Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

Posts

OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#1

OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

Gary Smyth

Ever heard of stop/start engines? You will. Years 2012 to 2025 progressively, cars will shut the engine down at stop lights, stop signs, coasting, rush hour traffic, and any other time your foot is not on the accelerator. Not a new technology, but with 54mpg requirements in the offing (2025) it has been reloaded and being launched this year in a serious fashion by Ford, Chevy, Buick, Fiat, Volvo, Alfa-Romeo, Kia, and BMW. Obviously car motors starters (synchronized) and other electrical components will have to be upgraded from 30,000 to 350,000 activations during the life of the car. Did you know that a typical car today averages 50 microcontrollers and 60 pounds of onboard wiring? That number will double with start-stop as almost all has to be better controlled, bigger, stronger, more powerful. Crankshafts will be bulked up and strengthened. Battery cranking and reliability increased. What happens with the car off and AC on? What about steering? Fuel flow? Braking? They’re working on it. But still Europe already uses a reliable but primitive form of start–stop in 20% of new cars. Before today I hadn't heard of stop-start. I thought I might pass the information along.

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#2

Been around for a long time

Neal in San Jose

The first time I heard about it was the mid '70s when Toyota started developing a system. I understand that there are several manufacturers that already produce and sell these in Europe and Asia. Honda has been selling a version of their 125 cc scooter with start-stop in Japan since sometime in the '80s. Mazda has a system that doesn't use a conventional starter - the computer looks to see which piston is already in the best position to start, and then just fires that spark plug. Audi holds the record for milage with a car that uses a start-stop system, and they use a combined starter/alternator. Several of the systems use an electric motor to run things like A/C, power brakes and steering, so it doesn't matter if the gas engine is running or not. Estimates I've seen are that these systems improve milage 5 to 10 percent in city driving but they wouldn't make any difference to highway milage of course. Exciting times ahead!

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#3

Re: Been around for a long time

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Lots of professional yardworker carts have used this for a long time, too.

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#4

No problem-

john lucas

On my budget I will never be able to afford a new car. It will be 10 or 15 years before all of that filters down to used cars in a price range I can buy. By then I'll be retired and won't need to drive very far so I'll probably still buy older technology vehicles. Either that or gas prices will be so high I'll ride the bicycle everywhere.

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#5

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

Dale warder

Toyota Prius uses this technology now. It has been in use for at least 10 years. Apparently makes quite a difference in fuel economy.

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#6

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

Gary Bindel

When I was in Japan around 2005, they had it on the buses.

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#7

Oh, c'mon. You've seen this technology before. *LINK*

Henry Higginbotham

Maybe not quite as advanced as what you were thinking of. And a bit noisy. :D

I'd rather walk, but that's just me.


Start/stop vehicle

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: Very common around here

Moses Yoder


Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#9

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

Don Evans

As far as running all the accessories back when Chev had police car bids out the version that went to the police had all accessory items run by electric motors. There was no serpentine belts on the engine to power anything. This was ofcourse to give the engine all available power to moving the car, fast! Chevy got out of the police car line because Dodge beat the bids with cheaper (and I don't mean less expensive, I mean cheaper) cars. With government, cheap allways seems to win.

Our 86 Oldsmobile had two electric fans for the radiator cooling - that was the engine radiator and the A/C coil. One fan was larger and main fan, smaller one would come on when weather in high 90's and idle in traffic, other than that the small one didn't run. That was 26 years ago!!

So nothing new about that part of the concept, but the one problem I do see if you are after the perfect answer is there is a point in duration of off time verse leaving it running as far as gas consumption is concerned. That point is a moving target also. Depends on car or truck. It takes more fuel to start my 325 hp truck than it would burn at idle for a short stop light. Back in the 90's that time was about 1 1/2 minutes I heard. Don't know if that is true or not and don't really care but the concept was that if you wanted to save and you knew you would be idling for that time or longer it was best to shut down the engine, if time was going to be shorter then leave it running was more economical.

It is really a lot of things coming together that is making this concept a reality but I think "fuel injection" was the biggest leap that makes it possible. They make car fire with one turn over where wasn't many years ago if you remember it would take 3 to 4 turn overs with a well tuned car before firing. That was a lot of raw gasoline being spit out the tailpipe unburned.

Don

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#10

That's the way to do it.


Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#11

My Prius already does this.


Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#12

Re: Very common around here

john lucas

Jay Leno said the Amish didn't want to put the glow in the dark triangle on the back of their buggies because thier religion tells them not to do things to stand out in a crowd. Of course a buggy does exactly that. :) If gas keeps going up I may have to go that route although it would have to be pedal powered for me.

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#13

Manual Start-Stop - by law

Bill Howatt

In the city of Ottawa, Ontario, and perhaps in others there is a law that states:

"No person shall cause or permit a vehicle to idle for more than three (3) consecutive minutes in a sixty (60) minute period"

There are exclusions for emergencies, parades, if the outside temperature is above 80 degrees or below 40 degrees. I think the intent was to try and cut down pollution caused by idling in drive-through lineups. In my visits to Ottawa, I can't say I've noticed any extra starting and stopping though.

Bill

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#14

Re: Manual Start-Stop - by law

Brian Aust

When I was stationed in Germany in 1990 the Germans would shut off their engines while stopped at a traffic light. The light would turn green/yellow before turning green to let them know that the light was turning green and to restart their engines. The law also said if you left your car you had to lock it.

Re: OT - Car and Truck, Start-Stop

#15

Re: Manual Start-Stop - by law

NickinMass

I do the manual start-stop myself when commuting. There are several points in my commute (if I leave past a certain time) where the light cycle is very long (there's one wacky 5-way intersection in particular) or where it takes multiple cycles to get through (and it is downhill towards the light). I've been doing it for years now and no problems - would only do it with a fuel injected car, though.