the column, and possibly headstock and table, pushing down onto and against the base caused the failure.

If it is an older one, it could have been dropped as above or the owner over-tightened the bolts holding it to a shop floor cracking the base. In the second case, depending on the casting, the bolt holes might break out or if the column extended too far out the bottom the base could break around the column.

There are other scenarios that could cause the same failure- iron worker dropping or tossing or stacking the bases while upside down. Really poor casting with flaws exacerbated when the column opening was milled, etc. An aggressive attack by a pneumatic chipper or needle gun when attempting to remove rust and paint can do the same thing.

Finally, if it was bolted to the floor and was subjected to side loads at table or headstock height (that is a long moment arm and can create a lot of leverage!), that would slowly do the same thing, as would the entire DP tipping over, only then it would be immediate.

Re: Drill press failure

#14

Re: Drill press failure

wooden leg

If you are able to get a new table are you going to see about getting the bigger rectangle one? If you can would you share how you did it? Thanks, Dave

Re: Drill press failure

#15

Re: Drill press failure

Iw

Table is ok, going to keep it. New base on order with new crank handle. Crank handle has been broke for years. This has been an excellent drill for 15 years. I moved it around some years back and that could have caused a crack.

Re: Drill press failure

#16

Re: Drill press failure

JMOHNIKE

You got me to thinking so I checked my 1960's vintage rockwell DP, the base plate has a stop so the colum can not slide to the floor. still a good thought.

Re: Drill press failure

#17

Re: My best guesses

Jason Waters

I would agree on the shipping thing, except I know my Jet was shipped with the head off, and there were some parts to assemble. I bought the floor model, but had looked at mine many times in the box so to speak.