Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

Posts

Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#1

Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

One of the things I hate is removing planer marks from lumber - It's boring and eating dust isn't my favorite thing to do. I have a couple of 3HP motors laying around the shop, so I thought about making a drum sander to do the rough sanding, with the added benefit of being able to do thickness sanding of thin pieces. I read Dominic's and Ray's articles and I think I have the chops necessary to do this. I will probably use wood even though I have experience with fitting and welding metal (built a rear-engine dragster from a pile of chrome moly tuning in my youth), as I no longer have space to do a proper setup and jigging before welding.

I have a couple of questions for those that have either built a drum sander or use one:

- Most of the plans I found are for hand-fed sanders. The lazy part of me would like to have a power feed. How important is a power feed to you? I will be sanding mostly longer boards, like a planer.

- Many of the sanders I see have a hook and loop method of attaching the sandpaper strip. It would seem to me that this would tend to melt if you take a heavy cut, or am I worrying about nothing? Have you had any issues with the softer surface of a hook and loop attachment?

- Anything else I should be thinking about?

Thanks for your help.

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#2

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Jim Hager

Think lighter cuts. A drum sander is good for some things but is definately not on my list of things to get next. I have had 4 different drum sanders trying to find one that was good, finally got a good GI sander but it still wasn't what I was hoping for. You are going to be trading your planer marks for drum sander streaks, almost as difficult to sand out.

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#3

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Hi Robbie,

Now here is a subject I have pondered many times. I have gathered a bit of information by Googling shop or home built sanders. I began a build in that I acquired a couple of old treadmill machines. They provided power feed at variable speed with the rubberized belt and platen. One even had the ability to increase the incline electronically, which would provide power depth of cuts. In fact, I still have many of those parts laying around in Arizona.

But bottom line, for removing planer marks, a Performax works wonderfully and I was fortunate enough to find one dirt cheap on Craigslist a while back. In fact, I found it in El Cajon! :) I had the 22-44 for many years. When I left California I foolishly sold it. My second one is a 16-32 and suit me fine.

Having said that, removing planer marks and sanding to 120 is easy. Generally light passes until the marks are gone. I rough cut my pieces and sand to 120. This I mill parts and assemble. That is a big head start on final sanding.

Sanders are not wood removing machines. Planers are. Sanders kiss the wood. With that thought in mind, your sand paper is more likely to gum up and create burn marks on the wood before the hook and loop melts. And that happens with heavy passes without belt and loop. This effective ruins teh expensive belt just as effectively as melting the hook and loop.

This I certainly know! Now you have some first hand stuff to think about.

BTW, I will be in Escondido this coming week, if you'd like to visit face to face. Email me your phone number. carol.j.reed@gmail.com

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#4

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Dick Coers

Jim is right about drum sanders. They put sanding marks in the wood that require a fair amount of sanding to get rid of. Drum sanders are SLOW. The paper doesn't last long since it gets back to the wood really quickly. Don't get me wrong, I love my Performax 16-32. I use it for drawer stock, boxes, shaker box stock, etc.... I wouldn't like to throw 10' stock in there. My favorite machine was a stroke sander I had in my professional shop. The abrasive basically floats over the wood, and doesn't leave heavy scratches. In a drum sander, the size of the abrasive is the depth of the scratch. I wouldn't use a drum sander without power feed. I think most of those hand fed are used by instrument makers with a couple boards to do.

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#5

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Carol wrote:

"Having said that, removing planer marks and sanding to 120 is easy. Generally light passes until the marks are gone. I rough cut my pieces and sand to 120. This I mill parts and assemble. That is a big head start on final sanding."

RW: That is what I am thinking about doing.

"With that thought in mind, your sand paper is more likely to gum up and create burn marks on the wood before the hook and loop melts."

That negates that worry. Thanks for the info. I do have a planer for the heavy removal.

I am sending you an email too.

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#6

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Jim - Thanks for replying. Did you get streaks even with a light cut with 120 grit paper?

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#7

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Thanks for the info, Dick. My thinking has changed to "rough cut the parts first, then sand".

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#8

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Forgot something: I wish I had room for a stroke sander. That is going to have to wait for my dream shop. I bought an 8" jointer a few years ago and it seems like I spend quite a bit of my time manuvering around it. I think a rethink of my shop layout is in the future. Too many toys, not enough room.....

I have to admit that I get almost as much of a kick out of making things for the shop as I do making projects. I have been messing around with some highly figured wood and need to surface it. I am kind of chicken to try it in my planer and that thought of that much sanding with a belt sander does not excite me.

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#9

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Jim Hager

Yes you will get streaks no matter what you do. The nature of a drum sander makes that the case. Your sanding will need to be done in LIGHT passes but even then your paper will become loaded with resins in rings that will leave the streaks.

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#10

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Barry Irby

I have a Performax 16/32 I bought used for $400. I really like it and think it was a great investment. A friend of mine has a huge belt sander with a 36" wide belt. (TimeSaver?) It has a 12 hp motor and a 1 hp feed motor. There is no comparison between the two machines. Of course there is no comparison between the prices either, His cost thirty times as much and runs on 3 phase power and I don't have that or the room for the machine. Like comparing a pickup to a Peterbilt.

The Performax is agonizingly slow. Seems underpowered. Wish it had a two Hp motor rather than a one HP. Carol's description of Kissing the wood is right on. I have started buying the sandpaper in fifty something yard long rolls that brings the price down from $7 to $3 per "belt". Much better, I get some use out of each one and don't have a heart attack when I have to trash one. (I still soak them in Simple Green and reuse them when I can)

I think power feed is a must. I have infeed and out feed rollers set up for mine and they are a huge help on longer stock. Made them out of old tread mill rollers. Mine is set up at about knee height because I too have a small shop and space problems. it parks under the wing of the TS and one of the roller sets serves as out feed rollers on the TS until I get a big sanding project and then I move it to its alternate assignment.

I looked at the Sand Flea. You basically slide the board over the top of a table with a sanding drum in it. It used Velcro to attach the paper. I suspect it rounds the corners a bit because the paper is "soft". I made a table to sit on top of my Performax and turned it into A Sand Flea. I use it once in a while for pieces too thick to go through the performax. (Great for touching up dovetails and the like. and knocking the corners off the hundred "pickets" in a arts and crafts piece.) It relies on YOU to keep the piece moving and to not end up with "snipe" if you pause. Would not want to sand large pieces this way.

The only streaks I get are when I install a belt too loosely and it over laps in the wraps and burns a piece. I quickly stop and fix the belt and re-sand that piece. If the belts is too loose and "flying" above the drum it will round over the lead and trailing ends, which is why I suspect the Sand Flea.

Having mentioned that it is slow, it will sand stock that my planer will destroy. Having destroyed a few things, I know this to be true. I had some curly walnut root stock and the planer ate one piece. In a few hours, I sanded the rest to uniform thickness. (Had it resawn by a guy with a bandsaw mill. He was apparently blind in one eye and could not see out of the the other one and was drunk. Any relationship these pieces bore to the thickness I asked for was a coincidence.) Started with a 36 grit belt and reduced them to the a nearly uniform thickness and then sanded them to near perfection. Without the Performax, I would have had nothing. With it, a beautiful set of drawer fronts for a chest of Drawers. Took about two hours.

Yes, it does leave sanding marks. I find it most useful for medium grits like 80 and 120. If the planer is performing well I give most things a pass at 120 and then sand by hand or with a ROS. I clean up snipe and slight planer marks with 80 and then hit it with 120. Its quick and easy to recue the 120 grit marks to accepatable. If you prefer, you can run them again at 180 or 240.

All in all, a very useful machine and I would buy another if this one failed.

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#11

Web page about drum sanders

del schisler

here is a web page about drum sander's you may get some idea's from it

http://www.woodworkersjournal.com/Ezine/Articles/Stockroom_Supplys_V_Drum_Sander_A_Unique_Drum_that_4130.aspx

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#12

Rick L

Re: Drum sander still leaves marks...

Rick L

You will still need to random orbit sand your panels. A drum still leaves a ripple type mark. A hook and loop paper leaves a less pronounced ripple than a wrap on a stiffer drum. Drums are typically steel, aluminum, rubber coated steel or discs of ply or mdf for many home builts. It is possible to melt the hook backing on a drum from too much pressure. Obviously the hook backing is glued to the drum. Changing the hook on a steel drum on a 36" Woodmaster is a long afternoon with solvents and heat. Would be easier to make a new wooden drum or I suppose you might glue some 80 grit sandpaper and feed it through the sander to sand off the hook and adhesive.

The better drum sanders oscillate which minimizes linear scratch marks and the same is true on a widebelt sander. The longer belts on a widebelt run cooler and most have a platen between the drums which duplicates the stroke sanders high quality finish.

The worst woods to sand are pitchy woods like pine and such as it gums up the paper. You can use those crepe sticks to clean off the belt and or simple green with a stiff scrub brush will remove pitch. We use special liquid cleaners on widebelts to wash off the pitch.Standard practice I've seen in 40 years of commercial shops.

My preferred sander for low budget is a stroke sander by far. The finished results can go right to staining and they don't take up as much room as you think. Certainly less room is needed than a drum or wide belt as you need to allow for infeed, outfeed and the length of the drum or widebelt itself. Stroke sander size would be the longest panel it can handle and a couple feet on each end and you can put it against a wall and in a corner which is a point that is typically missed by those who never used a stroke sander. You can often pick them up for a few hundred dollars. How often do yo sand longer than 6' and stroke sanders can do wider than a drum sander. The open ended drum sanders aren't that great.

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#13

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

TomD

Drum sanders will find a whole new way to waste your time. Joggle your blades, to eliminate the tracks, and get friendly with a scraper. There are some materials where the sanders are the only choice like certian guitar woods, but otherwise unless you are willing to spend industrial bucks, I do not find them useful. There are lots of plans on the guitar sites.

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questions

#14

Re: Thinking about building a drum sander - Questi

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Thanks for the ideas, all. You have given me plenty to think about.