KOA WOOD
SUSAN
HOW CAN I TELL IF AN ITEM IS MADE OF KOA WOOD?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
KOA WOOD
SUSAN
HOW CAN I TELL IF AN ITEM IS MADE OF KOA WOOD?
Re: KOA WOOD
Ellis Walentine
Post a photo of it.
Ellis Walentine, Host
Does it look like any of these ?
Yonak
SUSAN, check out these pics of Koas and judge for yourself.
http://www.rarewoodsandveneers.com/images/productimages/veneers/koa.jpg
Koa
http://www.rarewoodsandveneers.com/images/productimages/veneers/figured%20koa.jpg
Figured Koa
http://www.rarewoodsandveneers.com/images/productimages/rarewood/Acacia%20koa,%20Koa,%20Hawaii4.jpg
Acacia Koa
Formosan Koa
My correspondence with her...
Ellis Walentine
Susan sent me some pictures of the wood in question because she couldn't post them since she is unregistered. I got back to her telling her that the wood is almost certainly cocobolo. I saw lots of tourist-grade carvings in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, that looked almost identical to this turtle. Koa, of course, looks nothing like this.
Ellis

Re: My correspondence with her...
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
Ellis,
"Carvings" like that used to be pretty common Tijuana tourist items. They were advertised as 'Desert Ironwood' back the - like maybe 20 years ago.
Re: My correspondence with her...
John McGaw
If the carving is indeed 'desert ironwood' (Olneya tesota) then the best diagnostics would not be the surface appearance, especially when that might have changed due to age or dye, but the density and odor and 'oiliness'. Olneya is about 20% more dense than Dalbergia but telling the difference could be tricky since the should both sink rather than float in water. The odor on the other hand is quite distinct between the two and any sort of abrasion will tell the tale with Oneya being rather foul smelling and Dalbergia being quite floral.. Dalbergia is also quite oily and IIRC Olneya isn't.