We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I'm in the market for a new washer and dryer. I have been focusing more on just the washer as this is the more critical of the two machines. According to Consumer Reports, Whirlpool and Samsung are the top rated machines for Front loaders, and Samsung has the best rating for Top loader. When I read the reviews for any of these machines, the comments are at opposite extremes. All have both glowing and terrible review comments. I'm really stumped what to get - any advice or recent experience would be most appreciated.
i think for washers and dryers you will find reviews good and bad. This was what i noticed. better to select a model that is rated good and take your chances.
I went thru the same pain about 6 months ago and finally bought an L.G. At that time they were highly rated. So far I've been very pleased. I have an L.G. refrigerator and microwave that I'm happy with, so that did influence my decision.
The best price I found was at the big orange box - end of season sale plus 10% for ex military. The installers only made one mistake; they switched the hot and cold lines. I don't know how they ran a test cycle without noticing. Oh, well, it was free installation and they hauled the dead one away, so I didn't complain.
Kenmore. 12 years and counting on washer & dryer. Traditional models. Top-load washer, front dryer. I have YET to hear anything good about the modern versions. Matter of fact, noth'n but bad, bad, bad.
Just had my front loader crap out and needed to buy a new one about 3 weeks ago. Like you, I found it maddening to read reviews of models because they ranged from awful to awesome for every model you consider.
I bought a Frigidaire Affinity (front load washer) set about 5 years ago. Worked well but stopped working recently. Called out a service tech and found the spline or arm that holds the drum level had cracked or was somehow damaged and is basically unrepairable.....cheaper to replace the whole unit. His take is that most front loaders last about 5-6 years before they encounter something too expensive to repair.
I ended up replacing it with the same model hoping that this one will last til the 5-year old dryer finally gives out. I chose the same one mainly because I have the washer/dryer stacked and if I bought something else, I wouldn't be able to stack them.
I can't give you a particular model or brand to consider but it's my opinion that the days of 30-year old washers, refrigerators, and toasters are over. That's not an invitation for anyone to chime in with evidence to the contrary......I just view most appliances/tools under $800-$1000 to be somewhat disposable nowadays. I know how that might sound to some people but with all the electronics and circuits in most appliances now, you could spend $300 to repair one thing to have another $300 problem the following month. I think if you can get 7-10 years out of the average appliance, that's about all you can hope for.
Consumer Reports probably does the most comprehensive testing and I'd probably defer to them for opinions on particular models.
Yes, our Kenmore (Canadian) top-load washer and front-load dryer are at the 18 year mark and still going.
I also have heard nothing good about the new front-load washers other than they look sexy in the store. Save a bit of water, who cares. One service call for fancy modern gizmos will more than wipe out any energy/water or whatever presumed savings you think you are making.
It's not surprising that you encounter opinions tending toward the extremes. That's mostly who takes the time to fill out the review page--people who are very pleased or very PO'd.
I have a Whirlpool Duet that's about two years old now, and it works great. Squeaks briefly while it's trying to set up the counterbalance for the spin cycles, but it's done that from day one, so I suppose that's just its way.
I purchased an LG side by side a few years back. Biggest piece of $1700 piece of crap I ever bought. And LG's customer support is terrible. Had problems from the get go and LG gave me the run around. Finally contacted a consumer reporter at an Orlando TV station. Then they finally sent someone to fix the problem. Lasted 6 months and problem started again. Threatened to get a lawyer and again they did a Mickey Mouse repair. But periodically have the shut the junk down because the air circulation fan ices up.
The fan is directly behind the automatic ice maker. Go figure. Plus the reporter did another story about the LG front loader washer that destroyed the laundry. Don't know the outcome of that story. Home Depot sells LG so that should tell you something about the product.
1. Soap does not clean the clothes it simply breaks water surface tension which allows the agitator to beat the clothes to knock the imbedded stuff out.
2. Contrary to marketing fluff, the primary purpose of the washer is to wring as much of the gray and then the rinse water out of the clothes as possible before hanging or drying.
The key is the motor, the amount of wet clothing it can muscle, and the ability to do it over and over and over again. Look to solid switches and big motor and forget the powder coat and fancy buttons. You used to be able to purchase refurbished HD laundromat front loaders. They were ugly and needed special plumbing, but they ran almost forever when people didn't put painting tarps, tents, and horse blankets in them. They used more power but ran shorter times and used less water to boot. Now mostly they get shipped out of the country because people here are afraid of mold spores collected while out of service. A dollar's worth of bleach for a couple of run throughs will solve the problem but the general public ain't buying it.
About 10 days before Christmas my > 14 y.o. (I purchased it used in 1997) top-loading Whirlpool washer quit. The old top-loaders are a bullet-proof design, so I seriously considered Speed Queen - made in U.S. if that's a consideration. I thought about front-loaders, but my sister hates hers because she can't get rid of the mold/mildew around the door, plus keeping the door open all the time wouldn't work for my situation. I ended up buying a Samsung top-loader because I have always wanted a larger tub. I read some complaints about the agitator-less top-loaders twisting and knotting clothes, and the local salesman I talked to said clothes needed to be rolled up before dropping them in the tub. I haven't found that to be the case with the Samsung...I throw the clothes right in. I'm very happy with it so far.
We had a Frigidaire front loader and dryer that died after about 11 years (kids across the street gave my kids head lice and the daily washing of all the clothes and bedclothes finished off the bearings). We have a Samsung front loader and dryer now - pretty happy with it.
Front loaders seem to be much easier on clothes and get them just as clean, plus the high speed spin cuts way down on drying time (and energy used - both directly by the dryer and heating/cooling make up air)
I replaced my not very old Maytag with a Samsung front loader not more than a few of months ago. So far it is superb. Clothes come out clean and spun nearly dry.
But that isn't my point.
Reading user reviews is maddening for sure and fraught with bias and sampling error not to forget planted fake opinions. 'Professional' reviews simply tell you what the machine [sometimes factory prepped] worked like for the week or so that they played with it.
Disregard anyone who loves their machine made 15-20 years ago. That was when they still made them to last.
Another problem is that whatever the label you are hard pressed to find out who actually made it or made the major components.
The best advice I got was from an independent repair man. He easily checked off a few good makes and several that he loves because they break down a lot. One to avoid is anything made by GE. Can't recall the other good and bad he mentioned.
Another thing to ask about is parts. my LG frig works OK but if something goes wrong there are no regional parts depots so it takes some time to get parts from LA. Ask if there are off-the-shelf parts in your town.
Ours are 8½ years old and running strong. I've had to replace a microswitch on the dryer and the latch on the washer. Both are homeowner DIY tasks, although I had someone in to do the latch, only because it seemed like it was going to be tougher than it actually was. Mainly the things run and run and run, just like they're supposed to. They're reasonably quiet and very effective.
Our daughter bought a set about six years ago, and with three kids, they take a more than daily beating. So far no problems. They've also relocated three times in that period, so both units have been subject to moving stresses. They bought a set of stabilizing bolts for the washer the first time they moved them—not cheap, but they've now reused them twice.
Our son just took delivery of a Duet washer, as did a friend. The jury is obviously still out on them, of course.
Someone mentioned that you can't depend on reviews from a long time ago. Amen. We had a pair of Maytags (top loading washer) that we put in our house in 1978. They ran in arduous (family of four) use for more than twenty years with one heating element for the dryer replaced, and one routine maintenance set of parts for the washer. So far as I know, ten more years later, they're still there. I know I wouldn't have confidence of that kind of performance were we to buy Maytags today, because they're not made here anymore and industrial design philosophy has shifted from "bulletproof" to "good enough". Doesn't mean they're automatically junk, but "they don't build 'em like they used to."
If you do the front loader, get the pedestals. We have them for both, daughter just has one for the washer. I noticed when our son ordered his that they're up $100 from when we bought ours (now about $250).
My experience is different. My old top loader/dryer combo were very hard on my clothes. One or two trips through those machines and you could see the wear and tear. I think the wear may have been mostly caused by the dryer, made worse because the top loader spin cycle left the clothes sopping wet.
I replaced them with a Bosch front loader and dryer 6 years ago and - what an improvement. Clothes come out of the washer's spin cycle almost dry. The dryer uses lower temperature but higher air volume. Wear and tear and fading of the clothes is hugely reduced. Water and power consumption must be a lot lower, but the utility cost savings are not huge. Biggest improvement is reduced clothing wear and tear.
Ps. My Bosch machines have been flawless. Mine are installed on a solid, concrete floor. I have two young kids and the machines work hard.
After hearing my glowing reviews my Mom bought identical machines about 6 months after me. Her machines are installed on a second floor (wood floor supported by joists). Her machines have been less reliable. First the washer walks around. When it bumps up against the dryer during the spin cycle, the plastic cowlings/control panels are damaged. Her washer door seals have failed and a washer bearing is bad and squeals like the guy in Deliverance.
Our Kenmore washer is 23 years old and has zero issues. I dread having to replace it. (Of course, now that I'm stated out loud that it has zero issues, it's guaranteed to develop a few.)
I'm still using the same Maytag (top loading washer) I bought in 1973. Never a problem, in all these years... well that's not entirely true, the markings on the dial have worn off and I etched with a scratch awl where the cycles start. It probably uses 50 gallons of water per wash compared to the machines of today, but I wouldn't trade it for anything... they just don't make them like that anymore. ok, well, yeah, now that I gushed about it watch it explode and catch fire tomorrow!
"Design News" a trade publication for design engineers, there is an article in January 2012, "Made By Monkeys", p 18. In it it states that Front Loaders are much less reliable. The trouble spots are in the spider and assembly that cracks more often than it should. This item and its related parts and repair can total $1000. The new warranty for most newer machines is 1 year (which the article states is practically useless) and not ten years as they used to be. Finally a warranty is $140 or about 1/10 the cost of a new machine. Quote from the article.: "Front loaders have another issue: the repeated on/off hard cycling of the fill valve procures tremendous water hammer, which is both loud and can cause pipes (both old and new) to develop micro-cracks due to repeated motion...the solution is a water hammer arrestor on each fill line - if you know to do it. If not, you'll have leaking pipes and joints, or else a major leak in a few years."
Read the warranty information no matter what you purchase.
This is a New Zealand company. Until an ex-wife got one and raved about it, I'd never heard of Fisher & Paykel. The wash tub is directly connected to a stepper motor that's micro computer controlled. Because it's a stepper motor, it can be rotated in either direction in pretty small steps and the spin cycle can go up to almost 1000 rpms. Clothes come out almost dry - which saves drying time.
Neat features
auto water level adjustment
- the unit adds water, tries to aggitate the clothes and a feedback processes senses if there's enough water. If not it adds some more water and checks again. If there's enough water the wash cycle begins - using just enough to do the load.
delayed washing option
- utility companies are starting to charge more for peak periods and less for off peak periods. This unit can delay washing a load for 1,3 or 9 hours
unbalanced load adjustment
- before spinning dry, it can sense an imbalance. The unit adds some water, aggitates to shift things around and tries again. Usually that will get the load balanced. But after enough tries, the unit will let you know there's a problem you need to deal with. No more Washer Walking!
smaller footprint than regular washers
- because of its self load balancing before spinning, the unit doesn't need much room between the wash barrel and the sides of the unit. Two to three less inches in width doesn't sound like much, but when space is tight . . .
auto back flush feature
- after each drain cycle, the unit does a little back flushing so lint doesn't build up in valves.
A bit more expensive - up front - but pretty bullet proof. Mine had only one minor problem - that was fixed the same day, for about $50 for the service call.
For dryers, natural gas is much less expensive to run than electricity - at least here in California. Having a moisture sensor to determine how long the dryer must run to dry your clothes is much better than drying by a guess at time.
We had an old Maytag we had for abt 18 yrs. The tub support finally rusted out among other things so I got rid of it. First mistake. I said I had such luck with it Id get another Mayatag. Second BIG mistake. What a piece of...junk. It didnt last 2 yrs.One thing after another. Got an LG from "that store". Top loader that is. Problems with side loader Ive heard. Ive lo0ked at the washing sequence thru the glass top. For the life of me I cant see how it gets clothes clean but it does. Almost no water it seems but so far it does OK.Ive heard Bosh is a good one but no involvement there.
We ran across these machines while in Australia on vacation. Built like a tank and very good at what they do. The company also makes really inventive dishwashers which can have two slide out drawers for smaller loads. I haven't seen a lot of these locally, but I'm sure they're available.
Just from observation, not being an engineer, I'd put them in the same category as Bosch; pricey, but worth the money in the long run.