Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Recommendation for drum sander requested

Posts

Recommendation for drum sander requested

#1

Recommendation for drum sander requested

Bill Tindall

I have a loaner Ryobi 16" drum sander. It works ok except changing the sand paper is tedious to the point where I don't do it when I should to change grits. A 12" sander would do what I need to - mostly sand home made veneer, never wider than 12". 16" machine is ok too.

does anyone have experience with the Grizzly 12" machine? What is the best drum sander in a 12-16" size? Are other models easier for changing the sand paper?

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#2

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested *LINK*

Dave Paine

Bill,

I have a Performax 16in drum sander. I would likely not buy this again. It may be me, but the items I sand are narrower in the middle than the ends, and I try REALLY hard to avoid this.

I also have a Flat Master, see link. If you want ease of changing abrasives, this is the way to go. Barry Irby re-configuired his Performax to try a similar arrangement.

The big benefit is almost zero heat when sanding, so you could even sand off finishes.

I find I am able to get a much flatter surface with this unit than my Performax.

They also sell kits, so you could likely build your own frame.

Note the price does not include motor. I bought my motor from Grizzly.

If you do stick with a drum sander, I recommend the blue ziron abrasive from Klinspor. It does not generate as much heat, so less gumming up. So far I get a LOT more use from this abrasive than the Klingspor regular abrasive which came with the unit.


http://www.stockroomsupply.ca/shop/drum-sanders.html

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#3

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

Barry Irby

Bill, I have a Performax 16/32 and like it. They sold out to Jet I think and the machine is still made by them. The sandpaper is not all that easy to change but not bad once you get the knack. They make a little clip that holds the latch for you but I don't have one. They used to make a ten inch machine which I think was open ended so it would have been a 10/20. I have something of a love hate relationship with it but if it died I would buy another.

I bought mine used and would recommend looking for one that way.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#4

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

Nelson

I have 16 32 and love it. I hear a lot of people say its hard to change the paper, I don't get it, I can change the paper in about one minute and it's easy.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#5

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

norm knoxville

Bill, bought a Flatmaster a couple(3?) of years ago after I saw it demonstrated at the Nashville Woodworking show. I was impressed with the fellow sanding pine without any pitch build up and when he stalled a cherry panel over the drum without burning it. The under surface roller reduces dust greatly and it's sturdy. I was into jewelry and bandsaw boxes when I bought this sander and it works super for thin stock. Little heat and it takes a minute to change paper.

Now that I am retired I'm doing larger projects to supply the grand kids with they're furniture choices and I use my 16 inch dual drum Grizzly for just about everything. It is a pain to swap paper on this guy, but taking light passes helps it live longer.

If you'd like to try either of these guys out when your in Knoxville give me a shout. You can bring your own stock or clean up some of mine.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#6

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

TomD

I had the performax for guitar making, but sold it after about 5 or maybe 10 years. Good resale actually. I would check reviews on acoustic guitar sites before slapping down cash, or bow making sites.

Grizzly has a fair reputation because their president is a guitar builder and beefed up their offerings.

Unless you are running just a few boards, or mostly just sanding for light finishing, I would move right into a belt based machine. The drum ones have serious limits. So right now if I was diving in again for guitars I would buy the grizz 10" drum, subject to more reviews, or go straight for a grizz or similar drum machine. Some of them are not even that expensive. Actually grizz might be the one with 3 phase, but there are 15 inch open end belt machines that run on household.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#7

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

matt overton

I have the Sand-Flee. It is VERY expensive, but very well built and I use it for everything. Well worth checking out if this is the style sander you are looking for. They have a smaller model. The Flat master is a wooden knockoff of this design. I also have a Delta 16-32 that I find myself not using due to heat buildup and finicky tolerance adjustments.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#8

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

Don Evans

Bill, I've got a Jet 10-20 drum and so far like it. I have no experience with another type so cannot make comparisons. I've read the other responses and they are probably doing the same thing, none of us know more than one or two tools.

I saw a couple of comments on heat build up? That makes me wonder if they may be just over working the design of the machine. Sanding works on friction therefore heat. The instructions that came with the Jet clearly indicates that light passes are the way to go as opposed to fewer heavy passes.

This machine works by sanding 10" wide but left end is open so for wider stuff you turn it around and run the other side through giving you 20" wide sanding. One feature that I really like comes with the open end units and that is they must have the ability to tilt the drum so you can do that turn around. In the case of panel doors you would tilt it just very very slightly on left so you don't get a dig in the middle of the project, you then smooth this with final ros sanding. The fact that it is tiltable means you can, with carefull adjustments, make it flat from left to right.

Changing paper seemed at first a pain mostly due to Taiwan English but after couple of changes and doing it I figured out you only use the holding tool on one side, the other end you can do by hand. So just takes minute or so.

On another note: I have seen somewhere instructions for making a drum unit to use on one's lathe. The problem I see with that is the drum, so if I wanted to try that I would buy as a part one of the professional made drums from Jet or Sandflee etc and build it from there. It was simple to make, mount drum between centers and board under drum at an angle with an adjustable wedge to move the board up and down adjusting the thickness. Just a thought, but it's accuracy will just depend on your ability to get the panel that work slides on accurate in relation to the drum. If you try to make the drum or use something made for another purpose as the drum I think it would be a failure.

Just my 2 cents

Don

PS I like the jet and I only bought it for figured wood but it's turned into my go to machine after the planer for final thickness. Important note, I don't do production work, if I did and had to change setting on the drum constantly then I would hate it.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#9

thanks and clarification

Bill Tindall

I would mostly use the sander for sanding to uniform thickness home made veneer. Some of the suggestions do not seem to be suitable for this need. ?.

I was unaware that a 10/20 machine existed. It would suit my needs.

I would like to quiz a Grizzly owner abut the closed end 12" machine if there is one out there.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#10

Re: thanks and clarification

Bob Lang

I reviewed the Grizzly when it first came out. Because it isn't open on one end, it didn't have the issues that the open-ended machines do with flexing. Changing the paper wasn't as much of a pain, but it wasn't painless. I thought it a decent machine, my biggest gripe was that the abrasives are a hook and loop system rather than a rigid drum. That left a bit of flex that made it difficult to hit an exact thickness. If I was tying to bite off more than the machine wanted to chew, the hook and loop would compress. A second pass without moving the table would still remove more material. Things were okay if you ran everything through in one batch. If you had to come back later on, it was hard to match a thickness. We had it around for about a year, and used it off and on, so I don't have long term experience with it.

For the money, I think its a good value, but it doesn't do what a wide belt machine will do.

Bob Lang

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#11

Thanks for the additional data

Bill Tindall

I had two concerns with the Grizzly, the hook and loop which I feared would do what you found and the smaller drum which might make a less smooth surface. However, I am just looking for something to sand pieces of 3/32(about) veneer.

No question the benefits of a wide belt sanding machine but not for the amount of stuff I make in a year.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#12

Re: Thanks for the additional data

Barry Irby

Bill, I run thin stuff through my 16/32 all the time. I saw a slice of veneer, sand the sawed face of the blank lightly to remove the saw marks and then take another slice. Then if I want to I use a caul and sand the veneers themselves. I use the caul so that the belt does not brush the conveyor belt and sand the grit off it. If the pieces are thick enough, I use a cross piece on the caul to hold them in place. (usually use a piece of MDF or Melamine for a caul. If they are very thin I use double stick tape on the lead end. I was able to consistently sand to 1/50" on birds eye maple and used the pieces in a lamp shade. I made some so thin the double stick tape was thicker than the veneer and it sanded away to nothing above the tape.

I would be skeptical of the H&L sandpaper for this application, but as mentioned above I have no experience with it so I am just being skeptical. After all, I have a Ford and I ain't even going to look at no Chevy. Or vice versa.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#13

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

John b

I believe that it is well worth the money. I have owned it for a number of years. Once i switched to the Klingspore 100grit stearated paper it made a large difference. I go straight to the sander from the bandsaw, it only takes a couple of passes. 100grit paper is all that i use it does not take much hand sanding to get the desire finish. My planer does not get as used as much. The Grizz 12" is not a production mach it just operates as it was designed for. John b. SW Chicago burbs

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#14

checking to be clear......

Bill Tindall

so many machines have been mentioned. Your comments are for the Grizley 12" machine that looks like a small planer? If so that is what I will be buying. Is it annoying changing paper?

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#15

Re: checking to be clear......

John b.

Bill the one that i have is G0459. The price has gone up quite s bit since i got mine. I don't think that it is a big deal to change the abrasive. I purchased my paper from Klingspore, 100grit stearated(the white stuff), and don't change it all that often. I also prefer to do my finishing sanding by hand. The key is to let the paper do it's job don' push it, it is not a production sander. I believe that you can down load the manual and take a look how the paper is changed. I saved the original paper and use it as a template. The first time i changed paper it took me about 20min, now it is less than 5min. John b. SW Chicago burbs.

Re: Recommendation for drum sander requested

#16

Bart Goldberg

Grizzly G0459 Review On Amazon

Bart Goldberg

I was just checking out the reviews for this sander on Amazon and there seems to be a significant number of complaints regarding the convey drive system. Appears that many users have seen repeated problems with the drive shaft breaking. I would speak to Grizzly to see if they have corrected this issues before I'd buy this machine.

Bart